10 Best Bakeries in Key West

“The establishment maintained a high standard of cleanliness, contributing to a pleasant atmosphere. The key lime pie, while well-prepared, presented a level of tartness that exceeded my personal preference, and the presence of cinnamon in the crust was not to my liking. This appears to be a matter of individual taste. The key lime coconut ice cream shared a similar flavor profile with the pie, though I found the chocolate covering to be particularly enjoyable.

The customer service was exemplary; despite a high volume of patrons, the staff efficiently managed the flow, ensuring prompt service.

I would highly recommend this establishment to individuals who appreciate key lime pie or those interested in exploring a variety of distinct flavors.“

“Breakfasts sandwiches ,burritos and coffee“

“Their coffee is the best! I visited in person once and am now hooked on their love ln espresso. I order it online and only use their coffee. They even send a little personalized note in the package!“

“We tried two flavors - the original key lime pie and the coconut key lime pie - and both were amazing. The original captured the classic, traditional key lime pie flavor perfectly. The coconut version was even better, at least for me - the sweetness of the coconut balanced out the tartness of the lime, creating a smoother, more comforting taste.

We’d absolutely love to go back and try more, especially since we couldn’t find anything like this in downtown Miami.“

“Really good ice cream and so much more.“

“Key West Cakes exceeded our expectations! Our cake was delivered before we even arrived at the venue and was completely ready for us, making the entire process stress-free. The attention to detail was immaculate, and the cake tasted absolutely amazing.

We had a small wedding party and ordered the one-tier cake, and it was everything we asked for and more. They truly went above and beyond to make our day special. Highly recommend!“

“Best pie and service ever“

“Heads up…. Payed for a latte, received a regular coffee no foam. Coffee was weak. What surprised me the most was that they were adamant that it was a latte. Other than that, the food was delicious and the pastry’s were out of this world. Happy dining“

“One of the owners Dennis is so very accommodating. He is one of our favorite people formerly of TandT. Wonderful gentleman. So happy the business is so successful.“

“The ice cream I got was so delicious. The staff was also so kind. I walked in there and asked if there was an ice cream for under $5, since that was all I had with me. He said no and as I was about to leave, he got me two scoops of vanilla. Would highly recommend“