The food was exceptional, all the way from the bread to the lamb oso buco, beef Wellington , Jager Snitzel to the filet mignons! The appetizers and desserts were top notch as well. The staff was amazingly attentive!
Bob
Not very happy. Very few people in the inside room, and was quite warm. Our party of 4 did have a couple of good items off the menu, but... my cowboy steak was about one third grizzle and fat, way below par. My girlfriend's pasta was so-so. The two deserts we ordered, bananas foster the creme brulee were below par. The good stuff was the schnitzel strips appetizer and the waiter. We will not be going back.
Denise
Lobster Risotto & 1 1/2 lb. Maine Lobster, both delicious. The service was just average, expected better.
Joseph
It was so good we're going back for seconds, Maxi was very courteous and professional. Martin's cooking was superb. Ser gut!
Nancy
Delicious! The jaeger schnitzel was perfectly prepared! Crispy and tender with button mushroom gravy. Huge portion. Red cabbage and spatzle were ideal sides, washed down with German Riesling. Garden view was so inviting, and our server was pleasant. Perfect counterpoint to the fish and Caribbean meals we had all week. A definite recommendation!
John
Good but not great...was hoping for a better dining experience for our group. Beef Wellington, the signature entree for this restaurant, was disappointing. Filet Mignon and Lamb were tasty
Stephenne
The food, the beverages, the service, the atmosphere...all exemplary! Best cuisine we had in the Keys.
Roxanne
Great spot. Food was fantastic and the service was second to none. Thank you to Mica for making our night!
Jon
Incredible food and great service. My only slight complaint which isn't even enough to knock off a star is they really need to have better white rum than Bacardi. This is Key West and there is so much good rum around. It's shocking they don't have a better white rum option.
Hilda
Had dinner at Martin's and really enjoyed it! The food was great, and the vibe was nice and relaxed. The service was awesome—super friendly and attentive. It was a bit pricey though—$130 for two people, and one of us was vegetarian. Biggest downside was the parking; it was pretty terrible and hard to find a spot. Overall, I'd go back, but definitely plan ahead for the parking situation.
Excellent experience. Exceeded expectations. Amazing food (try the schnitzel!) and the service was exceptional.
Inga
Pros and Cobs: Lobster tail and tuna tataki were amazing. The Waldorf salad was meh. The bread did not need to be herbed. The drinks were 5 star!
Ellen
Very warm when sun was setting indoors and several flies. Other than that, the service was great and the food was great. I would highly recommend but work on above.
Christy
It is our go to restaurant whenever we are in Key West. The food is always delicious, you can sit inside or out, and you can make a reservation.
michael
Great waiter, good food. Had starters in the happy hour bar and went on to the dining room for the rest. Had a great evening.
The food was exceptional, all the way from the bread to the lamb oso buco, beef Wellington , Jager Snitzel to the filet mignons! The appetizers and desserts were top notch as well. The staff was amazingly attentive!
Not very happy. Very few people in the inside room, and was quite warm. Our party of 4 did have a couple of good items off the menu, but... my cowboy steak was about one third grizzle and fat, way below par. My girlfriend's pasta was so-so. The two deserts we ordered, bananas foster the creme brulee were below par. The good stuff was the schnitzel strips appetizer and the waiter. We will not be going back.
Lobster Risotto & 1 1/2 lb. Maine Lobster, both delicious. The service was just average, expected better.
It was so good we're going back for seconds, Maxi was very courteous and professional. Martin's cooking was superb. Ser gut!
Delicious! The jaeger schnitzel was perfectly prepared! Crispy and tender with button mushroom gravy. Huge portion. Red cabbage and spatzle were ideal sides, washed down with German Riesling. Garden view was so inviting, and our server was pleasant. Perfect counterpoint to the fish and Caribbean meals we had all week. A definite recommendation!
Good but not great...was hoping for a better dining experience for our group. Beef Wellington, the signature entree for this restaurant, was disappointing. Filet Mignon and Lamb were tasty
The food, the beverages, the service, the atmosphere...all exemplary! Best cuisine we had in the Keys.
Great spot. Food was fantastic and the service was second to none. Thank you to Mica for making our night!
Incredible food and great service. My only slight complaint which isn't even enough to knock off a star is they really need to have better white rum than Bacardi. This is Key West and there is so much good rum around. It's shocking they don't have a better white rum option.
Had dinner at Martin's and really enjoyed it! The food was great, and the vibe was nice and relaxed. The service was awesome—super friendly and attentive. It was a bit pricey though—$130 for two people, and one of us was vegetarian. Biggest downside was the parking; it was pretty terrible and hard to find a spot. Overall, I'd go back, but definitely plan ahead for the parking situation.
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent experience. Exceeded expectations. Amazing food (try the schnitzel!) and the service was exceptional.
Pros and Cobs: Lobster tail and tuna tataki were amazing. The Waldorf salad was meh. The bread did not need to be herbed. The drinks were 5 star!
Very warm when sun was setting indoors and several flies. Other than that, the service was great and the food was great. I would highly recommend but work on above.
It is our go to restaurant whenever we are in Key West. The food is always delicious, you can sit inside or out, and you can make a reservation.
Great waiter, good food. Had starters in the happy hour bar and went on to the dining room for the rest. Had a great evening.
Loading...