We had a wonderful dinner outside. Our server was friendly, efficient and accommodating. The food was amazing and everyone commented it was one of our top dinners!!
John
Excellent local spot. Andre and his team strive to provide a top rate experience. Great pasta and great service. Huge portions - good value.
Linda
I always have a good meal here. Last night I had the eggplant parmigiana and it was great. Our server was excellent and very sweet. We even had free appetizers. And the glass of wine was huge. Good value.
Robert
Food and service was excellent and exceptional value. The wine was great, with a very generous pour, the salad and main course (lasagna) were outstanding and Fletcher, our waiter, provided outstanding service. Everything was great!
Mary
The dinner was excellent and the waiter went out of the way to.make us coffee even though it was on the menu.
soo
Really pretty outdoor dining area. Definitely recommend sitting outside. Nothing great about the inside. The food was very good and priced very well. Very large portions!! The steak was so tender and cooked very well. I would definitely eat there again.
Bob
I had a 7 PM reservation. Stood outside till 7:22 PM before someone came over. After I sat down I ordered the calamari over marinara sauce. It was excellent. My main course was veal Parmesan. The view was dark, grainy and tough. After dinner I asked for an espresso. I was advised there was no espresso due to the machine, not working for a couple months, needing to be sent to Miami for repairs while sitting there I heard good things from other customers about their food. I don't doubt it. Do yourself a favor. Do not water the veal or ask for an espresso.
Pam
We enjoy dining at New York pasta garden every time we come to Key West. Good food, great service, and generous wine pours.
Tony
The food was delicious, and the portions were large.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Bella Mare
Fran C
Ordered fettuccine Alfredo with chicken for delivery. It was disgusting. Don’t recommend.
We went here after a friends wedding, the food was absolutely amazing. They went out of their way to accommodate us, they even went so far as to run to adjacent restaurants to accommodate our requests. These folks were amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Chicken Marsala
Sam
The reviews did not disappoint. Small and quaint like a cafe in Italy. The lasagna was amazing. The bread and olive oil with fresh garlic, amazing caesar salad, veal picatta, and wine we're all on point. Phillip was our server and was accommodating and attentive. Definitely 10/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Chase
Fillip was an amazing server. Took great care of us. The fried artichoke hearts were absolutely amazing! The garlic knots outstanding, and that’s before we got our meals. I had shrimp, scallop and lobster pasta and could barely get through half. 100% would recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp & Scallop Carino
Nicole Beckler
My friend picked out this place. It's located a couple blocks off of Duval Street. It's a classic Italian restaurant with your favorite dishes. The wine list was quite impressive for a small establishment. I chose a bottle of the Amarone from Italy. Superb!
Our waiter, Fillip, from Montenegro was excellent. He was very attentive, friendly, funny and efficient.
The food... Absolutely delicious. I'm a huge meatball connoisseur and these did not disappoint. They fell apart in your mouth and the sauce was delectable. I've included a lot of photos of the different dishes as there were five of us. The pasta is al dente and all of the sauces were savory, buttery and creamy. The chicken piccata was amazing and I could cut it with a fork. I highly suggest this hidden treasure! ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Ackerman
The food, service and above all the atmosphere were incredible. We were looking for a date night restaurant, although there are several good places in Key West, this offered a quiet romantic place to eat. And that is hard to find here. Our server Philip was friendly, attentive and was genuinely interested in us as patrons. Try it you will not be disappointed.
We had a wonderful dinner outside. Our server was friendly, efficient and accommodating. The food was amazing and everyone commented it was one of our top dinners!!
Excellent local spot. Andre and his team strive to provide a top rate experience. Great pasta and great service. Huge portions - good value.
I always have a good meal here. Last night I had the eggplant parmigiana and it was great. Our server was excellent and very sweet. We even had free appetizers. And the glass of wine was huge. Good value.
Food and service was excellent and exceptional value. The wine was great, with a very generous pour, the salad and main course (lasagna) were outstanding and Fletcher, our waiter, provided outstanding service. Everything was great!
The dinner was excellent and the waiter went out of the way to.make us coffee even though it was on the menu.
Really pretty outdoor dining area. Definitely recommend sitting outside. Nothing great about the inside. The food was very good and priced very well. Very large portions!! The steak was so tender and cooked very well. I would definitely eat there again.
I had a 7 PM reservation. Stood outside till 7:22 PM before someone came over. After I sat down I ordered the calamari over marinara sauce. It was excellent. My main course was veal Parmesan. The view was dark, grainy and tough. After dinner I asked for an espresso. I was advised there was no espresso due to the machine, not working for a couple months, needing to be sent to Miami for repairs while sitting there I heard good things from other customers about their food. I don't doubt it. Do yourself a favor. Do not water the veal or ask for an espresso.
We enjoy dining at New York pasta garden every time we come to Key West. Good food, great service, and generous wine pours.
The food was delicious, and the portions were large.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Bella Mare
Ordered fettuccine Alfredo with chicken for delivery. It was disgusting. Don’t recommend.
Food: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We went here after a friends wedding, the food was absolutely amazing. They went out of their way to accommodate us, they even went so far as to run to adjacent restaurants to accommodate our requests. These folks were amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Chicken Marsala
The reviews did not disappoint. Small and quaint like a cafe in Italy. The lasagna was amazing. The bread and olive oil with fresh garlic, amazing caesar salad, veal picatta, and wine we're all on point. Phillip was our server and was accommodating and attentive. Definitely 10/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fillip was an amazing server. Took great care of us. The fried artichoke hearts were absolutely amazing! The garlic knots outstanding, and that’s before we got our meals. I had shrimp, scallop and lobster pasta and could barely get through half. 100% would recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp & Scallop Carino
My friend picked out this place. It's located a couple blocks off of Duval Street. It's a classic Italian restaurant with your favorite dishes. The wine list was quite impressive for a small establishment. I chose a bottle of the Amarone from Italy. Superb!
Our waiter, Fillip, from Montenegro was excellent. He was very attentive, friendly, funny and efficient.
The food... Absolutely delicious. I'm a huge meatball connoisseur and these did not disappoint. They fell apart in your mouth and the sauce was delectable.
I've included a lot of photos of the different dishes as there were five of us. The pasta is al dente and all of the sauces were savory, buttery and creamy. The chicken piccata was amazing and I could cut it with a fork.
I highly suggest this hidden treasure! ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food, service and above all the atmosphere were incredible. We were looking for a date night restaurant, although there are several good places in Key West, this offered a quiet romantic place to eat. And that is hard to find here. Our server Philip was friendly, attentive and was genuinely interested in us as patrons. Try it you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp & Scallop Carino
Loading...