Blue Boy Sandwich Shop

The cheeseburger isn't as good as it used to be, but it's still good nonetheless ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Steak, Fries, Burger, Sub

Very rude and dismissive to third party delivery drivers and horrible parking lot.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

My husband's been coming here for 30 years we decided to bring our grandson , he loves it so we are going back again.
We drive from orange park just to have Blue Boys . Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

portion size was huge takes to people to eat there sandwich staff was ok the service was a little slow will return ? probably .

Parking: parking very small not to much to move around or turn around in

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

The best club ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First, let me say, the food here is great, but it is the service that gets the 2 stars. Prior to covid, ordering from here was easy. But be warned if you are using grub hub or uber eats. If you order add ons, they won't do it and they take no responsibility for it. We have order 8 times in the last 3 months and each time the order has been wrong. Either wrong sandwich, wrong customs, adding pepper sauce when ordered no pepper sauce, or even item is not available. One driver was told let them fix it on the app, it isn't our problem. We'll, we have removed them from our regular order locations. It is a shame since the food is good, but we are not going to waste time when other restaurants will take ownership to handle issues.

08/15 update:
So we tried again. 3 orders in the last month. All three orders were wrong. 1st order was 2 sandwiches, one not delivered and had to request a refund through grubhub. Next order, ordered hot sandwiches, delivered cold with the extras paid for, fried oreos were cold and very greasy, we could hold up the oreo and it dripped. Today, we ordered 2 biscuits and a large sub for our dunch later. We were called by the restaurant and told no biscuits, so we're requested to cancel full order. They said to do it ourselves. We did not have the option in the app yet. Called them back. Person who answered was rude. When we asked for a manager she hung up on us. same for the 2nd call. No help. This is not that New York deli that is famous for being rude. This is the south, where we treat each other with respect. We were very grateful for the initial call, but now we are done. Removed from favorite list and will no longer suggest it to anyone, not even my worst enemy.

Service: 1

I have loved Blue Boy for 13 years. My husband discovered it as soon as we moved to Jax and it has become a family tradition to treat ourselves with a Blue Boy, specifically the meatloaf Blue Boy, several times a year.

Not sure what has happened. I think it's under new ownership, but it's not the same and not better. Apart from the meatloaf being less generous (though the taste is amazing and tastes like the same recipe), there is a change in the bread that changes the experience of eating a meatloaf Blue Boy. They used to make their own sourdough bread and lightly toasted it. The sourdough is more airy and doesn't get soggy in the same way as the white bread they're using now. This new white bread is a lot more dense, so when it gets soggy it is a densely soggy white bread that decreases the taste ratio of meatloaf vs bread, and makes the bread more dominant. It also doesn't mix the same way while you're chewing because the bread is so dense.

I really hope they go back to making and using sourdough bread. It really is the signature of a Blue Boy. It's just not as enjoyable with hyper-dense white bread, especially with the expected increase in cost.

My husband said everything else seemed the same as far as atmosphere and service. Just average and not unpleasant, as has been my experience. We always take it to go. Glad to see it is open longer hours!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Ordered takeout first time here today. Had burger sandwich. Very good and huge portion. Sandwich cut into four large pieces. Loved the bread.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It's just lost it all...good service, good food...etc...all has went down hill

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

I didn’t go in, ordered out.
Their sandwiches are pretty good. And they are huge. Make sure you’re hungry before you go. lol

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Cuban Sandwich, Steak Sandwich

Today was my first time here and I’m actually very disappointed. I ordered a mini super club and I am not too sure what this is. It’s SO MUCH BREAD. I did not expect this and I also asked what’s a good, popular sandwich to choose as today was my first time here. I can’t believe I spent $17 for bread. I could’ve made a club sandwich at home had I known I was getting so much bread. This is just not healthy for anyone to eat this much bread. I had to take the bread off and the rest of the sand which went in the trash. I don’t think I’ll be back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Absolutely delicious ?

This is the dollar general of sandwich shops with high prices....the owner is trolling reviews because they know bologna sandwiches are better than the mystery meat they serve

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

I had the Puerto Rican Tripleta and it is huge. Going in for the first time I thought $15.00 for a sandwich was a little expensive, but when it's the size of 2 footlongs it's a bargain !! The ladies working could have not been any nicer !! And seemed genuinely happy to serve us. Definitely going back when I come back to town !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Puerto Rican Tripleta

This place right here is dirty and the owner is very rude and nasty just like the sandwich shop. I would not recommend any one to eat from this place.