Mixed Fillings Pie Shop
1049 Park St, Jacksonville
(904) 619-6455
Customers' Favorites
The Blue Dahlia Blueberry Pie
Three Sisters Mixed Berry Pie
Beach Don't Kill My Vibe Pie
Peanut Butter & Jealous Pie
Blurred Limes Key Lime Pie
Peanut Butter Mousse Pie
The Moon Pie French Silk
Mini Chicken Pot Pie
Lemon Pie of the Day
Coconut Cream Pie
Menu
Photos
+38 photos
+37 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
#glutenfree. The gluten free crust didn’t lose the taste or texture. The filling was dreamy creamy like my cutie told me at the window. Gluten free community. You need to support someone who heard us say we wanted desserts and she stepped up with love in every bite. Look for the white half door just past the pizza joint
Blurred Limes is a masterpiece of flavor and texture! The pretzel crust adds a salty, crunchy twist that perfectly balances the tartness of the filling. Speaking of the filling, it’s a revelation—velvety smooth yet delightfully textured, offering a rich, creamy bite with just the right zing of lime. The combination of sweet, salty, and tangy flavors makes this Key Lime pie truly exceptional—a standout dessert you won’t want to miss!
I had purchased pies before from their shop in back. I gleefully bought 3 for Thanksgiving and will not do that again. WAY overpriced for what the product was!! Cute names don’t make up for quality. Skimpy shallow pie pans were a big disappointment. We didn’t finish 2 of them.
You May Also Like
Biggies Pizza 5 Points Riverside - 1053 Park St
![]()
Pizza, Vegan
Rain Dogs - 1045 Park St
![]()
Bar, Lounges, Pet Friendly
Hoptinger Bier Garden & Sausage House - 1037 Park St
![]()
Beer Gardens, Gastropubs, German, Vegan