50 Best American Restaurants in Key West

“Lovely anniversary dinner. Excellent service and meal. They had a sign on our table wishing us a happy Anniversary and we had the best view of the sunset!!“

“Good breakfast with the roosters! Loved it!“

“Amazing food! Very friendly and attentive staff. Did I mention amazing food! Thank you for a great time!“

“Awesome restaurant and menu. Very, very friendly service!“

“Best seafood dinner I’ve had since 2005 hands down. That’s how good it was‼️The wife and I are in town for our Lucky 13yr anniversary and we were debating between dinner establishments. We settled on this one because it was in close walking distance of Casa. Dinner did not disappoint.“

“One of the best hotel and cafe restaurants in key west“

“We were guests for dinner and very happy with our choice., The cocktails were superb and our meal very good. Probably not a,ways easy to get in but this was a Sunday in September and it was not too busy. This is outside under cover with a very relaxed atmosphere out by tge beach bar. This was what we were looking for. This is Key West after all. Kt Venice fl“

“Great dining experience, excellent service, great food and drinks!!! Highly recommended“

“The moment I tasted their key lime pie French toast it was so delicious and it was so elegant and so very tasteful, it was like flavors bursting in my mouth, I literally almost reproduced with the key lime pie French toast. How beautiful and Venust jt was. Bro it was actually so good tho“

“Growing up in the Bradenton Florida area, I’ve had my fair share of BBQ but I literally think this was the best I’ve ever eaten anywhere. We tried the ribs, pork belly / burnt ends, brisket and pulled pork sandwiches. All six of us were kind of shocked at how good everything was. The pulled pork sandwich comes with cole slaw on it which I’m not usually a huge fan of but I liked the first bite so much I decided to pass on any sauce to add. Also the pulled pork was the perfect consistency and seasoned to perfection. We also got the mac and cheese which was also moist and flavorful. This was such a pleasant surprise for a Key West trip and I would highly recommend. The only thing that was regrettable was that we didn’t find it until our last day here. If we would’ve tried it earlier in the week we would have visited a second time for sure. Kudos for a job very well done!!!“

“It was great! Thanks Lenny for the good help, the good cocktails and the good food! �“

“if you know you know. I plan my key west trips around Mary Ellen's calendar....... especially Thursdays. I have the best time every time I go. it never lets you down.“

“I went there because the Korean reviews were pretty good, but personally, the tacos in Korea or the American mainland tasted better. It doesn't taste like the tacos I know, whether it's guacamole, salsa, or sour cream, but the Korean BBQ tastes like real Korean bulgogi (a little saltier). , I wanted to eat white rice, even though it is a tourist area, 2 pieces cost over $15.“

“Great food and drinks-Enjoy.“

“Always a fun time & loved the veggie quesadilla“

“Went to dinner at the bar before a show my wife had the best margarita of her life. Long haired bartender was entertaining and attentive. great place! great food! Tacos rock. highly recommend going there.“

“Excellent food. Their tomato bisque! Historic building. Charming.“

“Amazing food! Their service is outstanding and they handled our crowd flawlessly! Do yourself a favor and hire them!“

“Great atmosphere,great food and service. We’re definitely coming back. When you’re visiting Key West make plans to stop here for lunch or dinner.“

“Cajun Chicken Pasta was excellent. I'll be back for it !“

“Not sure what happened but when they opened the food was 5 star. Food now is good but not what it was when they opened. Happy hour is good. Good buck for you money.“

“I Went Tuesday And ENJOYED The Conch ChowdAH And Will Return.“

“2nd time staying at this resort. Love everything about it the rooms, pool, service and people. Hanna the manager is awesome she is very friendly and is a rockstar at what she does. This is our home away from home. Very close to down town and a perfect place to relax and stay. I would give it more then five stars if I could.“

“The food was awesome and everyone was so friendly and welcoming.“

“A wonderful atmosphere and the staff are very friendly and make you feel a part of the family. The food is top notch and has an inviting appearance. Had never eaten there before but went as a birthday dinner and was not disappointed. Next time we are in town, Red Shoe is on top of the list to return too. We love this restaurant!“

“Great vibe and kid friendly atmosphere. Perfectly captures the island fun meets luxury food and adult drink options and not at all overpriced. Highly recommend“

