Five Star Pizza

Cant say enough about this store and its pizza. Five Star Pizza lives up to its name every time we order! The store manager, Max, is extremely kind and helpful when it comes to placing large orders for UNF. We use this location for all of our campus and student organization events, and each order comes out perfect. We have quite literally never had an issue or mistake with them, and I couldn't be more thankful. Max's team and the delivery drivers go above and beyond to make sure it's local customers down the street at UNF receive quality food and service on every order. I cant say enough good things about this Five Star store!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you like sauce with a bite, you'll love it. Definitely not for fans of bland pizza. Every Sunday, two large pies, watching the Jags invent new ways to lose a game!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

This business will TEXT YOU coupon codes that don’t work. Just happened For the second time in 2 weeks, and it was the same discount wings code that they told me “didn’t exist” 2 weeks ago. This time they tell me at lunch that the new code will be useable for dinner.

Service: 1

Great staff, quality food, and best in town for pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I always order me pizza from here at least two times a month. I always get the cheese stick with extra cheese with pepperoni and sausage and of course those cinnamon rolls are so delicious. I’ll be forgetting to take photos because the food taste so good but I’ma make sure I start uploading my five ⭐️ 🍕 bTW The service never mess from from going inside great customer servers when drivers come to my house. They’re always kind and polite. One time I soda got loved at the store. They went and got it and brought it right back. Pretty cool people who work here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food wasn’t what I was expecting but didn’t mind it

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Best pizza i had in while

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Easy ordering process. Good food. Try the wings. They are bangin’

Five Stars All Around: Delicious Pizza, Delicious Garlic Knots, and Amazing Value!

I've finally found my go-to pizza spot, and it's Five Star Pizza – they truly live up to their name! This place offers an incredible combination of delicious pizza and amazing value, making every meal a win.
Let's start with the pizza itself. It's truly delicious! The crust is perfectly crafted, toppings are generous and fresh, and the sauce hits all the right notes. Every slice is a testament to their quality.
But it's not just the pizza that shines. You absolutely have to try their garlic knots. They're golden, buttery, perfectly seasoned, and incredibly addictive – the ideal companion to any pizza order.
And if you're looking for something special, keep an eye out for their barbecue pizza specials. I tried one recently, and the smoky, savory flavors combined with their fantastic pizza base created a truly unforgettable and delicious experience. These specials are a fantastic way to try something new and exciting without compromising on that signature Five Star deliciousness.
The value here is simply outstanding. You get top-notch, incredibly delicious food for a price that won't make your wallet wince. For quality, taste, and incredible deals, Five Star Pizza is my absolute first choice. Highly, highly recommended!

Although the register took forever to turn on, Connor gave wonderful customer service !

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

5 star pizza? More like 1 star… I’ve been eating buffalo chicken pizza my entire life. This wasn’t a pizza, it was a weaponized slab of molten lava disguised as food. Who the hell decided this much spice was okay? Are they actively trying to hurt people? One bite and my mouth felt like it was under siege. It wasn’t flavor it was pain. The sauce seemed to have been seasoned by someone holding a grudge against taste buds. If you’re looking for a pizza that burns hotter than a breakup text, this is for you. The sauce? It tasted like someone dumped an entire spice rack into it, then added gasoline for good measure. If I wanted to punish myself, I’d just skip eating altogether. This wasn’t a meal it was an assault. Avoid this disaster at all costs unless you hate yourself.

Food: 1

Pep powerhouse wow so goooood. We crave it

Food: 5

We had a 1 topping pizza, but we were able to get pepperoni on one side and Italian sausage on the other side (delicious) we happened to have a 1 large topping pizza for free coupon, so we used that, Alex was so sweet and kind to us, he made sure we had everything we needed like plates, parmesan, red peppers, and napkins. Thank you so much definitely will be coming back. Blessings 🙏🏼

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time ordering and pizza was delicious! We were thrilled to come somewhere open and we’ll definitely keep ordering!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Not a gourmet pizza, but our favorite for a chain. The food is always hot with fresh ingredients, the order nearly always correct, or they make good on it immediately on the rare occasion there is a mistake. The staff is friendly and efficient.

Parking: We frequent the St. Johns location in the UNF Towncenter.

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Rolls, One Topping Italian Sausage Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Marinara, Garlic Rolls, Garlic Butter