Mattheessen's Homemade
106 Duval St, Key West
(305) 923-5418
Customers' Favorites
Brownie with Vanilla Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Fudge Cookies
Delce De Leche Ice Cream
Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Cuban Coffee Ice-Cream
Big Half Pound Cookie
Chocolatechip Cookies
Peanut Butter Cookie
Baked Key Lime Pie
Brownie Explosion
Menu
Photos
+62 photos
+61 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Went there 3 years ago each day and yesterday once we returned to KeyWest. Cookies are yummy and the ice cream is delicious. Maybe a bit pricey but what’s not expensive on an island.
Cookies were great, but the lady behind the counter was very short with snippy with us.
Barely said anything to us while we were there. Wish our first experience could have been better.
Barely said anything to us while we were there. Wish our first experience could have been better.
You May Also Like
Hog's Breath Saloon - 400 Front St
![]()
Pubs, Bar, Pet Friendly
The Conch Shack - 118 Duval St
![]()
Seafood, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Burgers, Pet Friendly
Bagatelle - 115 Duval St #6505
![]()
Seafood, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
They are huge, incredibly fresh, and absolutely delicious. Soft, flavorful, and each cookie feels like a full experience, not just a snack. One is more than enough… but you’ll still want another - left with 4.
To top it off, the girls working there were friendly and let us know they ship — and within two days....