“Happy hour with oysters and Margaritas. Perfect.“

“Tonight was our second time here and it was just as perfect. Being from Charleston SC we have been to some excellent restaurants and this is right up there. The atmosphere, view, service, and food are all 110%“

“My husband and I absolutely loved this place. The dj was awesome, it was adults mixed with families just enjoying an outdoor pool, amazing bar, great views and awesome drinks! Can’t wait to go back. I’d highly recommend while you’re in Key West!“

“Honestly, from the outside looking in, it didn't look like anything special. But once we were inside and able to see and experience the ambiance, it was great. We are fans of the Margaritaville brand, so this being "the original" it was a must for us. We're glad we went.“

“Yummy conch fritters and the Bahamian Lobster was so luscious.“

“Nicole was GREAT! We stopped in on a hot day and she brought ice cold drinks immediately. Great service!!

Dietary restrictions: We have dairy, nut, and seafood/shellfish allergies and Nicole was great at easing our anxieties about eating out!“

“We were looking for a refined outdoor dining experience in Key West and we found it within the Casa Marina. We dine both in the evening and for lunch. Their excellent waitstaff and those that support them were genuine and timely. As for the our entree selections they were well portioned and delicious. It was indeed a different dining experience from anything we experienced while in Key West. We will return and have already shared our experience with friends and family if the decide to visit Key West in the future.“

“Try the whole yellow snapper, it's great! Crispy outside, meat fell off without bones. The vegetables were fresh and seasoned well. My husband tried the fried peanut butter and jelly sandwich. He did not complain, exactly what he expected.“

“Thank you for making my wife's birthday dinner enjoyable. Everything was first class. We have been here many times and Azur is one of our favorites in town.“

“This is the second time we have come in less than 4 months. It's a perfect view. The port offers drinks, meals and snacks to accompany it. Also on some occasions they bring live musicians and DJs to give the last touch to this incredible place. If you are in Key West, you can't miss this view!“

“All I can say is check this place out! The food is amazing!“

“Very Friendly! Great roll!“

“The party definitely never stope here! The food was delicious (try the sloppy joe with cheese) and a great drink menu. Live band played when we were there, and they sounded great!

Kid-friendliness: My son had a blast. He loved listening to the band. He also said the hot dog was delicious!“

“Excellent staff and owner who cares about everyone.“

“Great food experience - plus Eric behind the bar is exceptional!! A should not be missed Key West place if you want a refined night out!!“

“Wonderful locally owned shop with an amazing staff. Excellent food! A must try and repeat in Key West.“

“OMG the breakfast burrito was AH-MAZE-ING! I was skeptical about the rice inside, but it actually made it better! And the side of cilantro sauce was incredible. Plus pleasant people and very quick service. Cafe con leche was also perfect. We did takeout and she made it when we got there. I'd give you 10 stars if I could. Thank you!“

“Beautiful place great staff“

“We popped in for lunch not knowing anything about the place. Restaurant did not disappoint. Sliders were a perfect size and the fish sandwich of the day was Mahi. Both my husband and I very pleased. Recommend trying“

“Great experience during lunch. Go straight to the bar. It’s on the water. Beat the dinner crowd and enjoy a great view during a lunch visit. Much more relaxing! No reason to fight the crowds at night.“

“Very good food - we had spaghetti with fish variations, ribeye steak, tenderloin strips and surf & turf. Everything prepared to perfection, great quality. The salad is also highly recommended. The prices are high, but reasonable. The four of us paid $200 + tip including drinks.“

“Great experience during lunch. Go straight to the bar. It’s on the water. Beat the dinner crowd and enjoy a great view during a lunch visit. Much more relaxing! No reason to fight the crowds at night.“

“tasty brunch followed by relaxing on the beach. Kids loved it here“

“While staying at the Hyatt Centric, my wife and I took full advantage of the bar, spa, and pool. There was a server walking the pool area taking orders, and she was very timely and on top of our orders.We loved our experience. I also loved the roosters, personally.On our first night from the Hyatt, we ordered room service from here, and the order was quick, accurate, and tasty. Also, they didn't skimp on the to-go wine! Awesome service.It was so good that we ate there again 2 days later and took in the views.“