Delicious as always. We had the Arancini's, Creamy Chicken Pesto and the Pear Fiocchi. I took my family for the first time they enjoyed every bite. Service was fast as well
I want to clarify my 4 star rating: the food is 10/10 insanely delicious, the service was friendly, energetic and thoughtful. The only reason I did not rate 5/5 was the wait and the size of the place. Hardly any room when I was there and the wait was 45 minutes. However, it's worth every minute and any inconvenience of space! I ordered the pear and prosciutto ravioli....I can't, I just can't, it was so very delicious. I also ordered the classic chicken in white sauce pasta ? ? ?. My attendant was helpful, attentive despite the cramped space. I had a wonderful time with my best friend, we caught up on our lives and enjoyed every bite. I've been to Catullo's more than once and I've always enjoyed it. Oh BTW they have first come first serve only, they do not accept reservations. On the bright side, lots of parking and the parking is FREE.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creamy Chicken Pesto
Peter Bottini
The food was authentic, service was great, and if I closed my eyes, it felt like I was in Little Italy in Manhattan. Tasted like home. Limoncello cake was divine.
Place has a line of 10+ people waiting for it open every single day for a reason.u go for the food.the servers are A+
Olivia Harris
This place is excellent! The servers were very knowledgeable about the menu and specials. I had the Pear Fiocchi - they offered to make it spicy which I delightfully accepted! To say it was good is an understatement. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vincent Andrew
This is the kind of place that makes you forget that you're in Jacksonville...in the best way possible! Catullo's is unassuming on the outside, but as soon as you step foot in the door you know the pasta is gonna be amazing. The atmosphere reminds me of some small family places in Chicago or NYC. A few tables, bustling conversations, and always packed. Sitting at the bar is the most fun you're going to have anyway. The staff are engaging, funny, and give great recommendations. Their rotating pasta specials range from creative to regional Italian dishes I haven't seen stateside. Definitely keeping it interesting, and their staples are exceptional as well. I would say this is THE best pasta in Jax. If you're not feeling the dine-in I saw several people grabbing take out so don't sleep on this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Axxley
Small cozy restaurant with good eats and good service.We enjoyed all our food specially the shrimprosata (we made it spicy and added pancetta per the server’s recommendation).The restaurant is small so there is a line that forms about 30 minutes prior to opening. If opening time is too early for your dinner, I recommend coming at least 1hr 15min after opening when some of the tables from the first round of diners begin to clear out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Lanier
You shouldn't be in the "Hospitality Business" if hospitality isn't your passion. The Catullo Brothers, however, were apparently born for this! From receiving the hostess's friendly smile as we walked in, to Caitlyn's sincere "y'all come back soon" as we left, we felt at home and were doted on by family. Caitlyn, our waitress, knew the menu backwards and forwards and was not shy when we asked for advice. She recommended our appetizer and directed us in customizing our entrees and it could not have been more perfect! The atmosphere was fun and vibrant..basically it was authentically Italian! Glasses were filled before you could ask, dishes timely delivered and removed and every face defaulted to a sincere smile! Get dessert, too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Styron
We chose Catullos for dinner to celebrate our 48th anniversary. We knew their would be a bit of a wait at dinnertime because the secret is out. This is a small restaurant but the food, service, and quaint atmosphere are top notch. Our wait to be seated was a little over 30 minutes on a Thursday evening and our waitress, Misty, was very friendly and efficient. AJ, as always, made sure to come to our table to ensure our satisfaction and needs were being met. He congratulated us and he has a very outgoing and friendly personality. He never meets a stranger. We chose the Porcini Mushroom Tortillon and the limoncello mascarpone cake for dessert and it was something that we can highly recommend. Their portions and preparation are consistently excellent. If you are looking for a small venue with authentic cuisine that is consistently very good, with a cozy atmosphere, I highly recommend that you give them a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Limoncello Mascarpone Cake
Penny Janeway
We were so impressed by this restaurant the food is outstanding, and the service was fantastic. We will be back many times to come, highly recommend.Parking: It is in a strip mall tons of parking
It's very had to describe an experience like this without sounding like a broken record. From the moment you walk through the door the attention to detail shines bright like a diamond ?. My sister flew in to surprise me for her birthday and I knew immediately where to take her. You know that feeling you get inside when you hype up your favorite restaurant and deep down your hoping to not experience an "off night" after all the build up ? Yeah I never have that feeling when I'm going to Catullos. The food always and I mean always speaks that certain love language that can't be described only tasted and experienced.Our server AJ seemed to know exactly what we wanted , exactly what was needed and honestly seemed as though he was a family member by the time we parted ways. A+ ,10/10 , 5 Stars however you want to rate it , this is how the hospitality industry is done.Thank you Catullos for a great night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gary Spingarn
A shining example of what a restaurant can be. It's clear the entire staff takes great pride in everything they do. The best there is, period.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rick Genest
This is one of my daughter’s favorite restaurants. She asked to celebrate her birthday here and this would also be my first time dining at Catullo. Well I quickly learned why my daughter loves this place. From the moment we entered the restaurant I was absolutely amazed! We let the manager (maybe the owner) that we were celebrating a birthday. He went out of his way to ensure it was a special night to include a champagne toast with the staff! The service was outstanding! Along with that the food was outstanding! We all loved our dishes and even shared. Don’t be turned off at its location or the smaller size restaurant. If there is a wait……..then wait! I assure you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michele Knox
The food was delicious and the service was extraordinary!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Fra Diavolo, Arancini
Lori Rigotti
As good as food found on Arthur Ave in the Bronx -back in the day ! I always try the meatballs -they have Italian food figured out . Pasta is cooked al dente ,
