15 Best Italian Restaurants in Key West

“Had dinner at Bruchetta last night. everything was spot on from the mocktail and Becks NA to our Gelato dessert. We shared the Classico Bruchetta, the TRIO and the Gelato. We had the Trio with Picante that was spot on. The shrimp and fish were great but the surprise was the size and tenderness of the spiney lobster tail. The Sicilian spaghetti was another surprise. I am not a pasta lover and this was so good. our server Jimmy was very helpful and his recommendations sealed the deal. This is not cheap but worth it. I will gladly come again next year.“

“Oh my goodness, what a wonderful experience we had when dining with you on November 30th! The food was incredible and service was outstanding! If you like martinis, they have many to choose from. We celebrated my husband’s birthday with a beautiful sunset view. (Thank you to the staff for making it extra special!)Seriously, a perfect dining experience! When in Key West, definitely dine here!“

“Excellent food, above average friendly service and a warm cozy atmosphere! Spaghetti & meatballs and eggplant parm were both plentiful & delicious! Cool little bar, not a bad seat in the place! Looking forward to coming back again next year.“

“This restaurant is a hidden gem in Key West. Our meals were delicous, the service was excellent & we were able to sit outside on the beautiful patio. This restaurant by far is my favorite one in Key West.“

“lasagna soggy, not a greek salad, spaghetti sauce taste like ketchup, bruschella bread was hard. not good food at all. high prices our server was great. You call this a greek salad🤮🤮🤮“

“Best meatballs ever! Then my husband and I split a thin 12” pepperoni and mushroom - oh so good! Quaint and cozy! We shared a large table with other visitors and it made it festive. Service was wonderful. Beer and wine selection is generous. We stayed up the road and it was only a brief walk in the historic neighborhood. Highly recommend. My favorite meal while visiting Key West!“

“Best pizza. Owner handed the pizza to us like she cared so much for us So much love in this place and the food.“

“The food was excellent; my wife had the hog fish special and I had the chicken parmigiana. We split chocolate mousse for dessert. The service was excellent. Highly recommended!!“

“Absolutely loved our experience at Antonia’s! The food was delicious, the atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the service made the night even better. Our server Stefany was amazing, super friendly, attentive and made sure we had everything we needed throughout our meal. She truly made us feel so well taken care of. Definitely a wonderful spot in Key West, and we’ll be coming back! Highly recommend!“

“OUTSTANDING!! OUTSTANDING!! OUTSTANDING!! Only way to describe my recent experience at Chef Richie’s Lola’s Bistro. Incredible dinner with amazing sauces. Everything was great from start to finish. Will definitely eat here again. Two seatings 6:00 & 8:00. It’s BYOB. Best meal I’ve had in a long time. This place is a home run. Make sure to call ahead for reservations.“

“This restaurant was amazing! The food was fabulous and the staff makes your meal a true experience. Vladimir our server was great, but Fletcher the manager made it an unforgettable evening.“

“Lasagna pizza.....say no more. 😎“

“Absolutely wonderful food! Pizza, calzone, and carbonara were delicious! Calamari and caprese appetizers were fabulous too and atmosphere and service was top-notch! Highly recommend the location on Duval, down the alley!!“

“My husband and I have been coming here for years. It’s exceptional. We never have any problems with dietary restrictions and the service is 10/10“

“My partner and I had a really rough night and day, we came to Big John's Pizzaria in Key West and the staff was so friendly, shout out to Colton who went out of his way to extend some kindness and it turned our whole night around. THE FOOD IS TO DIE FOR AS WELL!“