Stone Oven Pizzeria - The Whistle Stop
82685 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada
(305) 664-1404
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Cordon Blue
Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Fingers
Philly Pizza
Garlic Knots
BBQ Chicken
Menu
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Hands down this is one of the best pizza joints we’ve EVER been to. My husband and I ordered a large meats to split. Every piece was piled with toppings. Marley took our order and he was super friendly and attentive. We will 100% be back when we’re in town again!
I am a 49-year-old Texas woman. I have eaten pizza at probably hundreds of pizza franchises as well as family owned, small pizzerias in my life. In July 2025, my family of five ate at this restaurant and fought over the enormous pizzas that we ordered. We all admitted that we weren’t even that hungry, but we just could not get enough! We all agree that it is the best pizza we have ever eaten and I will admit that I’m a bit depressed knowing that I will likely never get to...
The food was ok. We ordered a meatball sub and garlic knots. The meatball sub was pretty dry and had very little marinara sauce. However, the garlic knots were very delicious. I wish the food had come out closer together, instead of twenty minutes apart.
The workers were very kind and had excellent service.
The workers were very kind and had excellent service.
You May Also Like
The Whistle Stop Pub - 82685 Overseas Hwy
![]()
Pubs, American, Dive Bar, Vegetarian
Taki Outi - 82685 Overseas Hwy A
![]()
Chinese
Bitton Bistro Cafe - 82245 Overseas Hwy
![]()
Bistros, Creperies, French, Bakery, Gluten-Free