Delicious as always. We had the Arancini's, Creamy Chicken Pesto and the Pear Fiocchi. I took my family for the first time they enjoyed every bite. Service was fast as well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Arancini, Creamy Chicken Pesto
I want to clarify my 4 star rating: the food is 10/10 insanely delicious, the service was friendly, energetic and thoughtful. The only reason I did not rate 5/5 was the wait and the size of the place. Hardly any room when I was there and the wait was 45 minutes. However, it's worth every minute and any inconvenience of space! I ordered the pear and prosciutto ravioli....I can't, I just can't, it was so very delicious. I also ordered the classic chicken in white sauce pasta ? ? ?. My attendant was helpful, attentive despite the cramped space. I had a wonderful time with my best friend, we caught up on our lives and enjoyed every bite. I've been to Catullo's more than once and I've always enjoyed it. Oh BTW they have first come first serve only, they do not accept reservations. On the bright side, lots of parking and the parking is FREE.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creamy Chicken Pesto
The food was authentic, service was great, and if I closed my eyes, it felt like I was in Little Italy in Manhattan. Tasted like home. Limoncello cake was divine.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Arancini, Limoncello Mascarpone Cake
Place has a line of 10+ people waiting for it open every single day for a reason.u go for the food.the servers are A+
This place is excellent! The servers were very knowledgeable about the menu and specials. I had the Pear Fiocchi - they offered to make it spicy which I delightfully accepted! To say it was good is an understatement. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the kind of place that makes you forget that you're in Jacksonville...in the best way possible! Catullo's is unassuming on the outside, but as soon as you step foot in the door you know the pasta is gonna be amazing. The atmosphere reminds me of some small family places in Chicago or NYC. A few tables, bustling conversations, and always packed. Sitting at the bar is the most fun you're going to have anyway. The staff are engaging, funny, and give great recommendations. Their rotating pasta specials range from creative to regional Italian dishes I haven't seen stateside. Definitely keeping it interesting, and their staples are exceptional as well. I would say this is THE best pasta in Jax. If you're not feeling the dine-in I saw several people grabbing take out so don't sleep on this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Small cozy restaurant with good eats and good service.We enjoyed all our food specially the shrimprosata (we made it spicy and added pancetta per the server’s recommendation).The restaurant is small so there is a line that forms about 30 minutes prior to opening. If opening time is too early for your dinner, I recommend coming at least 1hr 15min after opening when some of the tables from the first round of diners begin to clear out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You shouldn't be in the "Hospitality Business" if hospitality isn't your passion. The Catullo Brothers, however, were apparently born for this! From receiving the hostess's friendly smile as we walked in, to Caitlyn's sincere "y'all come back soon" as we left, we felt at home and were doted on by family. Caitlyn, our waitress, knew the menu backwards and forwards and was not shy when we asked for advice. She recommended our appetizer and directed us in customizing our entrees and it could not have been more perfect! The atmosphere was fun and vibrant..basically it was authentically Italian! Glasses were filled before you could ask, dishes timely delivered and removed and every face defaulted to a sincere smile! Get dessert, too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We chose Catullos for dinner to celebrate our 48th anniversary. We knew their would be a bit of a wait at dinnertime because the secret is out. This is a small restaurant but the food, service, and quaint atmosphere are top notch. Our wait to be seated was a little over 30 minutes on a Thursday evening and our waitress, Misty, was very friendly and efficient. AJ, as always, made sure to come to our table to ensure our satisfaction and needs were being met. He congratulated us and he has a very outgoing and friendly personality. He never meets a stranger. We chose the Porcini Mushroom Tortillon and the limoncello mascarpone cake for dessert and it was something that we can highly recommend. Their portions and preparation are consistently excellent. If you are looking for a small venue with authentic cuisine that is consistently very good, with a cozy atmosphere, I highly recommend that you give them a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Limoncello Mascarpone Cake
We were so impressed by this restaurant the food is outstanding, and the service was fantastic. We will be back many times to come, highly recommend.Parking: It is in a strip mall tons of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
It's very had to describe an experience like this without sounding like a broken record. From the moment you walk through the door the attention to detail shines bright like a diamond ?. My sister flew in to surprise me for her birthday and I knew immediately where to take her. You know that feeling you get inside when you hype up your favorite restaurant and deep down your hoping to not experience an "off night" after all the build up ? Yeah I never have that feeling when I'm going to Catullos. The food always and I mean always speaks that certain love language that can't be described only tasted and experienced.Our server AJ seemed to know exactly what we wanted , exactly what was needed and honestly seemed as though he was a family member by the time we parted ways. A+ ,10/10 , 5 Stars however you want to rate it , this is how the hospitality industry is done.Thank you Catullos for a great night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A shining example of what a restaurant can be. It's clear the entire staff takes great pride in everything they do. The best there is, period.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is one of my daughter’s favorite restaurants. She asked to celebrate her birthday here and this would also be my first time dining at Catullo. Well I quickly learned why my daughter loves this place. From the moment we entered the restaurant I was absolutely amazed! We let the manager (maybe the owner) that we were celebrating a birthday. He went out of his way to ensure it was a special night to include a champagne toast with the staff! The service was outstanding! Along with that the food was outstanding! We all loved our dishes and even shared. Don’t be turned off at its location or the smaller size restaurant. If there is a wait……..then wait! I assure you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was delicious and the service was extraordinary!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Fra Diavolo, Arancini
As good as food found on Arthur Ave in the Bronx -back in the day ! I always try the meatballs -they have Italian food figured out . Pasta is cooked al dente ,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5