Our absolute favorite sub, sandwich, and gourmet cupcake place in Key West.. Hands down!! This local spot is a must visit and prepare your HUNGER because these massive subs are sure to fill you up! ALSO MUST save room for a mouth watering cupcake afterwards! As you can see from the pictures we visit this spot as our first, last, and in between our many trips to KW. We order and take these on our boat and beach trips and even fly them home to our kids per their request. We have tried every single sub in this place and a hard time deciding on a Favorite. I personally am a pastrami snob and have to order that sandwich at least once and my husband is obsessed with the Balboa their signature sub! You really cannot go wrong. The owners are two of the most hard working individuals and make sure your stomach is satisfied as well as your sweet tooth. They strive for perfection when it comes to an amazing lunch spot and never disappoint. If you have one day in KW on a cruise stop or spending some quality time checking out the island on vacation or boat outing DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND STOP HERE!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Butcher, Oy Vey, The Golden Pig, The Balboa, Strawberry Cupcake, The Karen, The Baller, Pastrami
Bernie Crandley
Great subs, quality ingredients. Can't go wrong here. Everything is good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Balboa
David Loo
Great food. Turkey freshly made in house, sub rolls imported from NJ. Owner was great and provided really helpful suggestions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jake Couch
Ordered the “Balboa” Italian sub and it was delicious! Staff is extremely friendly too! 100% recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Balboa
Joe Cantello
Excellent sandwich
D. Hunter
Hands down some of the best sandwiches you will ever eat! Props to Mica & Joy for taking pride and passion in what they do. It shows in all the little details! Also do t forget to grab a cupcake they are devine if I must say!Your friends Dustin & Alicia
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tulia Catering
Wow! The sandwiches here are unbelievable. Fully loaded, great bread, creative toppings, wonderful staff and clean. The owners are always there and are extremely friendly. Highly recommend if you find yourself in Key West, be sure to stop there. You won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Harvey
The Best!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Choice of 2 Meats, Balboa, The Swiss Miss, The Butcher, Oy Vey, The Ogie Hoagie, The Golden Pig, The Balboa, Strawberry Cupcake, Chips, Italian Sub Balboa, The Karen, Katz Tribute Sammy, The Cowboy, Side Sweet Peppers, The Indian, Fat Katz, The Baller, Chili Cheese, Turkey Sammy
Recommended dishes: Choice of 2 Meats, Balboa, The Swiss Miss, The Butcher, Oy Vey, The Ogie Hoagie, The Golden Pig, The Balboa, Strawberry Cupcake, Chips, Italian Sub Balboa, The Karen, The Cowboy, Side Sweet Peppers, The Indian, Fat Katz, The Baller, Chili Cheese, Turkey Sammy
Ty Petty
Do yourself a favor and get a balboa.It’s enough for 2 if you’re not starving or a big eater.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Baron
My friend and I went to Little Whitehouse Subs on Sunday 3/10/24 at 2:30pm. We were disappointed because the sign said they close at 3pm. We decided to come back again the following day to try these sandwiches that we heard were the BEST in Key West. We got there right at noon. We asked about their posted hours and why they were closed early the day before. The owner told us that there was a family emergency. Totally understandable. Boy, were we glad we gave them a second chance because these sandwiches definitely lived up to the hype! I ordered the Balboa and my friend ordered the Indian. The Balboa (love the name) is an Italian sub, but on massive amounts of steroids...this thing is HUGE!! I'm a big dude and was only able to eat half of it. I had it wrapped and took the rest with me. My friend ordered the Indian (think Thanxgiving). It was a hot sub that had everything you'd get at your grandmother's house on Thanxgiving...except greenbean casserole and pecan pie. He said it was Amazing. Well, before we left we ordered to-go orders so we could try what each other had. I ordered an Indian for myself & my friend ordered a Balboa, just to see if we were each correct in our assessments. We Absolutely were! The rest of the menu looked nothing short of Spectacular. There were SO many options for us carnivores and also quite a few vegetarian options as well, which my girlfriend will love. If you ever find yourself in Key West around lunch time and want to try some of the Best subs you'll ever have in your life B-line it straight to Little Whitehouse Subs, just call before you go to make sure they're open. Oh, I almost forgot to mention the 'SPECIAL DAILY CUPCAKE' for those with a bit of a sweet tooth, like me. They have a special homemade cupcake every day. We were there when it happened to be a Banana's Foster cupcake. This was the Best cupcake I've ever had! I looked back at some of there past cupcakes and it looks like you could come here every day for a year and not have the same cupcake, ABSOLUTELY WILD!Vegetarian options: They offer a few sandwiches that looked phenomenal. The portobello mushroom one looked the Best to me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Balboa, The Indian
Eric Mcflintstone
Best sub shop in the Keys! Great staff and foods always fresh and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Crosetto
Hours posted are until 3p.It's 2p and they're closed. Don't bother with this place...go somewhere they respect their customers though to stay
Best sub I had in my entire whole life. 6 stars
