9 Best Bakeries in Key West

Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shop - Elizabeth Street Bakery • $
200 Elizabeth St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie
Coconut Key Lime Pie Slice
Key Lime Pie in Key West
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Strawberry Key Lime Pie
Authentic Key Lime Pie
Chocolate Key Lime Pie
Original Key Lime Pie
Slice of Key Lime Pie

“Keylime pie was great, just like I expected. I did the strawberry Keylime pie and the chocolate covered Keylime pie, both were good. I think I may have surprisingly preferred the chocolate covered Keylime pie. And I typically am not a fan of Keylime pie“

4.6 Superb804 Reviews
Moondog Cafe Cafe • $$
823 Whitehead St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries with Key Lime Curry Sauce
Blackened Local Mahi Tacos
Caprese Croissant Benedict
The Elvis French Toast
The Classic Benedict
Brioche French Toast
Banana Cream Pie
Seafood Omelette
Breakfast Tacos
Hipster Burger

“Heads up…. Payed for a latte, received a regular coffee no foam. Coffee was weak. What surprised me the most was that they were adamant that it was a latte. Other than that, the food was delicious and the pastry’s were out of this world. Happy dining“

4.7 Superb954 Reviews
Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shop - 335F Duval Street Bakery • $$
335F Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie and the Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Key Lime Pie Slice Gluten Free
Chocolate Key Lime Pie Slice
Strawberry Key Lime Pie
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie
Regular Key Lime Pie
To Go Key Lime Pie
Gluten Free Items
Key Lime Treats
Gift Basket

“That was the best key lime pie of my life even warm. The lady told us not to wait longer than 30 mins cause we were walking around but we forgot about it and remembered several hours later and it was still incredibly good. Perfect amount of sour to sweet ratio as someone who doesn't like super sweet things. The strawberry was to die for and the vibe was soooo cute.“

4.5 Superb470 Reviews
Mattheessen's Homemade Bakery • $
106 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Brownie with Vanilla Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Fudge Cookies
Delce De Leche Ice Cream
Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Cuban Coffee Ice-Cream
Chocolatechip Cookies
Big Half Pound Cookie
Peanut Butter Cookie
Baked Key Lime Pie
Chocolate Brownie

“Really good ice cream and so much more.“

4.6 Superb349 Reviews
Old Town Bakery Bakery • $
930 Eaton Street, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Curry Chicken Salad Sandwich
Ham \u0026 Cheese Croissant
Ham & Cheese Croissant
CHC-Key Lime Pie Slice
Peach Cobbler Danish
Keywest Chicken Wrap
Chocolate Croissant
Breakfast Sandwich
Classic Croissant
Breakfast Burrito

“Breakfasts sandwiches ,burritos and coffee“

4.5 Superb433 Reviews
Key West Cakes Bakery • $
2510 North Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Cupcake
Vanilla Cupcake
Key Lime Cake
Birthday Cake
Key Lime Pie
Wedding Cake
Cupcakes
Bakery
Mochi

“We came from out of town for our friends birthday and ordered a cake for her ahead. We were running late to pick up the cake and they stayed open later for us to pick it up, which was so thoughtful of them. The cake itself turned out beautiful and exactly how I pictured it, tasted amazing as well! Highly recommend based on service and quality!!!“

4.7 Superb224 Reviews
Key Lime Pie Bakery Bakery • $
412 Greene St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie Bar
Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Pie Slice Key West
Key Lime Cheesecake
Original Whole Pie
Key Lime Milkshake
Mini Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Coconut
Key Lime Float

“Best pie and service ever“

4.3 Superb440 Reviews
The Coconut Factory Bakery • $$
414 Greene St, Key West

“Best Key Lime pie here…! Paired w key Lime ice cream for the win!“

4.3 Superb61 Reviews
River Street Sweets Ice Cream Shop • $$
400 Duval St B, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Double Waffle Cone
Single Waffle Cone
Caramel Turtles
Cookie Dough
Double Scoop
Praline
Gelato
Taffy

“The ice cream I got was so delicious. The staff was also so kind. I walked in there and asked if there was an ice cream for under $5, since that was all I had with me. He said no and as I was about to leave, he got me two scoops of vanilla. Would highly recommend“

3.9 Good172 Reviews