Mattheessen's Homemade

$ • Bakery, Ice Cream, Coffee Shops

About Mattheessen's Homemade

Mattheessen's Homemade is a popular spot in Key West, famous for its homemade cookies and desserts. The chocolate chip cookies are moist and chewy, and the brownie explosion is a large, decadent treat. The snickerdoodle cookies and chocolate milkshake are also highly appreciated, with good service to match. The dense, buttery, and perfectly chewy cookies, including the chocolate chip with pecans and peanut butter with chocolate fudge, are favorites that can brighten anyone’s day. Visitors have also enjoyed local ice cream and Keylime pie dipped in chocolate, which adds a fun twist to traditional desserts. The owner and staff are attentive, though some customers have experienced confusion about prices and billing, so it’s advised to double-check bills. Parking is available on the street, but many find walking from nearby resorts easier. Overall, Mattheessen's offers tasty treats and a lively atmosphere, making it a must-visit for dessert lovers in Key West.