An awesome snack with all the craziness in Key West!
Roger Cox
By the slice or by the pie.. the pizza is really good. Whole pizza takes about 15 minutes to make.. they get busy but no worries.. they keep things moving and orderly.
They have beer on tap, by the glass or by the pitcher. Seating is just outside.. usually you can find a spot to sit.
We had a simple pepperoni pie. Large was 33$ and could handle three adults easily. Nice sauce and the dough was delicious.
Der “Wertzeit” Tester
Conclusion first: If you’re questing for good vibes, great pizza, and even greater service — this is your tavern.
The staff at Angelina’s were genuinely kind, like NPCs programmed with nothing but helpful dialogue. Super friendly, attentive, and quick with a smile. Drinks? Offered for free when asked, and not just a sip — generously poured, like from a bottomless goblet of refreshment.
The pizza itself? Crispy, cheesy, and flavorful enough to make a bard sing. Easily one of the tastiest we had on our journey through the land of Key West.
Final verdict: A magical little pizzeria where service and flavor both roll natural 20s.
Wandering Guy
Firstly, very nice people. They were patient even at the end of the day, great. They explained me all I needed and followed all the instructions. I would not say best of the Pizzas but their dough was good enough to go again if I had to eat pizza in this place. Don’t forget to ask for the coins if you need to visit restrooms.
Todd Watkins
Pizza was so good we ate here multiple times while in town.
Adam Sawyer
Great little spot for a slice of pie for 5 dollars. Beers about what you’d expect. Two slices took all of 3-5 minutes to get out. Hot pizza and people walking by — a meal and entertainment.
Bethany Rose
Really good pizza!
Gregory Freund
This place is just weird, and not Key-Westy at all. My wife and I stopped there after a tour. I was in the mood for pizza, but also had to go to the bathroom. You need a token to use their bathroom. Super strange and questionably legal for a place that serves food. Ordered two slices and was given a token and a terrible attitude after forgetting to provide my credit card while briskly moving to the bathroom, with token in hand. The bathroom was honestly another level of weird. After the token strangeness, you literally pee on the floor. After unlocking this sacred toilet with my well earned token, I took some splash on my ankles from another dude. Pizza came out, but was served with more weird attitude for not knowing the laws of the token. The food i received looked like pizza, but I left it for (hopefully) the exact person they attempted to deny the decency of a safe bathroom. If not, maybe a rooster.
The pizza may be decent (?), but there are definitely better-looking slices in the northeast. However, this place does not match Key West's friendly, accepting atmosphere. Its food may be good (or bad); but buyers beware of the lack of Key West experience. You may end up with some pee on your ankles.
frances snow
Amazing food, love the vibe. My boyfriend loves how they call your number when your foods ready!
Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly, space to play and places to sit and eat.
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it is wheel chair accessible!
Excellent pizza... whole or by the slice and you can choose from a wide variety of toppings. Some of the best pizza I've ever had! A bit pricey, but so delicious!!
Absolutely avoid if you want to survive dysentery. Worst vacation experience!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Doi Recamara
I've been coming to this pizzeria since they opened. I love their pie and it was yummy. A New York style pizza always does the job. I like that they listen and make my big ziti to order sum sauce, no ricotta
An awesome snack with all the craziness in Key West!
By the slice or by the pie.. the pizza is really good. Whole pizza takes about 15 minutes to make.. they get busy but no worries.. they keep things moving and orderly.
They have beer on tap, by the glass or by the pitcher. Seating is just outside.. usually you can find a spot to sit.
We had a simple pepperoni pie. Large was 33$ and could handle three adults easily. Nice sauce and the dough was delicious.
Conclusion first: If you’re questing for good vibes, great pizza, and even greater service — this is your tavern.
The staff at Angelina’s were genuinely kind, like NPCs programmed with nothing but helpful dialogue. Super friendly, attentive, and quick with a smile. Drinks? Offered for free when asked, and not just a sip — generously poured, like from a bottomless goblet of refreshment.
The pizza itself? Crispy, cheesy, and flavorful enough to make a bard sing. Easily one of the tastiest we had on our journey through the land of Key West.
Final verdict: A magical little pizzeria where service and flavor both roll natural 20s.
Firstly, very nice people. They were patient even at the end of the day, great. They explained me all I needed and followed all the instructions. I would not say best of the Pizzas but their dough was good enough to go again if I had to eat pizza in this place.
Don’t forget to ask for the coins if you need to visit restrooms.
Pizza was so good we ate here multiple times while in town.
Great little spot for a slice of pie for 5 dollars. Beers about what you’d expect. Two slices took all of 3-5 minutes to get out. Hot pizza and people walking by — a meal and entertainment.
Really good pizza!
This place is just weird, and not Key-Westy at all. My wife and I stopped there after a tour. I was in the mood for pizza, but also had to go to the bathroom. You need a token to use their bathroom. Super strange and questionably legal for a place that serves food. Ordered two slices and was given a token and a terrible attitude after forgetting to provide my credit card while briskly moving to the bathroom, with token in hand. The bathroom was honestly another level of weird. After the token strangeness, you literally pee on the floor. After unlocking this sacred toilet with my well earned token, I took some splash on my ankles from another dude. Pizza came out, but was served with more weird attitude for not knowing the laws of the token. The food i received looked like pizza, but I left it for (hopefully) the exact person they attempted to deny the decency of a safe bathroom. If not, maybe a rooster.
The pizza may be decent (?), but there are definitely better-looking slices in the northeast. However, this place does not match Key West's friendly, accepting atmosphere. Its food may be good (or bad); but buyers beware of the lack of Key West experience. You may end up with some pee on your ankles.
Amazing food, love the vibe. My boyfriend loves how they call your number when your foods ready!
Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly, space to play and places to sit and eat.
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it is wheel chair accessible!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Lasagna, Angelina's Loaded Pizza Slice
Our favorite pizza place in Key West! Great service, excellent food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
BEST pizza in town!! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Food was just fine
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Excellent pizza... whole or by the slice and you can choose from a wide variety of toppings. Some of the best pizza I've ever had! A bit pricey, but so delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Pizza, Angelina's Loaded Pizza Slice
Absolutely avoid if you want to survive dysentery. Worst vacation experience!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I've been coming to this pizzeria since they opened. I love their pie and it was yummy. A New York style pizza always does the job. I like that they listen and make my big ziti to order sum sauce, no ricotta
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...