Restaurants in Key West
Loading...
Best Restaurants
“A wonderful atmosphere and the staff are very friendly and make you feel a part of the family. The food is top notch and has an inviting appearance. Had never eaten there before but went as a birthday dinner and was not disappointed. Next time we are in town, Red Shoe is on top of the list to return too. We love this restaurant!”
“Yummy conch fritters and the Bahamian Lobster was so luscious.”
Restaurants by Cuisine
“Best seafood dinner I’ve had since 2005 hands down. That’s how good it was‼️The wife and I are in town for our Lucky 13yr anniversary and we were debating between dinner establishments. We settled on this one because it was in close walking distance of Casa. Dinner did not disappoint.”
“Due to the weather, I found myself spending another night in Key West. I came across this quaint restaurant near my hotel. Francesca the owner is so sweet and friendly. Mario behind the bar was just great. He really knows the drinks and the food. I had the cream of zucchini soup. It was delicious large portion and great flavor. Two ladies at the bar shared their antipasto tray with me. Enjoyed both the tray and the ladies who shared it. I will definitely make this my first stop the next time I’m in Key West.”
Restaurants with Delivery
“A wonderful atmosphere and the staff are very friendly and make you feel a part of the family. The food is top notch and has an inviting appearance. Had never eaten there before but went as a birthday dinner and was not disappointed. Next time we are in town, Red Shoe is on top of the list to return too. We love this restaurant!”
“Best seafood dinner I’ve had since 2005 hands down. That’s how good it was‼️The wife and I are in town for our Lucky 13yr anniversary and we were debating between dinner establishments. We settled on this one because it was in close walking distance of Casa. Dinner did not disappoint.”
“We just stopped by for lunch. We ordered the stuffed grape leaves app, a falafel wrap and a Greek salad with chicken. Food was so fresh, and the finishing touches like dried herbs sprinkled on the grape leaves just made it next level. The Tzatziki was out of this world good 🤯. I prefer that over humus so was able to sub that in my wrap. We went in hungry and left stuffed. The place is tiny and so cute with three tables - blue and white tile and decor. Off the beaten path and sooooo worth it. We visit KW a lot and this will definitely be in heavy rotation.”
“Being from Canada we were looking forward to trying this little quirky restaurant on a boat . Ribs and brisket were excellent and best baked beans I’ve ever tasted. Apparently missed the neighbour hood manatee who lives in the port . We would definitely visit again !”
“Due to the weather, I found myself spending another night in Key West. I came across this quaint restaurant near my hotel. Francesca the owner is so sweet and friendly. Mario behind the bar was just great. He really knows the drinks and the food. I had the cream of zucchini soup. It was delicious large portion and great flavor. Two ladies at the bar shared their antipasto tray with me. Enjoyed both the tray and the ladies who shared it. I will definitely make this my first stop the next time I’m in Key West.”
“Nestled in the heart of Key West, hidden from the tourist-heavy streets, is a spot the locals know as a treasure: Glazed Donuts. But this isn’t your typical donut shop. Glazed is a *donut bakery*, and once you grasp the difference, you’ll never settle for just any donut again. Here, the dough is crafted like a masterpiece, and the flavors aren’t just tasted—they’re experienced.
But let’s talk about one particular standout creation: the key lime donut. This isn’t just another Key West homage to the famed key lime pie—this is a revelation. Imagine the tart, bright burst of real key lime, perfectly balanced against a soft, fluffy donut. The glaze is light but tangy, offering just enough sweetness to cut through the citrus while still allowing that signature zing of key lime to shine. It’s like biting into a bite-sized piece of Key West sunshine.
You know that perfect moment when a key lime pie hits that magical balance of creamy tartness and sugary sweetness? Now, imagine that distilled into the ideal donut. With each bite, the soft dough gives way to an explosion of flavor that captures the tropical essence of Key West. It’s refreshing, indulgent, and completely unexpected—transforming the simple donut into an unforgettable taste experience.
