Just crazy good.. keep doing what you do best and we will keep coming!
Marina Zigovsky
#glutenfree. The gluten free crust didn’t lose the taste or texture. The filling was dreamy creamy like my cutie told me at the window. Gluten free community. You need to support someone who heard us say we wanted desserts and she stepped up with love in every bite. Look for the white half door just past the pizza joint
A Unique Entertainment, inc
It’s very hard to decide which pie is the best or even the best five pies so I always get the variety pie as I can’t make up my mind you want me disappointed
Jennifer Garcia Knight
Blurred Limes is a masterpiece of flavor and texture! The pretzel crust adds a salty, crunchy twist that perfectly balances the tartness of the filling. Speaking of the filling, it’s a revelation—velvety smooth yet delightfully textured, offering a rich, creamy bite with just the right zing of lime. The combination of sweet, salty, and tangy flavors makes this Key Lime pie truly exceptional—a standout dessert you won’t want to miss!
Patrice Drolte
I had purchased pies before from their shop in back. I gleefully bought 3 for Thanksgiving and will not do that again. WAY overpriced for what the product was!! Cute names don’t make up for quality. Skimpy shallow pie pans were a big disappointment. We didn’t finish 2 of them.
Michelle M
Mixed Pies Fillings supplied both regular and mini pies for my daughter‘s baby shower. Hands down the best pies I’ve ever had in my life. Great value and even greater quality. Highly recommend for personal and/or events.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christina Medrano
Amazing pies! I have so many favorites like peanut butter
& jealous, pumpkin, and banana cream.
Yolanda Riley
This is a must have treat. My friend and I tested a few Pies! The number one pick, it's the Boomer French Silk for me! Second place, Peanut Butter and Jealous. Third place is Beach Don't Kill My Vibe. She liked Beach Don't Kill My Vibe, Strawberry Fields, and Blurred Limes. You really can't go wrong with any pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Majestic Capricorn
This place is so cute. I’m sorry to hear of their closing. :(. As soon as you walk in, you can smell the pies in the air. We got a flight. My flight included the Key Lime (amazing), Oreo, Apple, & Strawberry Pies. They were all fresh and delicious. Go grab a slice!!
Such a cute, cozy, welcoming pie gem in Jax!! It’s so hard to find good pie places in Jax with variety. First time here— tbh I’ve had this place saved in my Yelp collections for a while and wish I visited sooner. Finally came after several recs from friends & family.
I came here with my bf who is visiting from NYC who really wanted to try some great southern pies and we were more than pleased. We ordered the flight of 6 pies for $38– which was absolutely perfect for indecisive foodies who want to try nearly everything they see!
The pies & their names that we bought are pictured as attached. HIGHLY recommend their Creamsicle pie (seasonal I think?) which was perfect for someone like me who dislikes fruit/jammy pies— I loved this fruit pie since it was a more vanilla-y creamy pie with notes of fruity fragrant citrusy flavor. And as a chocolate lover, I highly recommend anything “French Silk” from here; this first time I bought the only one available which was the OK, Boomer pie. My bf loved the Creamsicle and the Blurred Limes (Key Lime) pie so much that he ended up going off on his own after our lil sampling to buy 2 FULL sized $40 pies of those 2 flavors (which we almost had no fridge space for, but I tried to make space anyways). The full pies we bought will be shared with some of my friends & family to try to spread the love :)
I’m a chocolate pie, cream pie, & custard pie girlie, so you bet I will be on the lookout!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pies
Deb Venn
the berries pies were delish, but that Brûlée All Day pie was to DIE FOR ! so good not too sweet, yum!
Chris Spohn
Great pies across the board. I love the Creme Brulee pie they make. Lots of great choices. All beautifully executed. Try em today. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Toasted Meringue, Peanut Butter Mousse Pie, Pies, The Moon Pie French Silk, Peanut Butter & Jealous Pie, Banana Cream
Kasia Ford
Y’all… this place! I have been a couple of times and have tried the peanut butter & jealous, key lime, orange creamsicle, and chess pie and THEY JUST DO NOT MISS. I can’t recommend enough.
