Mattheessen's

614 Greene St, Key West
(305) 923-5418

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Key Lime Ice Cream & Key Lime Pie Slice

1 2 lbs Chocolate Chip Cookies

Key Lime Pie on a Stick

Key West Key Lime Pie

Raspberry Sorbet

Photos

+26 photos

+25 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Frozen key limeade. If you pass this up, you’ll regret it. Super refreshing on a rather warm day. We did a lot of walking (4 miles) and when we got back to the marina area, this was a welcome and well needed drink.
Reasonable price and wonderful counter service. Plus, they have some outdoor seating to relax while sipping on the limeade.

November 2025

We ordered a whole key lime pie and one cookie. The cookie was soft and fresh, and the pie was exactly what we hoped for—bright, tangy, and well balanced. We first tried a slice at another location and liked it best out of the local competition, so we came back for a full pie for Thanksgiving. Great choice for a holiday dessert. The price is worth the pie, especially because of it's size.

November 2025

BEST KEY LIKE PIE! We have been trying every key lime pie we find on this vacation up and down the keys, this has been the best by far!!! I also love the fact it is family owned 💚

September 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Key West, FL

Mattheessen's

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Mattheessen's