If you’re in Key West, trying the key lime donut from Glazed Donuts is a must. Sure, key lime pie is a staple of the island, but this donut could easily rival even the best slice of pie you’ve ever had. In fact, if you were to rank the greatest key lime creations on the island, this donut would be second only to the legendary key lime pie at Old Town Bakery. It’s that good. One bite and you’ll realize that this donut isn’t just a tribute to Key West’s iconic flavor—it’s a new way to savor it.
PSA: At Glazed Donuts, don’t even think about ordering a dozen. That’s not how this works. You’ll grab one, maybe two if you’re feeling adventurous, and then guess what? You’ll be back tomorrow… and the day after that. This isn’t just a donut shop—it’s a donut commitment. Proceed with caution; you might just end up planning your entire week around these donuts!”
“The moment I tasted their key lime pie French toast it was so delicious and it was so elegant and so very tasteful, it was like flavors bursting in my mouth, I literally almost reproduced with the key lime pie French toast. How beautiful and Venust jt was. Bro it was actually so good tho”
“This place was phenomenal all around. The owner greeted us, management all greeted us, and staff was attentive all around. Lobster pizza and the street corn pizza were phenomenal. I loved the Pina colada key lime pie. It is by far the best key lime I have tried. The view, the chickens, all of it!!”
Outdoor Dining
“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I recently visited Sunny Eggs in Key West, and it has quickly become my new favorite spot! The location is simply amazing, providing a perfect backdrop for a delightful evening. The atmosphere is vibrant and inviting, enhanced by fantastic live music that makes you want to stay and soak it all in.
Now, let’s talk about the food – it’s absolutely delicious! Each dish we tried was packed with flavor and beautifully presented. The menu offers a great variety, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
Overall, Sunny Eggs is a must-visit for anyone in Key West. Between the ambiance, the music, and the incredible food, it’s an experience you won't want to miss. I can’t wait to go back!
Dietary restrictions: Have vegan options”
“This place was phenomenal all around. The owner greeted us, management all greeted us, and staff was attentive all around. Lobster pizza and the street corn pizza were phenomenal. I loved the Pina colada key lime pie. It is by far the best key lime I have tried. The view, the chickens, all of it!!”
“Growing up in the Bradenton Florida area, I’ve had my fair share of BBQ but I literally think this was the best I’ve ever eaten anywhere. We tried the ribs, pork belly / burnt ends, brisket and pulled pork sandwiches. All six of us were kind of shocked at how good everything was. The pulled pork sandwich comes with cole slaw on it which I’m not usually a huge fan of but I liked the first bite so much I decided to pass on any sauce to add. Also the pulled pork was the perfect consistency and seasoned to perfection. We also got the mac and cheese which was also moist and flavorful. This was such a pleasant surprise for a Key West trip and I would highly recommend. The only thing that was regrettable was that we didn’t find it until our last day here. If we would’ve tried it earlier in the week we would have visited a second time for sure. Kudos for a job very well done!!!”
“This place was fantastic. I met the owner(s?), they were so warm and friendly. They went above and beyond with their service and knowledge. I fell in love when the gal told me she made all the treats herself and all their packaging was biodegradable. The coffee was phenomenal, like nothing I’ve ever had before. I wish I lived close enough to have it regularly”
“An absolutely hidden gem in Key West. 18 in-house beers that were all very good. There are lots of different beer styles that are all very good. The food menu is perfect for a day of drinking. Their guacamole was superb. The bartender, Angelina, was a joy. Very engaging and knowledgeable about the beer and all things local.”
“To access the restaurant you have to go up to the first floor, it is the typical American bar with people eating at the counter, the food was good, and the price was affordable.
Wheelchair accessibility: As it is a first floor with exterior stairs, it cannot be accessed by wheelchair.”