One of the best sandwiches ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Balboa
Our absolute favorite sub, sandwich, and gourmet cupcake place in Key West.. Hands down!! This local spot is a must visit and prepare your HUNGER because these massive subs are sure to fill you up! ALSO MUST save room for a mouth watering cupcake afterwards! As you can see from the pictures we visit this spot as our first, last, and in between our many trips to KW. We order and take these on our boat and beach trips and even fly them home to our kids per their request. We have tried every single sub in this place and a hard time deciding on a Favorite. I personally am a pastrami snob and have to order that sandwich at least once and my husband is obsessed with the Balboa their signature sub! You really cannot go wrong. The owners are two of the most hard working individuals and make sure your stomach is satisfied as well as your sweet tooth. They strive for perfection when it comes to an amazing lunch spot and never disappoint. If you have one day in KW on a cruise stop or spending some quality time checking out the island on vacation or boat outing DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND STOP HERE!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Butcher, Oy Vey, The Golden Pig, The Balboa, Strawberry Cupcake, The Karen, The Baller, Pastrami
Great subs, quality ingredients. Can't go wrong here. Everything is good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Balboa
Great food. Turkey freshly made in house, sub rolls imported from NJ. Owner was great and provided really helpful suggestions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered the “Balboa” Italian sub and it was delicious! Staff is extremely friendly too! 100% recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Balboa
Excellent sandwich
Hands down some of the best sandwiches you will ever eat! Props to Mica & Joy for taking pride and passion in what they do. It shows in all the little details! Also do t forget to grab a cupcake they are devine if I must say!Your friends Dustin & Alicia
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow! The sandwiches here are unbelievable. Fully loaded, great bread, creative toppings, wonderful staff and clean. The owners are always there and are extremely friendly. Highly recommend if you find yourself in Key West, be sure to stop there. You won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Best!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Choice of 2 Meats, Balboa, The Swiss Miss, The Butcher, Oy Vey, The Ogie Hoagie, The Golden Pig, The Balboa, Strawberry Cupcake, Chips, Italian Sub Balboa, The Karen, Katz Tribute Sammy, The Cowboy, Side Sweet Peppers, The Indian, Fat Katz, The Baller, Chili Cheese, Turkey Sammy
Restaurantji Recommends
The best sandwich shop I have ever been to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Choice of 2 Meats, Balboa, The Swiss Miss, The Butcher, Oy Vey, The Ogie Hoagie, The Golden Pig, The Balboa, Strawberry Cupcake, Chips, Italian Sub Balboa, The Karen, The Cowboy, Side Sweet Peppers, The Indian, Fat Katz, The Baller, Chili Cheese, Turkey Sammy
Do yourself a favor and get a balboa.It’s enough for 2 if you’re not starving or a big eater.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
My friend and I went to Little Whitehouse Subs on Sunday 3/10/24 at 2:30pm. We were disappointed because the sign said they close at 3pm. We decided to come back again the following day to try these sandwiches that we heard were the BEST in Key West. We got there right at noon. We asked about their posted hours and why they were closed early the day before. The owner told us that there was a family emergency. Totally understandable. Boy, were we glad we gave them a second chance because these sandwiches definitely lived up to the hype! I ordered the Balboa and my friend ordered the Indian. The Balboa (love the name) is an Italian sub, but on massive amounts of steroids...this thing is HUGE!! I'm a big dude and was only able to eat half of it. I had it wrapped and took the rest with me. My friend ordered the Indian (think Thanxgiving). It was a hot sub that had everything you'd get at your grandmother's house on Thanxgiving...except greenbean casserole and pecan pie. He said it was Amazing. Well, before we left we ordered to-go orders so we could try what each other had. I ordered an Indian for myself & my friend ordered a Balboa, just to see if we were each correct in our assessments. We Absolutely were! The rest of the menu looked nothing short of Spectacular. There were SO many options for us carnivores and also quite a few vegetarian options as well, which my girlfriend will love. If you ever find yourself in Key West around lunch time and want to try some of the Best subs you'll ever have in your life B-line it straight to Little Whitehouse Subs, just call before you go to make sure they're open. Oh, I almost forgot to mention the 'SPECIAL DAILY CUPCAKE' for those with a bit of a sweet tooth, like me. They have a special homemade cupcake every day. We were there when it happened to be a Banana's Foster cupcake. This was the Best cupcake I've ever had! I looked back at some of there past cupcakes and it looks like you could come here every day for a year and not have the same cupcake, ABSOLUTELY WILD!Vegetarian options: They offer a few sandwiches that looked phenomenal. The portobello mushroom one looked the Best to me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Balboa, The Indian
Best sub shop in the Keys! Great staff and foods always fresh and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hours posted are until 3p.It's 2p and they're closed. Don't bother with this place...go somewhere they respect their customers though to stay
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1