Just crazy good.. keep doing what you do best and we will keep coming!
#glutenfree. The gluten free crust didn’t lose the taste or texture. The filling was dreamy creamy like my cutie told me at the window. Gluten free community. You need to support someone who heard us say we wanted desserts and she stepped up with love in every bite. Look for the white half door just past the pizza joint
It’s very hard to decide which pie is the best or even the best five pies so I always get the variety pie as I can’t make up my mind you want me disappointed
Blurred Limes is a masterpiece of flavor and texture! The pretzel crust adds a salty, crunchy twist that perfectly balances the tartness of the filling. Speaking of the filling, it’s a revelation—velvety smooth yet delightfully textured, offering a rich, creamy bite with just the right zing of lime. The combination of sweet, salty, and tangy flavors makes this Key Lime pie truly exceptional—a standout dessert you won’t want to miss!
I had purchased pies before from their shop in back. I gleefully bought 3 for Thanksgiving and will not do that again. WAY overpriced for what the product was!! Cute names don’t make up for quality. Skimpy shallow pie pans were a big disappointment. We didn’t finish 2 of them.
Mixed Pies Fillings supplied both regular and mini pies for my daughter‘s baby shower. Hands down the best pies I’ve ever had in my life. Great value and even greater quality. Highly recommend for personal and/or events.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pies! I have so many favorites like peanut butter & jealous, pumpkin, and banana cream.
This is a must have treat. My friend and I tested a few Pies!
The number one pick, it's the Boomer French Silk for me! Second place, Peanut Butter and Jealous. Third place is Beach Don't Kill My Vibe. She liked Beach Don't Kill My Vibe, Strawberry Fields, and Blurred Limes.
You really can't go wrong with any pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is so cute. I’m sorry to hear of their closing. :(. As soon as you walk in, you can smell the pies in the air. We got a flight. My flight included the Key Lime (amazing), Oreo, Apple, & Strawberry Pies. They were all fresh and delicious. Go grab a slice!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a find! Great pies!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pies
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing pie and service. Natasha is so friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a cute, cozy, welcoming pie gem in Jax!! It’s so hard to find good pie places in Jax with variety. First time here— tbh I’ve had this place saved in my Yelp collections for a while and wish I visited sooner. Finally came after several recs from friends & family.
I came here with my bf who is visiting from NYC who really wanted to try some great southern pies and we were more than pleased. We ordered the flight of 6 pies for $38– which was absolutely perfect for indecisive foodies who want to try nearly everything they see!
The pies & their names that we bought are pictured as attached. HIGHLY recommend their Creamsicle pie (seasonal I think?) which was perfect for someone like me who dislikes fruit/jammy pies— I loved this fruit pie since it was a more vanilla-y creamy pie with notes of fruity fragrant citrusy flavor. And as a chocolate lover, I highly recommend anything “French Silk” from here; this first time I bought the only one available which was the OK, Boomer pie. My bf loved the Creamsicle and the Blurred Limes (Key Lime) pie so much that he ended up going off on his own after our lil sampling to buy 2 FULL sized $40 pies of those 2 flavors (which we almost had no fridge space for, but I tried to make space anyways). The full pies we bought will be shared with some of my friends & family to try to spread the love :)
I’m a chocolate pie, cream pie, & custard pie girlie, so you bet I will be on the lookout!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pies
the berries pies were delish, but that Brûlée All Day pie was to DIE FOR ! so good not too sweet, yum!
Great pies across the board. I love the Creme Brulee pie they make. Lots of great choices. All beautifully executed. Try em today. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Toasted Meringue, Peanut Butter Mousse Pie, Pies, The Moon Pie French Silk, Peanut Butter & Jealous Pie, Banana Cream
Y’all… this place! I have been a couple of times and have tried the peanut butter & jealous, key lime, orange creamsicle, and chess pie and THEY JUST DO NOT MISS. I can’t recommend enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blurred Limes Key Lime Pie, Pies, Peanut Butter & Jealous Pie
Loading...