“Heads up…. Payed for a latte, received a regular coffee no foam. Coffee was weak. What surprised me the most was that they were adamant that it was a latte. Other than that, the food was delicious and the pastry’s were out of this world. Happy dining”
“We’ve been coming hear for seven years, and despite the fact that they’ve opened three other locations, it still a real treat. Many restaurants lose their focus on quality when they spread out, but not Santiago’s. The Al Fresco seating is fantastic, and the menu is updated sufficiently to reward the repeaters who also like something new. Oh, and the Sangria…”
Online Reservation Available
“We’ve been coming hear for seven years, and despite the fact that they’ve opened three other locations, it still a real treat. Many restaurants lose their focus on quality when they spread out, but not Santiago’s. The Al Fresco seating is fantastic, and the menu is updated sufficiently to reward the repeaters who also like something new. Oh, and the Sangria…”
“It was recommended to us by some locals. The atmosphere is elegant, very clean and friendly staff. We had the Hogg fish which they are known for. Absolutely excellent dinner. Reasonably priced for where you are and what we ate. If you're ever in Key West I highly recommend dining here. We didn't call ahead and got right in at opening time. It would probably be a good idea to make a reservation, as we saw many people wait outside when we left. 5 stars ☆☆☆☆☆”
“Amazing restaurant, every last detail thought about when it comes to service, ambience, food, flavor! This place is awesome!! They are certainly aiming to please! We had the lobster risotto, the grouper oscar, escargot and stonecrab appetizer and lobster bisque, dirty martinis!! Finished with some key lime pie!! Ask for the love Nick from Georgia!! ??”
“I’m on vacation and found this place three days ago, been there everyday since. As a Central American the dishes taste just like a homemade breakfast, portions are hefty (just as a breakfast lover like me needs), and the coffee satisfies every taste bud as only Cuban coffee can. The ladies (and gentleman) that work there are kind, quick, and helpful ! Breakfast never tasted so good (I drove during severe weather warnings and thanked the heavens they were open)
Parking: If you really can’t find street parking I’d say use the first few spots (by the bushes) across the street at the advanced auto parts”
“I been visiting White Street Pizza since shortly after its opening. It has always been a restaurant that serves high quality food. The pizzas, along with the specialty small plates, have always been prepared to the highest standard. The desserts are out of this world!
The service is always on point, and always friendly and welcoming.
You gotta visit White Street Pizza!”
“Oh my goodness, what a wonderful experience we had when dining with you on November 30th! The food was incredible and service was outstanding! If you like martinis, they have many to choose from. We celebrated my husband’s birthday with a beautiful sunset view. (Thank you to the staff for making it extra special!)Seriously, a perfect dining experience! When in Key West, definitely dine here!”
“Great dining experience, excellent service, great food and drinks!!! Highly recommended”
“I was looking for true island food, and the Duval Street scene is not for me. Trusted the high review numbers and was not disappointed.
I went with the shrimp creole. The rich seasonings were infused in each bite and only encouraged each next bite. The generous portion ensured I would not leave hungry.
I topped off the meal with a slice of key lime pie. The decadent key lime flavors contrasted the rich consistency of the dessert.
An electric guitar hung nearby with the promise of live music on busier nights. I am certain the ten tables and bar seats quickly fill on weekends.
I left fully satisfied and ducked into Hurricane Helene for a stormy nights rest.”
24 Hour Restaurants
“I booked this hotel for my daughter and friends. They had nothing but praise for the property. It was clean, staff extremely friendly and helpful and the location was perfect. If they get a chance to re-visit Key West, they expressed that they will re-book the same place.”
“A good restaurant and affordable prices for every pocket. I had oysters in a very sour lemon cream but an excellent dish. The hamburger meat wasn't that tasty. Overall, a nice place.”
“It was recommended to us by some locals. The atmosphere is elegant, very clean and friendly staff. We had the Hogg fish which they are known for. Absolutely excellent dinner. Reasonably priced for where you are and what we ate. If you're ever in Key West I highly recommend dining here. We didn't call ahead and got right in at opening time. It would probably be a good idea to make a reservation, as we saw many people wait outside when we left. 5 stars ☆☆☆☆☆”
Takeout Restaurants
“We went there hoping to find gluten free key lime pie and found it but we also ask about if they were a peanut free and no one could give us an answer. ¿They don’t have labels on the pie? Besides that the place is gorgeous!”
