We come from Lancaster County Pennsylvania, where there’s Cow to come ice cream on Every corner, yours is amazing what’s more, we were Here almost twenty years ago (maybe 18 or 19) I said to Katie last night “were ya’ll Here 20 years ago She said Yes!!!! We’ve been proudly serving for like forty years!!!!” She was WONDERFUL The best ever really you meet some people occasionally who serve others with a Kind Heart interested in Helping others she’s one of them, and the ice cream was spectacular too, a can’t miss on your list of Key West Experiences
Greg Myers
Excellent
Kyle Curry
Great place to stop for some ice cream after walking around and people watching.
Wandered Off
A scoop of Coconut and Cuban Coffee was delish!!
Ilya Semenyuk
Big scoops! A ton of very good flavors!
Rey Kinney
Great shop. Very friendly staff. We always stop in when we are in the keys.
Melissa Allen
Wow on unique flavors at this location! It was delicious and I loved sampling the different varieties they had! Definitely try this place out! It was fabulous!
Tracy Cannon
Whoever was working tonight was so sweet,attentive and helpful. And I'm sure we were annoying with all our questions but she seemed to really enjoy helping. The strawberry ice cream was super fruity n creamy. Loved the chocolate chip. It was just like we used to get when I was a kid. Light flaky chocolate chips. Lots of chocolate. Was not a huge fan if the chocolate amaretto. Promising but it had a slightly fake alcohol flavor to it. Maybe a minor adjustment in the recipe would fix it. The best by far BANANA CINNAMON! Light, fluffy, and velvety and a little sweeter. It's my new favorite. Anyhow definitely the best ice cream in Key West. We've had them all. This one is the most flavorful and absolute best service.
Jade S
lavender and coconut so yummy
Crystal Gail Smith
I have the Irish whiskey milkshake. It was excellent.
Favorite and best ice cream place in Key West. Katie is very friendly and remember us every time we go back! 10/10 recommend ☺️
Nysa Tiwari
This place needs more credit on the island as it definitely seems underrated. They have so many fun and fresh flavors to offer and some local ones like Cuban coffee and key lime. They also have variety as they serve sorbets, frozen yoghurt and gelato-style ice cream. I had the coconut and guava and both of them are excellent. The coconut has actually shreds of coconut that gives it a nice texture and the guava is the prettiest color. It did get a little crowded and chaotic while I was there as there was only one person running it but she was super nice about offering samples and being patient. Highly recommend just dropping by as you walk around!
Uncorked 08
A must do for the best ice cream and the very best service! Amazing flavors and the sweetest girl behind the counter! Thank you Katie!!! Wonderful to meet you.
chad helmke
Go to flamingo crossing say hi to Katie and try the soursop in a cone!! The true key west experience she will treat you like family!
Candace Courtway
Super fresh ice cream with fun tropical flavors. Huge scoops! A Key West must.
We come from Lancaster County Pennsylvania, where there’s Cow to come ice cream on Every corner, yours is amazing what’s more, we were Here almost twenty years ago (maybe 18 or 19) I said to Katie last night “were ya’ll Here 20 years ago She said Yes!!!! We’ve been proudly serving for like forty years!!!!” She was WONDERFUL The best ever really you meet some people occasionally who serve others with a Kind Heart interested in Helping others she’s one of them, and the ice cream was spectacular too, a can’t miss on your list of Key West Experiences
Excellent
Great place to stop for some ice cream after walking around and people watching.
A scoop of Coconut and Cuban Coffee was delish!!
Big scoops! A ton of very good flavors!
Great shop. Very friendly staff. We always stop in when we are in the keys.
Wow on unique flavors at this location! It was delicious and I loved sampling the different varieties they had! Definitely try this place out! It was fabulous!
Whoever was working tonight was so sweet,attentive and helpful.
And I'm sure we were annoying with all our questions but she seemed to really enjoy helping. The strawberry ice cream was super fruity n creamy. Loved the chocolate chip. It was just like we used to get when I was a kid. Light flaky chocolate chips. Lots of chocolate. Was not a huge fan if the chocolate amaretto. Promising but it had a slightly fake alcohol flavor to it. Maybe a minor adjustment in the recipe would fix it. The best by far BANANA CINNAMON! Light, fluffy, and velvety and a little sweeter. It's my new favorite. Anyhow definitely the best ice cream in Key West. We've had them all. This one is the most flavorful and absolute best service.
lavender and coconut so yummy
I have the Irish whiskey milkshake. It was excellent.
Restaurantji Recommends
Favorite and best ice cream place in Key West. Katie is very friendly and remember us every time we go back! 10/10 recommend ☺️
This place needs more credit on the island as it definitely seems underrated. They have so many fun and fresh flavors to offer and some local ones like Cuban coffee and key lime. They also have variety as they serve sorbets, frozen yoghurt and gelato-style ice cream. I had the coconut and guava and both of them are excellent. The coconut has actually shreds of coconut that gives it a nice texture and the guava is the prettiest color. It did get a little crowded and chaotic while I was there as there was only one person running it but she was super nice about offering samples and being patient. Highly recommend just dropping by as you walk around!
A must do for the best ice cream and the very best service! Amazing flavors and the sweetest girl behind the counter!
Thank you Katie!!! Wonderful to meet you.
Go to flamingo crossing say hi to Katie and try the soursop in a cone!! The true key west experience she will treat you like family!
Super fresh ice cream with fun tropical flavors. Huge scoops! A Key West must.
Loading...