Walked a while to check this place out. We got there around 1230 PM on a Wednesday in March, no employees in sight, no customers, hardly looked like it was open. 🤯
Rachel Brown
Very sugary. I got the extra tart but it’s countered with so much sugar. Also served frozen so they tell you to wait to eat it. Maybe it’s just me but that’s weird. Daughter had begnet $6. Mediocre at best.
luke king
Don’t listen to the Instagram about other places having the best Key Lime. The best is right here at Key Lime Pie Co
Maxim Panca
Best Key Lime Pie ever !! The Original
Quin Freeman
Simply, Amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Rokeby-Mayeux
I am not one who loves key lime pie, but when you’re in Key West you’ve got to have it. The Key Lime Pie Co has converted me. Their pie reminded me of my grandmothers ice box pie. I had the original, and extra tart is also available.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Julie Lamberson
One fine day, I stopped at Key Lime Pie factory, Kermits, Four Marlins and Blue Heaven. I got key lime pie at each location and had a pie buffet to sample and compare. Excessive? Yes. Scientific research, absolutely. It was for the good of humanity. Hands down, the Key Lime Pie Factory was my favorite. If you love mile high meringue, go to Blue Heaven. If you like cheesecake consistency, go to Four Marlins. If you like crust and mild pie go to Kermits. If you want chocolate covered frozen key lime that will make you close your eyes and transport you to heaven….go to Key Lime Pie Factory. If you want a key lime pie cup with lots of lightly tart key lime pie that will have you licking the cup at the end….go to Key Lime Pie Factory. If you want a perfect little mini pie with just the right amount of crust versus filling ratio….go to Key Lime Pie Factory. Science has spoken, the Key Lime Pie Factory is a winner no matter what you get. Or be like us, get them all and share the experience!!
Peter
Best pie I could find on Key West, but like the others I could barely taste any time flavor, bland base etc. I would be shocked if they use fresh lime juice, let alone Key limes
If you can spell "key lime pie", you can probably make one better at home
TheWorldTraveler
I've tried KLP in several other places and here i can surely say-is THE BEST! Semi-sweet and sour, very fresh and simply delicious. The cream is freshly made and if you take away, they even offer in a frozen option, so it won't lose its quality till you reach home. It melts in your mouth and leaves a sweet after taste. No other places will be on my way now when it comes to KLP!! Simply the best!
onjewel smith
My husband LOVES key lime pie and he is still raving about this one. He ate the first slice and ordered a second one. I had the beignet (I’m from New Orleans) and it was outstanding. You only get one, but it’s a nice size, light, and fluffy…and plenty of powdered sugar. ;-) Highly recommend!
Grabbed a key lime pie to go. Will say I had a decent amount of key lime pie this trip. I will say this one’s ok. Maybe it’s because for me I’d like to have a bit more crust for a texture difference or contrast, also the pie was more tart than sweet.
Basically, if those flavor profiles matches your fancy, absolutely come in and grab a slice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Bhanu Nagalla
Good quantity, and okay quality. It was really tasty but surprisingly my hotel's Key Lime Pie tasted a lot better. I really love this place though due to its location near Duval St, but not nearly on where it gets chaotic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jorge Gonzalez Graupera
Stopped in on my way out of town to get a slice of key lime pie for my wife back in Miami. The shop had just opened, and the sweet, attentive lady behind the counter really made my day. Back in Miami, we served those mini pies, and they were delicious. I don't know if KWKLPC has the best pie in the Keys, but I do know it's the only place I will ever go when I'm down there.
Walked a while to check this place out. We got there around 1230 PM on a Wednesday in March, no employees in sight, no customers, hardly looked like it was open. 🤯
Very sugary. I got the extra tart but it’s countered with so much sugar. Also served frozen so they tell you to wait to eat it. Maybe it’s just me but that’s weird. Daughter had begnet $6. Mediocre at best.
Don’t listen to the Instagram about other places having the best Key Lime. The best is right here at Key Lime Pie Co
Best Key Lime Pie ever !! The Original
Simply, Amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am not one who loves key lime pie, but when you’re in Key West you’ve got to have it. The Key Lime Pie Co has converted me. Their pie reminded me of my grandmothers ice box pie. I had the original, and extra tart is also available.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
One fine day, I stopped at Key Lime Pie factory, Kermits, Four Marlins and Blue Heaven. I got key lime pie at each location and had a pie buffet to sample and compare. Excessive? Yes. Scientific research, absolutely. It was for the good of humanity. Hands down, the Key Lime Pie Factory was my favorite. If you love mile high meringue, go to Blue Heaven. If you like cheesecake consistency, go to Four Marlins. If you like crust and mild pie go to Kermits. If you want chocolate covered frozen key lime that will make you close your eyes and transport you to heaven….go to Key Lime Pie Factory. If you want a key lime pie cup with lots of lightly tart key lime pie that will have you licking the cup at the end….go to Key Lime Pie Factory. If you want a perfect little mini pie with just the right amount of crust versus filling ratio….go to Key Lime Pie Factory. Science has spoken, the Key Lime Pie Factory is a winner no matter what you get. Or be like us, get them all and share the experience!!
Best pie I could find on Key West, but like the others I could barely taste any time flavor, bland base etc. I would be shocked if they use fresh lime juice, let alone Key limes
If you can spell "key lime pie", you can probably make one better at home
I've tried KLP in several other places and here i can surely say-is THE BEST! Semi-sweet and sour, very fresh and simply delicious. The cream is freshly made and if you take away, they even offer in a frozen option, so it won't lose its quality till you reach home. It melts in your mouth and leaves a sweet after taste.
No other places will be on my way now when it comes to KLP!!
Simply the best!
My husband LOVES key lime pie and he is still raving about this one. He ate the first slice and ordered a second one. I had the beignet (I’m from New Orleans) and it was outstanding. You only get one, but it’s a nice size, light, and fluffy…and plenty of powdered sugar. ;-) Highly recommend!
Restaurantji Recommends
Served frozen and poor service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Grabbed a key lime pie to go. Will say I had a decent amount of key lime pie this trip. I will say this one’s ok. Maybe it’s because for me I’d like to have a bit more crust for a texture difference or contrast, also the pie was more tart than sweet.
Basically, if those flavor profiles matches your fancy, absolutely come in and grab a slice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Good quantity, and okay quality. It was really tasty but surprisingly my hotel's Key Lime Pie tasted a lot better. I really love this place though due to its location near Duval St, but not nearly on where it gets chaotic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in on my way out of town to get a slice of key lime pie for my wife back in Miami. The shop had just opened, and the sweet, attentive lady behind the counter really made my day. Back in Miami, we served those mini pies, and they were delicious. I don't know if KWKLPC has the best pie in the Keys, but I do know it's the only place I will ever go when I'm down there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The key lime milkshake is insanely delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...