“Best cheesesteak I’ve had in a long time! It was so tasty, fresh and hot. I devoured it in minutes! This is a no-frills place, everyone was nice and they treat you right. I was there late at night and it was busy, I could tell there was a great energy from all the happy customers. Highly recommended, especially for a delicious late-night meal.”
“We stayed down the block at a AirBnB so naturally got coffee and breakfast our first morning. It was so delicious we ate breakfast there every morning except for one (we had to leave for the ferry before they opened, so we ate dinner there that night!) All the food was amazing! Well seasoned, fresh, flavorful, and portions were huge! The coffee was perfect, I really loved the cortadito and milk espreso. The staff was friendly and offered recommendations if needed.”
“I was looking for true island food, and the Duval Street scene is not for me. Trusted the high review numbers and was not disappointed.
I went with the shrimp creole. The rich seasonings were infused in each bite and only encouraged each next bite. The generous portion ensured I would not leave hungry.
I topped off the meal with a slice of key lime pie. The decadent key lime flavors contrasted the rich consistency of the dessert.
An electric guitar hung nearby with the promise of live music on busier nights. I am certain the ten tables and bar seats quickly fill on weekends.
I left fully satisfied and ducked into Hurricane Helene for a stormy nights rest.”
“Best Bacon Cheese burger on the Island hands down! Wendy's, McDs and Sonics has nothing on this Mom & Pop corner sandwich shop! If you're looking for a Good burger I can not recommend this shop enough as this they serve the best!. Plus the French Frys are ALWAYS hot and fresh unlike Mcgurggles!!”
“Bartender alone ! She made an Outstanding Old Fashion and grapefruit Martini.”
Drive-Thru Restaurants
“Lovely place for breakfast! Me and my family ate eggs, pancakes, bacon and bread for a really reasonable price. The coffee was really good as well! The two people who ran it were really friendly and were happy to talk to us about Key West after we ate. It is also in a beautiful courtyard with seats both outside and inside.
Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly”
“We stopped in after a exhausting day and we were so glad we did! Great selection of ice cream and snow ice, my kids were thrilled! The ice cream was amazing and so fun! Love the tropical vibe decor and excellent customer service! Don't miss this fun spot for a good treat while in Key West!”
“Good food, fast friendly service. Excellent breakfast burritos. Burgers have gone way downhill the last year or so. Appetizers and sides are always excellent. Fantastic ice cream, and it stays open later than Dairy Queen. EDIT: since my previous review, I suffered a heart attack and developed diabetes, so I haven't been to Sonic since, but my housemates say nothing has changed. Maybe once my health is under control, I can try something other than a Sprite Zero from them again.”
“They have great bands at the Pier. The best in the area in my opinion. Burger was ok but given the atmosphere we were very happy to be able to get food, drinks, people watch and listen to awesome music.”
“Thank you for making my wife's birthday dinner enjoyable. Everything was first class. We have been here many times and Azur is one of our favorites in town.”
Cheap Eats
“Went there yesterday after seeing reviews. Absolutely fantastic food. The owner is very nice and personable. Her food lives up to the hype! Little difficult to find parking, but well worth it. Compared to all the other food we have tried in Key West...she is on a whole other level!”
“This is some of the best Mexican we have had in Key West. The staff is very friendly. I wish I remembered his name but our waiter was so friendly and attentive that we asked if he owned the place. he said no he just worked there but really enjoyed his job. You don't see that much any more!”
“Delicious breakfast of cinnamon butter toast and cafe con leche”
“Friendly staff and clean establishment. My boyfriend was so excited to find authentic shave ice like they have in Hawaii! This was my first time having it like this, and it was delicious plus the portions were huge. Make sure you upgrade to island style!”
