Mattheessen's Homemade

106 Duval St, Key West
(305) 923-5418

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Brownie with Vanilla Ice Cream

Peanut Butter Fudge Cookies

Delce De Leche Ice Cream

Key Lime Pie on a Stick

Cuban Coffee Ice-Cream

Big Half Pound Cookie

Chocolatechip Cookies

Peanut Butter Cookie

Baked Key Lime Pie

Brownie Explosion

Photos

+56 photos

+55 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I can't rave about their cookies enough!!!!! I died and went to heaven after my diabetic overload (No seriously I survived)! They were so good, that we went back the next day just to grab some more and plus some on the road trip back to Bradenton, Florida to visit some of our relatives. Definitely, didn't share with the relative. The last cookie didn't make it past the turn off from Alligator Alley to I-75. ----- Author C.A. McJack

November 2025

By far the best key lime pie in all of Key West! The crust was incredible , and the key lime flavor is spot-on — tangy, smooth, and just right. We actually stumbled upon this spot while looking for ice cream but decided to try the pie instead… and I’m so glad I did! Highly recommend — even better than Kermit’s!

October 2025

Amazing cookies! We got the chocolate chip and m & m and it was great. Perfect amount of crunch on the outside with soft on the inside. Perfect touch is the combo with milk. We also got the fudge which was different from normal. Little firm on the out then a frosting like inside that melts on your tongue. Delicious!

July 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Key West, FL

Mattheessen's Homemade

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Mattheessen's Homemade