Browse menus, reviews and photos of Caribbean Restaurants in Key West.
Caribbean · $$
1116 White Street, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“I don’t even do food reviews but the Oxtails , the rice and beans , the fried plantains , and the cooked vegetables… all I can say is wow. If I could rewind time and eat it again for the first time I’d start crying first bite. SO GOOD”
Caribbean · $$
618 Duval Street, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“this restaurant is one of the best in Key West. It has an exceptional atmosphere, extensive menu and great service. We were pleased with all that this restaurant has to offer including impeccable drinks and food selections. We were delighted to have Mercedes as our server and she did everything possible to make us feel like family.”
Caribbean · $
1824 Flagler Avenue, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“Everything I’ve tried here has been DELICIOUS! I highly recommend. Especially the tequeños!”
Cuban · $$
900 Catherine Street, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“Great food and friendly staff!”
New American · $$
424 Eaton Street, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“Nice atmosphere inside, friendly owners and staff. GREAT FOOD!”
Caribbean · $$
1 Duval Street, Key West
“The restaurant is located right on the front of the key to the west and affords a great spot to watch the sunset. The staff were attentive and the food tasted great. The restaurant itself is new modern and has great rest rooms. We had the surf and turf for $48 and both the steak and the lobster were cooked to perfection. Def recommend this place. We had the perfect pina colada priced at $10 a drink which was strong and delicious. My tip book the place for sunset watch the magnificent view with a great drink in your hands.”
Pet Friendly · $
1107 Simonton Street, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“the fish and chips were sooo good!!!!”
Caribbean · $$
1405 Duval Street, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“2025 Key West Caravan with Central Florida Corvette Association (CFCA) friends - we come every year. This year we discovered the Southernmost Beach Cafe- Very Nice... Great breakfast feast, great service and a wonderful atmosphere looking right out at the beach. Update October 2026 13 of the CFCA member made a return trip to the Southernmost Beach Cafe and once again we are so glad that we did . Food was great and the service was wonderful. Obie & Ramona Young ** OBIE ** Florida Aviation Network”
American · $$
804 Whitehead Street, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“Great vibe and probably the best eggs Benedict I’ve ever had in my life Great service by Costa who kept us smiling and hydrated with lots of water to accompany our breakfast cocktail. Really enjoyable and will certainly go back whenever we get to Key West !”
Jamaican · $$
508 Southard Street Ste 101, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“I scoped out this place before traveling here as I love Jerk chicken ! This place did not disappoint ! Very casual and about 8 stools - but the food was spectacular! The ox tail were beyond amazing - the jerk chicken was delicious along with rice and beans and the festivals ( like fried dough pieces ) So good you will not be disappointed !!”
Cuban · $
934 Truman Avenue, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“Great Cuban coffee and breakfast; warm and friendly staff, great service, and delicious food.”
Seafood · $$
700 Duval Street, Key West
Customers’ favorites
“We stopped for lunch which was amazing! The space was beautiful, especially the back courtyard. If we had more time, I would have stopped again.”