“Frenchies is a wonderful little cafe between Simonton and United, only a 1/2 block from Duval St. The owners are French and passionate about delicious breakfast and lunch fare, the staff and the huggable pup Gaston make this a place sure to bring a smile. My favorites are the salads, anything from the pastry and dessert cases, omelets and the French Toast soaked in cream is the best I've ever enjoyed. It's small, come early, they are open 7am to 2pm daily, closed on Wednesdays during the summer only.”
“Amazing service, food and atmosphere! Definitely a hidden gem within Key West. A must try if you are in the area”
“Mark is wonderful and knows his wine! We were visiting for my husbands 30th and our hotel put us in touch with Mark. He helped get a wonderful wine and snack selection together for us to have in our room for the time of our stay! We went and visited him at his shop and had the best conversation, and even got another bottle of yummy wine! Do your self a favor and stop in while you’re in town, he also has wonderful dining suggestions…. Listen to him for good food!!!”
“The best bang for your buck on their late night menu. Bartenders are amazing and very friendly.
Food and drinks: The best bang for your buck on their late night menu. Bartenders are amazing and very friendly.”
“Had the Mr. Neil last night Was amazing, tons of tuna and spice, chili oil”
“Fast, fresh delivery. Visiting the area and pleased to have such delicious food delivered so quickly! Spinach samosas were hot and steamy upon arrival and delicious. Falafel and gyro platter come with fresh roasted vegetables- a nice, fresh non-fried choice in the keys”
“Have been there twice. Last year was amazing. Everything perfect. This year, the special was prawn (not gulf coast shrimp as specified) and the prawn had the seafood stank, unlike typical fresh seafood. Didn’t want to cause a stink. Way overpaid IMO, we’ll be back about a 50:50 shot. Wasn’t busy? Perhaps off season? Idk.”
“Many people recommended this place in Key West. We arrived with five people, and they only allowed us to sit at a small table where four would barely fit! There was a bigger table available, as two tables had just been pushed together and the guests had left, but the waitress wouldn’t let us sit there. The atmosphere was great, so I would still definitely recommend the place! The food is simple but tasty. Fortunately, another waiter came to our table and he was very kind!”
“Amazing restaurant, every last detail thought about when it comes to service, ambience, food, flavor! This place is awesome!! They are certainly aiming to please! We had the lobster risotto, the grouper oscar, escargot and stonecrab appetizer and lobster bisque, dirty martinis!! Finished with some key lime pie!! Ask for the love Nick from Georgia!! ??”
“Great food experience - plus Eric behind the bar is exceptional!! A should not be missed Key West place if you want a refined night out!!”
“We had a great time at Irish Kevin’s… great support of our military folks!”
“Food was spectacular; service low key (pun intended) and great limeades”
“Oh my goodness, what a wonderful experience we had when dining with you on November 30th! The food was incredible and service was outstanding! If you like martinis, they have many to choose from. We celebrated my husband’s birthday with a beautiful sunset view. (Thank you to the staff for making it extra special!)Seriously, a perfect dining experience! When in Key West, definitely dine here!”
“We had the best food and service while visiting Key West in June. Can wait to go back on our visit next weekend!”
“Best dinner on the island! Four of us luckily got a late reservation on a rainy Christmas evening (2023). Food was fabulous! Service top-notch. Great atmosphere. Nice specials were offered for a holiday dinner.”
“Amazing food! Their service is outstanding and they handled our crowd flawlessly! Do yourself a favor and hire them!”
“Simply our favorite in Key West and we've been there many times. Wine is outstanding, food is excellent and surprisingly a great selection of beer including some of the best Belgiums.
Then they add service with personality. Look for this place and you're welcome!!”
“OUTSTANDING!! OUTSTANDING!! OUTSTANDING!! Only way to describe my recent experience at Chef Richie’s Lola’s Bistro. Incredible dinner with amazing sauces. Everything was great from start to finish. Will definitely eat here again. Two seatings 6:00 & 8:00. It’s BYOB. Best meal I’ve had in a long time. This place is a home run. Make sure to call ahead for reservations.”
“Lovely anniversary dinner. Excellent service and meal. They had a sign on our table wishing us a happy Anniversary and we had the best view of the sunset!!”