Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar
96 Madeira Rd, Islamorada
(305) 664-2692
Customers' Favorites
Lorelei World Famous Madeira Bay Fish Sandwich
Frozen Key Lime Pie with Mango Sauce
Peppercorn Crusted Yellowfin Tuna
Alaskan Snow Crab Platter
Tropical Coconut Shrimp
Bayside Grilled Chiken
Sunset Conch Fritters
Captain's Quesadilla
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Stone Crab Chowder
Menu
Photos
+83 photos
+82 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We LOVE Lorelei’s! We stayed in Key Largo for about a week and during that week, I think we went to Islamorada and ate there 4 times. The atmosphere is wonderful- it’s welcoming and feels like a local’s joint. Their food was very good - we had lunch, dinner, and breakfast there and the breakfast is really affordable too! It just felt homey and beautiful at the same time, and we couldn’t have enjoyed it more.
The vibes were immaculate but the food was cheap bar food. I can say that the location is beautiful and the staff was friendly and kind. Unfortunately the menu fell flat and was very overpriced for what you are getting, with the only saving grace being the Frozen Key Lime Pie which was pretty good. I would probably only return for happy hour to drink in the future. Don’t bother eating here
Obsessed with this place. First time was on a rainy day, second time the weather was perfect. Both times were incredible experiences. I highly recommend getting a slice of their frozen key lime pie! And the key lime pie colada is so refreshing. Sitting by the water, watching the boats is such a vibe. Very friendly atmosphere among patrons. Plenty of parking and seating area.
You May Also Like
Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream - 81933 Overseas Hwy
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream
Islamorada Shrimp Shack - 81901 Overseas Hwy
![]()
Seafood, Gluten-Free, Vegan, Vegetarian