Angelina's Pizzeria
208 Duval St #6508, Key West
(305) 296-3600
Customers' Favorites
Angelina's Loaded Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Sausage Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Slice Cheese Slice
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Angelina's Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pizza Margherita
Hawaiian Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Loaded Slice
Menu
Photos
+55 photos
+54 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Conclusion first: If you’re questing for good vibes, great pizza, and even greater service — this is your tavern.
The staff at Angelina’s were genuinely kind, like NPCs programmed with nothing but helpful dialogue. Super friendly, attentive, and quick with a smile. Drinks? Offered for free when asked, and not just a sip — generously poured, like from a bottomless goblet of refreshment.
The pizza itself? Crispy, cheesy, and flavorful...
The staff at Angelina’s were genuinely kind, like NPCs programmed with nothing but helpful dialogue. Super friendly, attentive, and quick with a smile. Drinks? Offered for free when asked, and not just a sip — generously poured, like from a bottomless goblet of refreshment.
The pizza itself? Crispy, cheesy, and flavorful...
Firstly, very nice people. They were patient even at the end of the day, great. They explained me all I needed and followed all the instructions. I would not say best of the Pizzas but their dough was good enough to go again if I had to eat pizza in this place.
Don’t forget to ask for the coins if you need to visit restrooms.
Don’t forget to ask for the coins if you need to visit restrooms.
You May Also Like
Sloppy Joe's Bar - 201 Duval St
![]()
Bar, American, Salad, Pizza, Pet Friendly
Key West Taco Dog Food Stand - 208 Duval St #204
![]()
Hot Dogs, Food Trucks, Tacos, Pet Friendly
They have beer on tap, by the glass or by the pitcher. Seating is just outside.. usually you can find a spot to sit.
We had a simple pepperoni pie. Large was 33$ and could handle three adults easily. Nice sauce and the dough was delicious.