Bay 1 Ice Cream & Sandwich Shop

19713A Gulf Blvd, Indian Shores
(727) 595-2291

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

2 Scoop Waffle Cone
Ice Cream Cones
Butter Pecan
Hot Dog

Menu

Savory Sandwiches
9" Pressed Authentic Cuban Sandwich
Authentically made Cuban sandwich. savory pulled pork, smoked ham, salami, Swiss cheese and pickle, covering freshly baked Cuban bread pressed to perfection. Sandwich comes with mayo, mustard, and pickle unless told otherwise.
9" Pressed Cuban Pulled Pork Sandwich
Savory pulled pork covering authentic Cuban bread pressed to perfection. Sandwich comes with mayo, mustard, and pickle unless told otherwise.
9" Pressed Cuban Reuben Pulled Pork Sandwich
Savory pulled pork, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing, covering freshly baked Cuban bread pressed to perfection. Sandwich comes with mayo and mustard unless told otherwise.

Old Fashioned Premium Ice Cream
The Little Dipper
Delicious Yoder's premium ice cream. Pick up to 2 flavors.
The Big Dipper
Delicious Yoder's premium ice cream. Pick up to 3 flavors.
Pint Ice Cream
Your choice of one of our premium flavors.
Couples Pint Ice Cream
Discounted pricing for two pints. Your choice of one of our premium flavors per pint.
It's a Party Trifecta Pint Ice Cream
Discounted pricing for three pints. Your choice of one of our premium flavors per pint.

Shake It Up
20 oz. Shakes
20 oz. Malts
20 oz. Root Beer Float
20 oz. Coke Float
20 oz. Diet Coke Float

Quenchers
12 oz. A&W Root Bear
20 oz. Soda
Bottle of Water

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+60 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+59 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Bomb ice cream and the two servers Gav and Alex were awesome and busting tail so fast. I’d give five starts but it is SO SO HOT inside. I couldn’t stay and hang out I had to leave. Will come back but fix AC please
June 2026
We stopped by this quaint little ice cream shop today and absolutely loved it! I tried the blueberry-lemon ice cream, and it exceeded all expectations. The flavor was fresh and delicious, with small pieces of blueberry and swirls of lemon curd that made every bite even better. Such a charming spot with amazing homemade flavors — we’ll definitely be back!
May 2026
I ordered 9 cuban sandwiches today, they prepared them quickly & they were delicious! Everyone loved them including 3 who were Cuban. Great service, great choices! AND they had 4 choices of dairy free ice cream!(on top of their many choices of regular). Awesome place right by the beach!
April 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

DJs Clam Shack Indian Shores - 19705 Gulf Blvd Ste A
Seafood, Fast Food, Beer Bar
Caddy's Indian Shores - 20025 Gulf Blvd
Pubs, Seafood, Pet Friendly, Vegan
Salt Rock Grill - 19325 Gulf Blvd
Seafood, American, New American, Vegan, Vegetarian

Bay 1 Ice Cream & Sandwich Shop

19713A Gulf Blvd, Indian Shores, FL 33785
(727) 595-2291