Dessert Restaurants in Key West, FL

“A Getaway to key west Hubby Wifey Time Celebrated our 12 year anniversary ❤️ Absolutely loved this place. Everything was delicious!! Menu was naughty and fun 🤩 Loved it!! Loved the French Kiss 💋 and the Fourgasm❤️“

“Everything in here looked decadent. A place where you wish you could try everything. We came as soon as we researched Dubai Chocolate and found this shop near us. It exceeded our expectations was incredibly rich in flavor and great texture. I also had to have the Turkish coffee. One the best cups I've ever had. If you like dark dark coffee that is smooth; it is a must have. Our host was very nice and she gave us great service.“

“As someone who is gluten free I was ecstatic to receive a box of gluten free cupcake sushi. They taste amazing! No one even knew they were gluten free as I shared them. Thank you for making them so I could have something sweet for my birthday! I will be ordering more now that I know I can eat them!“

“Really good ice cream and so much more.“

“I would like to express my sincere gratitude for the outstanding service! From the moment we arrived, we were welcomed by Aiko with warm smiles, genuine hospitality, and exceptional attention to detail. Aiko was friendly, professional, and went above and beyond to make our visit truly enjoyable.
A special compliment goes to the Key Lime Pie — it was absolutely amazing! The perfect balance of sweetness and tanginess, the fresh ingredients, and the smooth, creamy texture made it unforgettable. It is truly one of the best Key Lime Pies I have ever tasted!
Thank you for creating such a wonderful atmosphere and providing an exceptional dining experience. We will definitely be back and will gladly recommend you to our friends and family!“

“7/26
This was our 1st trip to Key West and we arrived via Celebrity Reflection Cruise Ship. We love Key Like Pie and was trying to find the best in Key West. If you like a more tart filling than Kermit’s is for you! However, if you like a less tart filling and an awesome crust, then Mattheessen’s is for you.“

“We stopped in after a exhausting day and we were so glad we did! Great selection of ice cream and snow ice, my kids were thrilled! The ice cream was amazing and so fun! Love the tropical vibe decor and excellent customer service! Don't miss this fun spot for a good treat while in Key West!“

“From one ice cream shop to another — you made our Top 10! 🍦 We love to travel, and every trip includes a little “market research” at all the local ice cream and candy shops. It’s been a while since we’ve been in, but we haven’t forgotten you — and we’ll definitely be back soon! In celebration of National Ice Cream Month, we wanted to give a shoutout to one of the greats. Keep up the amazing work! If you are ever in Wilburton Oklahoma, stop in and say hello! #WilburtonIceCream #PaxsonsPopCreamery“

“Where do I begin? My mom and I are die hard REAL Key Lime Pie fans living in VA. It is so difficult to find a good key lime pie here.

Recently a friend of mine went to the Keys for her anniversary and as a thank you for watching her dogs, had a pie shipped to me.

It was just delivered…… first bite…. Oh my lanta…. Heaven. Pure blissful heaven.“