If you are looking for pizza in Key Largo, THIS IS IT!!! The absolute best staff and atmosphere and the food is beyond amazing. The pizzas are very fairly priced for size and toppings. The staff was so kind and helpful both on the phone and in person. I’m beyond impressed. They made my night. You have to come here!
Agnes Giele
There are many pizza options on the Keys. As you drive down you will see. But DO NOT MISS THIS ONE!!!! OMG this was deliciousness. Every bite I was hoping that I had a bigger stomach. Just soooo good. Their flavors were so well balanced and their treys keep the pizza hot while you enjoy it.
On top of that, the owners are amazing. The wife is super nice and friendly and she will happily engage in a conversation about their European heritage. The husband is beer enthusiast. If you like international beer collection then definitely have a chat with him. He will explain to you every option offered and some of his vintage options too.
We stumbled upon this treasure almost by an accident but next time we visit, we are not missing it, for sure!!!!
Consuelo Sanchez
Pizza was soggy, edges kind of burnt and barely- there toppings were not enough. I strongly believe that the pizza is overpriced for what you get. I will never buy pizza from this place again.
Elizabeth Baker
I'm tough to please when it comes to pizza. I did enjoy the pizza here. And the service was very good. Nice staff.
Dillon D.
I've driven by this place a gazillion times and mostly couldn't stop due to work. I've wanted to try it out a long time. Today a friend and I (we live in Miami not key largo) came down to do a consultation and buy supplements at my favorite shop, Remedy's Nutrition. We came down early enough to have breakfast, run some errands, then go to the supplement shop. We were there a long time sorting things out. When we left, we both agreed we were hungry and wanted pizza, so we stopped here. First time but not our last. The pizza tasted so fresh and organic. Not a part of it tasted fake, stale, or inferior. Their menu says extra sauce and extra cheese is already on it, and here it's true. This pizza is some of the best ever had!!! We had dessert, my friend had key lime pie and I had Tiramisu, again everything was so fresh tasting, organic, and delicious. Idk if truly organic but it tasted of that quality and I can usually tell. I went full organic at least 10 years ago and have trouble eating garbage food because it tastes so fake... this wasn't the case at this pizza place.
Only drawback was the noise was of a cafeteria vibe. The people were super nice. The noise could easily be addressed by using booths with tall backs of seats. Or putting some acoustic panels up.
I loved this little gem regardless.
Richard Belka
Upper Crust Pizza blew us away with both their food and service! The pizza was absolutely incredible—crispy crust, rich sauce, and plenty of fresh, high-quality toppings. We had a variety for our group, and every pie was a hit. The wings, garlic knots, and salads were just as impressive. The staff went above and beyond to accommodate our large party, keeping things running smoothly with friendly, efficient service. The cozy, laid-back vibe made it easy to relax and enjoy the evening. It’s clear they care about both their food and their customers. Five stars all the way—we’ll definitely be back!
Mary Torres
Absolutely the best pizza anywhere in the country! Reliable local place. Service could be a little tighter but the pizza is never a disappointment!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Upper Crust Pizza
Daniel Silgailis
To much money for the pizza I can go to Domino's and save. They need to look up Metro pizza in Henderson Nv. That's a pizza for comparable prices! Get with the program
Marco Arguelles
We had a pretty big order. The staff super friendly and the pizza well made really tasty definitely a great spot in Key
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gator Mangrove
Pizza was very good. A little light on the pepperoni but a nice portion of cheese.
Ordered take out delivery. Food was fine. Delivery lady called us to come to parking lot to get our order because she could not get into hotel, even though we had other delivery people get in fine. Lazy pure and simple delivery person.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Shirley Luk
The seafood pizza is amazing delicious, I didn't eat 3 slices pizzas for very long time ,that's how good it is.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Daniel Gielchinsky
This place alone put a smile on my face best service from Beth a nice place to be but the pasta and other food is good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upper Crust Pizza
Curtis Peck
Best pizza in the entire keys. Bayside restaurant in islamorada is cheaper but not as good of a crust recipe. Upper Crust is THE best!!!
