EXCELLENT New York thin crisp pizza!!! This is absolutely the best spot to grab a quick slice of delicious pizza on Duvall Street and the price is perfect
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Thomas
Ordered a pepperoni pizza, was handed a supreme pizza and when I asked to change for what I ordered the man offered to fight me. Very unprofessional service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Tracy Czyz
So good we ate it twice and bought the T shirt! š canāt wait to go back! Best slice in town.
Zach Smith
Would absolutely recommend to everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex blanco
Amazing pizza! Thx guys
Courtney Bieghler
Our favorite place to eat when we visit. We will grab a slice as many times as we can. Itās crispy and flavorful! You need a token for the bathroom but with as many people that are on Duval street, it makes sense.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Paul
Canāt believe this doesnāt have five stars. Easily best pizza in Key West. Iāve ordered late at night and always comes fast and the owner is a really nice man who delivers the pizza. You wonāt be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Neal
Their slices are huge, hot, and delicious. Right there on Duval, great while walking the strip.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gyvel Berkley
Recently, I called and placed an order for Pizza. The person who delivered was an African-American male. Middle age, and on a method of E bike transportation. When he delivered my pizza, it was full of gravel. Obviously, he dropped it. Put it back in the box and delivered. Disgusting. When I called to complain, I was told to take it up with the driver. So this is what Iām doing now. This was for my family, including my children. How dare you put your profit above the safety of my family. Donāt get Delivery from this restaurant ever. And for the owner of Angelinaās Pizza, you know who Iām talking about. Get rid of him. Heās not good for your business. And you know it!
An awesome snack with all the craziness in Key West!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roger Cox
By the slice or by the pie.. the pizza is really good. Whole pizza takes about 15 minutes to make.. they get busy but no worries.. they keep things moving and orderly.
They have beer on tap, by the glass or by the pitcher. Seating is just outside.. usually you can find a spot to sit.
We had a simple pepperoni pie. Large was 33$ and could handle three adults easily. Nice sauce and the dough was delicious.
Der āWertzeitā Tester
Conclusion first: If youāre questing for good vibes, great pizza, and even greater service ā this is your tavern.
The staff at Angelinaās were genuinely kind, like NPCs programmed with nothing but helpful dialogue. Super friendly, attentive, and quick with a smile. Drinks? Offered for free when asked, and not just a sip ā generously poured, like from a bottomless goblet of refreshment.
The pizza itself? Crispy, cheesy, and flavorful enough to make a bard sing. Easily one of the tastiest we had on our journey through the land of Key West.
Final verdict: A magical little pizzeria where service and flavor both roll natural 20s.
Wandering Guy
Firstly, very nice people. They were patient even at the end of the day, great. They explained me all I needed and followed all the instructions. I would not say best of the Pizzas but their dough was good enough to go again if I had to eat pizza in this place. Donāt forget to ask for the coins if you need to visit restrooms.
Best pizza I've ever had keep it up
EXCELLENT New York thin crisp pizza!!! This is absolutely the best spot to grab a quick slice of delicious pizza on Duvall Street and the price is perfect
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a pepperoni pizza, was handed a supreme pizza and when I asked to change for what I ordered the man offered to fight me. Very unprofessional service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
So good we ate it twice and bought the T shirt! š canāt wait to go back! Best slice in town.
Would absolutely recommend to everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza! Thx guys
Our favorite place to eat when we visit. We will grab a slice as many times as we can. Itās crispy and flavorful! You need a token for the bathroom but with as many people that are on Duval street, it makes sense.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Canāt believe this doesnāt have five stars. Easily best pizza in Key West. Iāve ordered late at night and always comes fast and the owner is a really nice man who delivers the pizza. You wonāt be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their slices are huge, hot, and delicious. Right there on Duval, great while walking the strip.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recently, I called and placed an order for Pizza. The person who delivered was an African-American male. Middle age, and on a method of E bike transportation. When he delivered my pizza, it was full of gravel. Obviously, he dropped it. Put it back in the box and delivered. Disgusting. When I called to complain, I was told to take it up with the driver. So this is what Iām doing now. This was for my family, including my children. How dare you put your profit above the safety of my family. Donāt get Delivery from this restaurant ever. And for the owner of Angelinaās Pizza, you know who Iām talking about. Get rid of him. Heās not good for your business. And you know it!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
An awesome snack with all the craziness in Key West!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
By the slice or by the pie.. the pizza is really good. Whole pizza takes about 15 minutes to make.. they get busy but no worries.. they keep things moving and orderly.
They have beer on tap, by the glass or by the pitcher. Seating is just outside.. usually you can find a spot to sit.
We had a simple pepperoni pie. Large was 33$ and could handle three adults easily. Nice sauce and the dough was delicious.
Conclusion first: If youāre questing for good vibes, great pizza, and even greater service ā this is your tavern.
The staff at Angelinaās were genuinely kind, like NPCs programmed with nothing but helpful dialogue. Super friendly, attentive, and quick with a smile. Drinks? Offered for free when asked, and not just a sip ā generously poured, like from a bottomless goblet of refreshment.
The pizza itself? Crispy, cheesy, and flavorful enough to make a bard sing. Easily one of the tastiest we had on our journey through the land of Key West.
Final verdict: A magical little pizzeria where service and flavor both roll natural 20s.
Firstly, very nice people. They were patient even at the end of the day, great. They explained me all I needed and followed all the instructions. I would not say best of the Pizzas but their dough was good enough to go again if I had to eat pizza in this place.
Donāt forget to ask for the coins if you need to visit restrooms.
Loading...