Atlantic's Edge Restaurant

We love coming to the Atlantic Edge for lunch. Maybe not a 5 star experience but a solid 4.5 star. We'll definitely come back again.

Very mediocre food for a lot of money , it says I have to type more to be able to leave this review

We dined outside in a beautiful setting with a view of the beach and water. The ambiance was very nice listening to the guitar player while we enjoyed our meal.

Great raw oysters, and incredible atmosphere. Loved the vibe. Our meals were fabulous, and the servers were friendly and helpful. On the beach is a huge plus for us.

Amazing place to enjoy breakfast and the sunset! And the staff was very fast and helpful. I would totally go back next time I am in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food was really mediocre at best. Filet was served cold, salad was meh. Service was great but definitely not worth the price. We were there for NYE so maybe they were a bit overwhelmed but the Prix fixe is generally expected to be on point.

Although the food was rather delightful I have a very serious complaint. I ordered a croque madame how ever I received a croque monsieur. For the unaware, a croque madame only has one piece of bread, and open face sandwich. The croque monsieur has two pieces of bread. Please remove one piece of bread or change the name on the menu. Thank you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Amazing food on Christmas night. Beautiful atmosphere and amazing staff! A wonderful night

Food was authentic well plated and fresh! Delish! The wings were flavorful, the burger was full of flavor! The hummus was like no other I've had with perfect blend of flavor and texture. The atmosphere was so comfy and inviting! The views are impeccable. The staff was super friendly and accommodating . Little pricy but you get quality everything for us that was not a problem .

I visited this restaurant on Christmas and the experience was extremely disappointing. The food was far below expectations. The chicken was poorly prepared and completely unseasoned, and the filet appeared to be old, with an unpleasant taste and texture.

On top of that, the drinks were poorly balanced, with far too much ice and very little alcohol, which felt like an attempt to cut costs. Considering the date, the prices, and the restaurant’s positioning, the overall experience was very negative. Unfortunately, I cannot recommend it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ambiance and setting is great. The rest not so great. Service was really poor, overall value for money not good as very expensive versus quality of food offered. No signs of any leadership also added to service issues. Shame as setting is lovely.

Thursday November 13. No one in the restaurant, we arrive with a party of 19. have been waiting for nearly an hour for the food. It is also freezing cold and they cannot adjust the ac so they gave us a bunch of towels to put over our shoulders to try to warm up. totally overpriced as well. Waitress was great, but couldn’t do anything to help us. Won’t be back.

A MUST! Not only is the resort beautiful but so is the food and open waterfront dining. We tried the shrimp burger, AMAZING! The key lime pie is a tart so that should be correctly stated, flavorful nonetheless. If nothing else, stop for a nice walk about the grounds right on the beach, and spend a bit of time decompressing at this lovely little restaurant, where the service, food, and atmosphere do not disappoint.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wow, what an amazing spot! The food was absolutely delicious — super fresh local fish and tasty guac. You can really tell everything's made with care. And the crepes with ricotta cheese and berries... seriously to die for! The place has such a great vibe — an upscale casual resort feel with old Southern charm, open-air seating, ocean views, and the smell of tropical flowers in the breeze. Just perfect. The service was friendly, fast, and on point. Can't wait to come back! Highly recommend this place to anyone looking for great food and a relaxed coastal atmosphere.

Beautiful eating outside with the ocean sounds close by and delicious food and great service! Highly recommend in Islamorada for a special evening out or just a casual keys dining experience!