The pizza was delicious and the vibe was just what we needed. Martina and David make an excellent pizza and are amazing proprietors. If you are in Key Largo swing by for an excellent pie. Lots a great choices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Hough
Best wings in the keys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
sharon a schoeller
We are here eating the most delicious meat lovers Pizza there is. A special thank you to the delivery girl Lisa I believe her name is who was very kind delivered the pizza in the pouring rain and came all the way into the hotel area so that I wouldn't need to get wet. We will be ordering from you folks again. Thank you Lisa for calling me back and checking on my satisfaction I really appreciated that phone call.
Atmosphere: 5
Kurlyo
Very good pizza 🍕
Judith Kuehner
I will never order pizza from here again. We were told that they would not honor the prices shown online as they were several years old. Well, either update your prices or remove the outdated prices!! We ordered Hawaiian pizza with Alfredo sauce which was a $5 extra charge. The pizza was fair at best. I left cash tip in the jar on the bar and authorized just the amount for the pizza on the statement copy. Later upon checking my charges for my card I was surprised to see that someone at the restaurant had added almost $6 to my total which I had not authorized! So beware of extra charges at Upper Crust Puzza!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
D M
Do not miss out on this place! This will be our number one spot every time we pass through!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin Wilson
Our local spot. Great pizza, great people, chimay, good wine and homemade food so not much else to say.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy “Pure Pug \u0026 Company” Seiler
This place is always fabulous. The food is so good. It’s fresh. The owner takes pride and attention to everything that happens. The kitchen staff turns out deliciousness every time. They have a great curated lineup of beers that all have a story and profile they love to share their experience And discoveries. Great place to sit down and just relax and enjoy yourself and the food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gali
A surprising hidden gem in Key Largo.
Clarissa Myers
Whether you are a local or a tourist, this is the only place to get GREAT pizza. This is the #1 place recommended by locals, as well! We have eaten here for over 10 years with carry out orders, or you can just sit at the bar and have a beer. Enjoy!
This is the best pizza I've had outside of New Jersey and is comparable to the best pizza I've had there. I'm a pizza connoisseur who has traveled the country and this is some of the Finest America has Got
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Catherine Taylor
The pizza was good but $60 for two pizzas is wild. I know prices are more in these areas but the pizzas were smalls and not anything crazy topping wise.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Campeon Marinero
I expected a really good pizza, and I was right! This place is a hidden gem. Our pizza was tasty, made just right and did not fall short from perfection. also I really enjoyed the laid back atmosphere of the place. Will be definitely returning !!!
Amanda Jones
If you are looking for pizza in Key Largo, THIS IS IT!!! The absolute best staff and atmosphere and the food is beyond amazing. The pizzas are very fairly priced for size and toppings. The staff was so kind and helpful both on the phone and in person. I’m beyond impressed. They made my night. You have to come here!
Agnes Giele
There are many pizza options on the Keys. As you drive down you will see. But DO NOT MISS THIS ONE!!!! OMG this was deliciousness. Every bite I was hoping that I had a bigger stomach. Just soooo good. Their flavors were so well balanced and their treys keep the pizza hot while you enjoy it.
On top of that, the owners are amazing. The wife is super nice and friendly and she will happily engage in a conversation about their European heritage. The husband is beer enthusiast. If you like international beer collection then definitely have a chat with him. He will explain to you every option offered and some of his vintage options too.
We stumbled upon this treasure almost by an accident but next time we visit, we are not missing it, for sure!!!!
The pizza was delicious and the vibe was just what we needed. Martina and David make an excellent pizza and are amazing proprietors. If you are in Key Largo swing by for an excellent pie. Lots a great choices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best wings in the keys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We are here eating the most delicious meat lovers Pizza there is. A special thank you to the delivery girl Lisa I believe her name is who was very kind delivered the pizza in the pouring rain and came all the way into the hotel area so that I wouldn't need to get wet. We will be ordering from you folks again. Thank you Lisa for calling me back and checking on my satisfaction I really appreciated that phone call.
Atmosphere: 5
Very good pizza 🍕
I will never order pizza from here again. We were told that they would not honor the prices shown online as they were several years old. Well, either update your prices or remove the outdated prices!! We ordered Hawaiian pizza with Alfredo sauce which was a $5 extra charge. The pizza was fair at best. I left cash tip in the jar on the bar and authorized just the amount for the pizza on the statement copy. Later upon checking my charges for my card I was surprised to see that someone at the restaurant had added almost $6 to my total which I had not authorized! So beware of extra charges at Upper Crust Puzza!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Do not miss out on this place! This will be our number one spot every time we pass through!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our local spot. Great pizza, great people, chimay, good wine and homemade food so not much else to say.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is always fabulous. The food is so good. It’s fresh. The owner takes pride and attention to everything that happens. The kitchen staff turns out deliciousness every time. They have a great curated lineup of beers that all have a story and profile they love to share their experience And discoveries. Great place to sit down and just relax and enjoy yourself and the food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A surprising hidden gem in Key Largo.
Whether you are a local or a tourist, this is the only place to get GREAT pizza. This is the #1 place recommended by locals, as well! We have eaten here for over 10 years with carry out orders, or you can just sit at the bar and have a beer. Enjoy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This is the best pizza I've had outside of New Jersey and is comparable to the best pizza I've had there. I'm a pizza connoisseur who has traveled the country and this is some of the Finest America has Got
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was good but $60 for two pizzas is wild. I know prices are more in these areas but the pizzas were smalls and not anything crazy topping wise.
Food: 4
Service: 5
I expected a really good pizza, and I was right! This place is a hidden gem. Our pizza was tasty, made just right and did not fall short from perfection. also I really enjoyed the laid back atmosphere of the place. Will be definitely returning !!!
If you are looking for pizza in Key Largo, THIS IS IT!!! The absolute best staff and atmosphere and the food is beyond amazing. The pizzas are very fairly priced for size and toppings. The staff was so kind and helpful both on the phone and in person. I’m beyond impressed. They made my night. You have to come here!
There are many pizza options on the Keys. As you drive down you will see. But DO NOT MISS THIS ONE!!!!
OMG this was deliciousness. Every bite I was hoping that I had a bigger stomach. Just soooo good. Their flavors were so well balanced and their treys keep the pizza hot while you enjoy it.
On top of that, the owners are amazing. The wife is super nice and friendly and she will happily engage in a conversation about their European heritage. The husband is beer enthusiast. If you like international beer collection then definitely have a chat with him. He will explain to you every option offered and some of his vintage options too.
We stumbled upon this treasure almost by an accident but next time we visit, we are not missing it, for sure!!!!
Loading...