Atlantic's Edge Restaurant

Beautiful eating outside with the ocean sounds close by and delicious food and great service! Highly recommend in Islamorada for a special evening out or just a casual keys dining experience!

The hostess at the host stand were very rude and smelled like marijuana. I asked to be sat away from the live music and they said they could not accommodate me when there was only one other party sitting at a table in the whole restaurant and their reasoning was that the table they wanted to sit me at was the only table available ... make it make sense. Later, the hosts were loudly speaking natively about my husband and I? The waitress was kind but the hostess made the experience terrible and we left after an appetizer.

Food and atmosphere were fantastic! Service was ok. Felt a little abandoned at times. Ate on the garden level. Two hour dinner but we weren't in a hurry.

Absolutely wonderful! Friendly staff super accommodating. The most delicious key lime pie ever :)

Dined twice during our 6-night stay in Islamorada. Our first experience was so good, we returned! However, the same meal prepared on the second night wasn't comparable to the first. We had the Seafood Medley both nights. The first night the sauce was creamy and abundant. The second night it was separated and scarce. The ambiance is romantic. I would return.

We went here with a group of 9 for my daughter's 30th birthday. We had a lovely table outside, but that is unfortunately the only good thing we had. Service was extremely slow - 45 minutes to receive our first round of drinks (and the restaurant was NOT busy, it was 6:00 pm) and to order. Then another 45 minutes for the second drink - after 1 1/2 hours we had bread and a 2 cocktails. Once the food arrived, it was subpar at best. $65 for a stuffed lobster that was dry and tasted old. My grilled whole fish had some type of weird breading on it, as if it were meant to be fried and they threw it on the grill instead. The rice in the lobster curry was crunchy.... It was Terrible. Then we clashed with Management over the bill, finally being told the General Manager was not there and the person we were dealing with did not have the ability to comp the check. WHAT? Where was management? We ended up paying for 1/2 and will never return. Such a disappointment. Go for the view, skip the food.

I booked reservations for the harvest moon dinner, and to stay at your house the harvest moon dinner was canceled, and I was not made aware of that. My steak was overcooked so is mushroom and the person I was with hot fish and it was very dry. Service was very slow and non-attentive.

Very disappointed in Atlantics Edge change in menu. Used to be ok, now nothing is good, bad variety in choice, low quality food, so cheap for a nice place on the water. New management , sorry you are not doing a good job

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

We were staying at Cheeca lodge and have eaten here before so we were expecting great. That's not what we got. Service was weak and the server didn't know much about the menu ( how many items came with apps, whether sides could be substituted ). Everything was very slow. We sat in front of a wine display which had dirty streaks running on the glass from floor to ceiling. The medium steak was raw. When sent back, it looked pan fried to cook the rest of the way. The lobster special was good. Desserts were bland. Very disappointing

Great hotel restaurant! Views are spectacular and the wildlife is an added bonus!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

What and exceptional meal. Our server was possibly the sweetest human we gave met on our vacation. The staff is so courteous and professional. Our meal was a special treat and we were given top star service. The meal itself was a showstopper. Our daughter is a picky eater and was treated with such care. The Mahi Mahi is absolutely one of the most exquisite dishes. I was able to pair it with a side reserved for the specials (coconut rice) and honestly it should be served as such. My husband got a rib and shrimp meal and loved every bite. Our desserts were equally incredible. If you want a family friendly meal (that's a treat) you HAVE to check out Atlantics edge.

Had the English Peas with Prosciutto, had no dressing so it was bland. Had Mussels in a yellow butter sauce also bland.

We dined inside and the overall atmosphere was nice. The food was bland overall. One thing to note is that you need to order sides separately so all of the entrée prices are just for the main and then sides are additional.
One person in our group ordered a filet mignon, medium, and it came out well done, so we then waited for another one to be cooked to medium, which took about 15 minutes for a second one to come out and then that one was cooked rare so then we waited for a third filet mignon to be cooked to medium and was finally complete and waited 35 to 40 minutes since the first one came out. They clearly did not prioritize re-cooking this meal and more importantly there was no concessions for this. No manager came by and they did not do anything for us. The server did apologize but that was it.
The only thing that might be worth getting is the salads or burgers which we’re not overpriced and we’re full meals.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

Great place..Ours grandkids loved to see all the 🐟 🐠 🎣

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Definitely a top notch dining experience~great menu, very good service, amazing dining room, views, etc...wine menu was good but could use more selections by the bottle. This is a first class experience.