New York Pasta Garden

1075 Duval St, Key West
(305) 292-1991

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tim

Air conditioning broken so ate outside. Bathroom had stepladder in front of toilet. Not very classy

Jay

My experience started off with host stand no one was there. Then they came over got us seated and server was no where to be found. I had to ask multiple times for bread and drinks. The food was good but the lack of service made the experience a 0. I wouldn't recommend this place and the staff act so surprised at anything you asked them. Some people even walked out of the place because of super super slow service.

Ilianet

Nice restaurant and excellent food. We were a table of 12 and we all ordered a different dish. Everything was delicious and well served. Our only complaint was because we had an outdoor seating and it was a very hot night, some fans could alleviate the heat. Most of the restaurants in Key West have outdoors fans and that's definitely a great help when eating outside.

Russell

Pathetic. It's my only word for this “Italian “ restaurant. The worst... getting hot clam sauce accidentally poured on my forehead and shorts. With a mild apology from the bus man. Waited to get an apology from the waiter, manager or owner......nothing. Had to to tell the hostess. She instructed the owner to come out to me. He apologized but when I asked him why are you apologizing....? He said “ I don't know”. Waiter found out and dropped our appetizer from the bill. Yep that was it. So listen to my recommendation. Skip this place. Staff seem to work hard. Manager/owner are pathetic. Teach your employees how to do their job. That's your job. And for an Italian restaurant, they pitch you the worst California wine. Didn't even know what Brunello was....super odd. Don't go here. Keep looking for anything else.

richard

Our party of 6 ate inside as it was almost 100 degrees outside. Service was terrible, food was terrible, and the restaurant had mold on the walls behind where we sat. NEVER AGAIN FOR ANY REASON.

Elizabeth Griffin Wiggins

This restaurant was amazing! The food was fabulous and the staff makes your meal a true experience. Vladimir our server was great, but Fletcher the manager made it an unforgettable evening.

Opentable Diner

WE HAVE BEEN COMING TO THIS KEY WEST FAVORITE RESTAURANT FOR MORE THAN 20 YEARS AND HAVE NEVER BEEN DISAPPOINTED! FROM THE ATTENTION WE RECEIVED AS SOON AS WE ENTERED ,THROUGH OUR ENTIRE MEAL AND AFTER...THE SERVICE WAS AWESOME, AS USUAL. THE FOOD WAS GREAT, ALSO AS USUAL, WITH FAIR PRICES. EVERYTHING ON THE MENU WAS AVAILABLE. EVERYTIME WE VISIT I CHOOSE SOMETHING DIFFERENT FROM THE MENU...NEVER A BAD CHOICE! WINE GLASS IS LARGE AND ALWAYS KEPT FULL...WHAT MORE CAN YOU ASK FOR?

Emmett

Awesome place. Service was great and the food was excellent. Would definitely go there again

stacey

8 of us dined and everyone loved their meals including appetizers that were ordered. Donna was our server and we can't say enough about her. She was fun, entertaining, and sweet. She made our experience that much better.

Cathy

We had a wonderful dinner outside. Our server was friendly, efficient and accommodating. The food was amazing and everyone commented it was one of our top dinners!!

John

Excellent local spot. Andre and his team strive to provide a top rate experience. Great pasta and great service. Huge portions - good value.

Linda

I always have a good meal here. Last night I had the eggplant parmigiana and it was great. Our server was excellent and very sweet. We even had free appetizers. And the glass of wine was huge. Good value.

Robert

Food and service was excellent and exceptional value. The wine was great, with a very generous pour, the salad and main course (lasagna) were outstanding and Fletcher, our waiter, provided outstanding service. Everything was great!

Mary

The dinner was excellent and the waiter went out of the way to.make us coffee even though it was on the menu.

soo

Really pretty outdoor dining area. Definitely recommend sitting outside. Nothing great about the inside. The food was very good and priced very well. Very large portions!! The steak was so tender and cooked very well. I would definitely eat there again.

Loading...