If you are looking for pizza in Key Largo, THIS IS IT!!! The absolute best staff and atmosphere and the food is beyond amazing. The pizzas are very fairly priced for size and toppings. The staff was so kind and helpful both on the phone and in person. I’m beyond impressed. They made my night. You have to come here!
There are many pizza options on the Keys. As you drive down you will see. But DO NOT MISS THIS ONE!!!!
OMG this was deliciousness. Every bite I was hoping that I had a bigger stomach. Just soooo good. Their flavors were so well balanced and their treys keep the pizza hot while you enjoy it.
On top of that, the owners are amazing. The wife is super nice and friendly and she will happily engage in a conversation about their European heritage. The husband is beer enthusiast. If you like international beer collection then definitely have a chat with him. He will explain to you every option offered and some of his vintage options too.
We stumbled upon this treasure almost by an accident but next time we visit, we are not missing it, for sure!!!!
Pizza was soggy, edges kind of burnt and barely- there toppings were not enough.
I strongly believe that the pizza is overpriced for what you get.
I will never buy pizza from this place again.
I'm tough to please when it comes to pizza. I did enjoy the pizza here. And the service was very good. Nice staff.
I've driven by this place a gazillion times and mostly couldn't stop due to work. I've wanted to try it out a long time. Today a friend and I (we live in Miami not key largo) came down to do a consultation and buy supplements at my favorite shop, Remedy's Nutrition. We came down early enough to have breakfast, run some errands, then go to the supplement shop. We were there a long time sorting things out. When we left, we both agreed we were hungry and wanted pizza, so we stopped here. First time but not our last. The pizza tasted so fresh and organic. Not a part of it tasted fake, stale, or inferior. Their menu says extra sauce and extra cheese is already on it, and here it's true. This pizza is some of the best ever had!!! We had dessert, my friend had key lime pie and I had Tiramisu, again everything was so fresh tasting, organic, and delicious. Idk if truly organic but it tasted of that quality and I can usually tell. I went full organic at least 10 years ago and have trouble eating garbage food because it tastes so fake... this wasn't the case at this pizza place.
Only drawback was the noise was of a cafeteria vibe. The people were super nice. The noise could easily be addressed by using booths with tall backs of seats. Or putting some acoustic panels up.
I loved this little gem regardless.
Upper Crust Pizza blew us away with both their food and service! The pizza was absolutely incredible—crispy crust, rich sauce, and plenty of fresh, high-quality toppings. We had a variety for our group, and every pie was a hit. The wings, garlic knots, and salads were just as impressive. The staff went above and beyond to accommodate our large party, keeping things running smoothly with friendly, efficient service. The cozy, laid-back vibe made it easy to relax and enjoy the evening. It’s clear they care about both their food and their customers. Five stars all the way—we’ll definitely be back!
Absolutely the best pizza anywhere in the country! Reliable local place. Service could be a little tighter but the pizza is never a disappointment!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Upper Crust Pizza
To much money for the pizza I can go to Domino's and save. They need to look up Metro pizza in Henderson Nv. That's a pizza for comparable prices! Get with the program
We had a pretty big order. The staff super friendly and the pizza well made really tasty definitely a great spot in Key
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was very good. A little light on the pepperoni but a nice portion of cheese.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Upper Crust Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
The best pizza in the south of florida
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upper Crust Pizza
Ordered take out delivery. Food was fine. Delivery lady called us to come to parking lot to get our order because she could not get into hotel, even though we had other delivery people get in fine. Lazy pure and simple delivery person.
Food: 5
Service: 1
The seafood pizza is amazing delicious, I didn't eat 3 slices pizzas for very long time ,that's how good it is.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place alone put a smile on my face best service from Beth a nice place to be but the pasta and other food is good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upper Crust Pizza
Best pizza in the entire keys. Bayside restaurant in islamorada is cheaper but not as good of a crust recipe. Upper Crust is THE best!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...