Key West Key Lime Pie Co.
511 Greene St, Key West
(305) 517-6720
Customers' Favorites
Mango Extra Tart and Tart Key Lime Pie
Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie
Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie
Strawberry KeyLime Pie Bars
Chocolate Dipped Pie Bar
Key Lime Pie Milkshake
Personal Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Milkshake
Original Whole Pie
Whole Key Lime Pie
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Went there Ty was friendly and very knowledgeable as a native conch I'm secptical of other people's key lime pie,however I was pleasantly surprised at the taste and I got the frozen chocolate dipped pie and even though I DO NOT LIKE DARK CHOCOLATE Ty convinced me to give it a try and I was not disappointed. It was delicious 😋 he's got a loyal customer now everytime I come back home I'll be stopping by to grab a slice. Go check them out you won't be...
I loved the key lime pie in a cup, great for gluten free folks to savor the best part of the pie. I seriously felt intoxicated after I was finished—soooo good! My hubby loved the slice dipped in chocolate.
Very sugary. I got the extra tart but it’s countered with so much sugar. Also served frozen so they tell you to wait to eat it. Maybe it’s just me but that’s weird. Daughter had begnet $6. Mediocre at best.
You May Also Like
Pickles Pub Key West - 511 Greene St
![]()
Sports Bar, New American, Seafood, Vegetarian
Tattoos and Scars Saloon - 512 Greene St
![]()
Bar, Pet Friendly
Shots & Giggles - 201 Ann St
![]()
Bar, Pet Friendly