Mr C's Homemade Ice Cream
86701 Overseas Hwy suite 1, Islamorada
(305) 780-2210
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Brownie and Recesse
Cheesecake & KeyLime
Mango Peach Sorbet
Cannoli Ice Cream
Orange Sorbet
Key Lime Pie
Menu
Photos
+26 photos
+25 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Visiting from out of state. We drove 20 minutes to get this famous ice cream that a friend told us about. Very disappointed to see that the hours online were wrong. Please update so others aren’t frustrated. I also think it’s odd to be completely closed on a Saturday in August.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Florida Keys Classic — Ice Cream with a Side of Personality
Mr. C’s isn’t just an ice cream shop. It’s a whole experience. The second you walk in, you’re hit with old-school vibes; vintage signs, a toy train behind the counter, handwritten notes, and a flavor list that seems to go on forever.
I had Butterfinger, Butter Pecan, and Rum Raisin. All three were super creamy and packed with flavor. You can tell this place...
Mr. C’s isn’t just an ice cream shop. It’s a whole experience. The second you walk in, you’re hit with old-school vibes; vintage signs, a toy train behind the counter, handwritten notes, and a flavor list that seems to go on forever.
I had Butterfinger, Butter Pecan, and Rum Raisin. All three were super creamy and packed with flavor. You can tell this place...
We waiting all week to go to Mr. C's and I'm so glad we did! Mr. C himself walked us through all of his creams and sorbets it's was wonderful! Prices were great, and everything was delicious!
You May Also Like
Puerto Vallarta Mexican Bar & Grill - 86701 Overseas Hwy
![]()
Mexican, Seafood, Cocktail Bar, Gluten-Free
Lobster Shack - 86700 Overseas Hwy
![]()
Seafood, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian