Great place to people watch and have amazing local food!! Conch fritters and Peppered Ahi Tuna is out of the world!! And may be the best Key Lime pie on the island!!
Fancypants
We have been down here 8 days for our honeymoon and have been here 5 times, twice in 1 day. The food is good, the drinks are amazing and keep us coming back. All the staff has been super friendly and make us feel welcome. The way they treat you is so different from a lot of the places on Duval. I highly recommend the Banana Breeze with an extra vanilla shot, the Mahi Mahi bites were delicious.
Rani Walker
Good food good drinks good service and location right in the party scene
Ghost Hunter
Great food and drinks.. great service
Gene Arrow
The food was great. The unfortunate part that my credit card was charged an extra $158. Be aware and make sure to take a photo of the receipt — not a trustable place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
T S
Right on Duval Street. So the background noise.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rippchen Und Salat
William Hammond
The drinks are fantastic, and the girls behind the bar are the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taylor Nicole
Fogartys was one of our favorite places to eat. Maxwell was our server and he was great! he has a wonderful personality and made sure we were well taken care of. Slushy drinks were made extremely well, and food was delicious. atmosphere was fun and laid back. 5/5 would highly recommend and definitely on our list of places to visit again in our next visit.
Jeffrey Primeau
Love the frozen drinks and atmosphere
Katha
We had a fantastic dining experience at this restaurant! The food (espacially the shrimp) was fresh, delicious, and full of flavor. Our server, Sarah, was exceptionally attentive and friendly, offering wonderful recommendations that really enhanced our meal. The restaurant manager was also very welcoming and genuinely cared about ensuring all guests were having a great time and were satisfied with their experience. We highly recommend this restaurant for its excellent dishes and amazing frozen drinks
During our visit to Key West, we decided to have lunch at Fogarty's, attracted by its central location and casual ambiance. The overall experience was okay, but with some areas for improvement.
The menu at Fogarty's is diverse, offering a wide selection of classic American dishes. Our dishes were well presented and the portions generous. However, the taste quality was uneven: some items were flavorful and well prepared, while others lacked finesse and flavor, leaving an impression of a lack of consistency.
The service, although friendly, seemed overwhelmed. Wait times between courses were longer than we expected, especially given how busy it was that evening, which affected our experience somewhat.
The ambiance of the restaurant is pleasant, with a relaxed setting that seems perfect for casual evenings. Nonetheless, the overall experience did not live up to our expectations for a well-located restaurant in Key West.
Overall, Fogarty's could be an acceptable option for those who are not looking for a memorable dining experience but rather a simple meal in a casual atmosphere. With a few improvements, particularly in terms of service and consistency in the quality of the dishes, this restaurant could easily improve its appeal.
Holly Rush
Lenny our bartender was absolutely amazing, we came back to restaurant multiple times and made sure we got her!! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keith Webb
Not many customers as we ate early. I mentioned my egg allergy to Lenny, the waitress, when we ordered food. The manageress delivered our food and assured me that every precaution had been taken with my food to ensure it was safe for me to eat - excellent service. The food was scrummy-licious - thank you Fogarty's... ??
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hannah Mintek
Big salads and meals here!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tonye Lee
Alejandro was an awesome waiter! 2 other staff members came over to chat. Such a friendly place to eat and drink! The food was fresh, hot and delicious.
Great place to people watch and have amazing local food!! Conch fritters and Peppered Ahi Tuna is out of the world!! And may be the best Key Lime pie on the island!!
We have been down here 8 days for our honeymoon and have been here 5 times, twice in 1 day. The food is good, the drinks are amazing and keep us coming back. All the staff has been super friendly and make us feel welcome. The way they treat you is so different from a lot of the places on Duval. I highly recommend the Banana Breeze with an extra vanilla shot, the Mahi Mahi bites were delicious.
Good food good drinks good service and location right in the party scene
Great food and drinks.. great service
The food was great. The unfortunate part that my credit card was charged an extra $158. Be aware and make sure to take a photo of the receipt — not a trustable place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Right on Duval Street. So the background noise.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rippchen Und Salat
The drinks are fantastic, and the girls behind the bar are the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fogartys was one of our favorite places to eat. Maxwell was our server and he was great! he has a wonderful personality and made sure we were well taken care of. Slushy drinks were made extremely well, and food was delicious. atmosphere was fun and laid back. 5/5 would highly recommend and definitely on our list of places to visit again in our next visit.
Love the frozen drinks and atmosphere
We had a fantastic dining experience at this restaurant! The food (espacially the shrimp) was fresh, delicious, and full of flavor. Our server, Sarah, was exceptionally attentive and friendly, offering wonderful recommendations that really enhanced our meal. The restaurant manager was also very welcoming and genuinely cared about ensuring all guests were having a great time and were satisfied with their experience. We highly recommend this restaurant for its excellent dishes and amazing frozen drinks
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
During our visit to Key West, we decided to have lunch at Fogarty's, attracted by its central location and casual ambiance. The overall experience was okay, but with some areas for improvement.
The menu at Fogarty's is diverse, offering a wide selection of classic American dishes. Our dishes were well presented and the portions generous. However, the taste quality was uneven: some items were flavorful and well prepared, while others lacked finesse and flavor, leaving an impression of a lack of consistency.
The service, although friendly, seemed overwhelmed. Wait times between courses were longer than we expected, especially given how busy it was that evening, which affected our experience somewhat.
The ambiance of the restaurant is pleasant, with a relaxed setting that seems perfect for casual evenings. Nonetheless, the overall experience did not live up to our expectations for a well-located restaurant in Key West.
Overall, Fogarty's could be an acceptable option for those who are not looking for a memorable dining experience but rather a simple meal in a casual atmosphere. With a few improvements, particularly in terms of service and consistency in the quality of the dishes, this restaurant could easily improve its appeal.
Lenny our bartender was absolutely amazing, we came back to restaurant multiple times and made sure we got her!! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not many customers as we ate early.
I mentioned my egg allergy to Lenny, the waitress, when we ordered food.
The manageress delivered our food and assured me that every precaution had been taken with my food to ensure it was safe for me to eat - excellent service.
The food was scrummy-licious - thank you Fogarty's... ??
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Big salads and meals here!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alejandro was an awesome waiter! 2 other staff members came over to chat. Such a friendly place to eat and drink! The food was fresh, hot and delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...