Bayside Gourmet
82758 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada
(305) 735-4471
Customers' Favorites
Grouper Reuben Sandwich
Lobster Bisque Soup
Saltimbocca Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
The Works Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Lobster Bisque
Hawaiian Pizza
Spicy Fish Taco
Veggie Pizza
Menu
Photos
+55 photos
+54 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Whenever we visit Islamorada, this iconic and traditional place becomes a must-stop. The warm service and the culinary offerings stand out for their freshness and variety: from artisanal pizzas and pastas to vibrant salads and flavorful sandwiches. Each dish reflects quality and dedication, making the experience a constant delight for the senses.
Stopped by here with the family during our August vacation in the Keys. The food was excellent and they had plenty of flash back items all around to look at, like old arcade games, record albums and movie memorabilia. The service however left much to be desired, as we got our own sodas out of the cooIer and I understand helping out each other, but a different waitress and the busboy brought our food and for the price of the entrees the side salad should come with it. Also, a small...
We brought our fresh caught Mahi and black fin tuna here and they cooked it perfect! The staff were very prompt in service and bussing the plates off the table. The place is very clean. It’s a hidden gem in my opinion! We ended up coming back a second night and eating off the menu, my husband said the key lime seafood pasta was the best meal he has eaten on our whole trip from Pompano to Key West and it was his birthday trip so we ate at great spots. They key lime pie is delicious...
You May Also Like
Italian Food Company - 82779 Overseas Hwy
![]()
Italian, Gluten-Free
The Whistle Stop Pub - 82685 Overseas Hwy
![]()
Pubs, American, Dive Bar, Vegetarian