Key Colony Inn Restaurant & Lounge

I was hesitant about eating after the reviews but we decided to try it. We got huge portions and it was very good and had great service. My husband brought in his catch from fishing earlier and they cooked it up for him.

We visit this restaurant every year on Christmas Day, so that my mother doesn’t have to worry about cooking as it’s also her birthday. We look forward to this trip every year. Typically the food is great, however things have changed significantly in the past year. We had a 3PM reservation. We were greatful that we were able to get in early, as we arrived at 2:30. Looking back, that should have been our first warning sign. We were sat, had our drink order taken, immediately followed by food order. We were not given the water that they typically give at seating, and had to request the bread and butter they give for each table 45 minutes into our seating. We ordered another round of drinks as we received our salads. At last our food arrived after having being sat at the table for an hour and fifteen minutes. The food was absolutely terrible. Fish was snapper, but the fish smelled terrible and the meat was dark not white like it’s supposed to be. An hour and forty five minutes into our seating we received our second drinks, after having been empty for more than 45 minutes. (Again without a water option) They did remove the snapper dinners from our bill, thankfully. However, the manager never even came to ask what was wrong. After two hours, and spending nearly an hour without a drink, and the quality of the rest of the food (chicken Alfredo, spaghetti & meatballs, fried dolphin) that was the least that could have been done. Every plate was left 90% full, and there were 8 of us. What was a yearly birthday routine for my mom and our family has come to an end. We will find a new place to start her annual birthday celebration in 2025!!

Thank you for the great dinner. The waiter was really nice. Very large portions. Everything was great, please keep it up.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I went in for lunch today and ordered French Onion Soup and Snapper Del Mar, Iced Tea with No Ice. The bill came to $55.90. Breaking down the bill, the FISH Del Mar was $36.— And there was an additional charge of $10.00 for SNAPPER. What’s going on with that?? I mean, I ordered a dish, Snapper Del Mar and was charged for something else. Well I guess I won’t be going to this Rip Off Joint again

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Yeah, the best place I've ever eaten. Dayshon was the best bar tender I've ever seen. Food was awesome. We caught a load of fish, and they cooked it all up differently and brought it to us on a platter. The food was amazing. Service was the BEST. 10/10 would recommend

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Title: Disappointing Experience at Key Colony Inn

I recently visited Key Colony Inn with high hopes for a lovely evening, but unfortunately, it turned into a frustrating experience. All we wanted was dessert and an espresso martini to cap off our meal, but what we encountered was anything but welcoming.

Upon our arrival at the bar, we were met with an awkward scene where the bartender and server were openly arguing about who would take our order. It was uncomfortable to witness, and it seemed like neither of them wanted to assist us. After waiting far too long, we finally got their attention, but the lack of enthusiasm and professionalism was palpable.

It felt like we were an inconvenience rather than valued guests. We left without our desired dessert or drink, feeling completely ignored. It’s disappointing when a place fails to provide basic service, especially when all we wanted was a sweet treat and a drink to enjoy.

I won’t be returning, and I can’t recommend Key Colony Inn if you’re looking for a pleasant dining experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Food was amazing, service was friendly and prompt, will come back again for sure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I found bugs in my food and they refused to do anything!!! I couldn't believe it!!! Don't waste your hard earned money at this disgusting establishment.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I GOT FOOD POISONING EATING HERE. DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

When we come to the keys we always have to go and have their fish. If you are lucky they have yellow tail. If not the dolphin is always yummy. They have the BEST homemade thousand island dressing.

Kid-friendliness: Plenty of dining room space

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Dolphin Blackened

Disappointing Experience at Key Colony Inn I recently visited Key Colony Inn with high hopes for a lovely evening, but unfortunately, it turned into a frustrating experience. All we wanted was dessert and an espresso martini to cap off our meal, but what we encountered was anything but welcoming. Upon our arrival at the bar, we were met with an awkward scene where the bartender and server were openly arguing about who would take our order. It was uncomfortable to witness, and it seemed like neither of them wanted to assist us. After waiting far too long, we finally got their attention, but the lack of enthusiasm and professionalism was palpable. It felt like we were an inconvenience rather than valued guests. We left without our desired dessert or drink, feeling completely ignored. It’s disappointing when a place fails to provide basic service, especially when all we wanted was a sweet treat and a drink to enjoy. I won’t be returning, and I can’t recommend Key Colony Inn if you’re looking for a pleasant dining experience.

We have dined here many time while visiting Marathon and enjoyed the food. We dined here September 5th 2024 and unfortunately our dinner was not worth the price and wait to get our meal after ordering. My fish and baked potato were not even warm when I received it. Not sure how long it sat in the kitchen before it was picked up. Prior to this visit we always liked the food.

First time here and I will repeat, the place is very spacious and has different atmospheres, the food is delicious and very generous portion, if you eat little you can order a dish for 2, the prices are affordable, it is not very cheap but not expensive either.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

If I could leave this review a 0 star review I would. From the second we walked in we waited an astonishing amount of time just to be served because the host was too busy on the phone. Didn’t even say to us he will be with us shortly just ignored us. Once we EVENTUALLY sat down we waited another 15 minutes for getting drinks. Then food was out. Salads were poorly presented. And sauces came out in plastic pots. You can tell the food is cooked from frozen. Nothing is fresh. Absolutely astonished for a place that looks so nice on the outside.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Food was soooo good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calamari