We got married in Key West and went to NY Pasta Garden for a small dinner reception. Not only were they wonderful to accommodate our party without a reservation but the waitress Dona was was a complete delight! Her spectacular attitude was both funny and charming. She kept telling all the other customers to congratulate us and even gave us a dessert sample platter at the end of the meal. Thank you so much for the wonderful wedding memories
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Evan G.
This shit is ass and i had to wait like 1:45 mins, the food tasted like cardboard. And the ambiance was horrible someone was smoking weed in the building
Nicole Charbonneau
Meal was excellent, service was very good and the atmosphere was friendly and warmParking: Large free parking lot close to the restaurant
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
wiktoria nowowiejska
We dined yesterday. The place itself and location amazing cute outside area with lights, but tablecloth not fitting table AT ALL not to mention all wrinkled looking like a dog chewed on it and spit it out.. Our server seemed drunk and was saying weird stuff and i feel horrible mentioning it but his fingernails had probably dirt from 2015… food bland no taste and pasta probably frozen, traumatizing experience considering i work in fine dining. Everything was terrible
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
Kim S.
Highly disappointed. Meals didn't contain the food that was listed on the menu. Entrees were missing "chunks of lobster" and "large sea scallops". Another meal was missing the anchovies. One of the entrees delivered was incorrectly. Large salad to share was nice. Waitress refused to split checks. We weren't a large party. This was the only restaurant in our 10 days in Key West that refused our request. We discussed this with the server and she assured us the seafood was in the dishes. Def wasn't. Will not return and will not recommend.
turner
Horrible. They were out of a lot of stuff, including wine, and short staffed. I felt so very bad for our waitress who was very nice and apologetic, but way too many people for her to handle on her own. We left before ordering as we waited for 30 minutes before someone came by - I blame management.
Pe4kms
Food entrees didn't match the menu description. No “large chuncks of lobster” or “large sea scallops” in 2 of the entrees. Also no anchovies in one of the dishes. Also one of the entrees was not correct when it was brought out. Server did correct it in a short amount of time. Shared salad was very good. Outside seating was very dark. Difficult to read menus. Inside seating is not appealing at all. Server wouldn't separate the checks. We were not a large party. This was the only restaurant that wouldn't provide separate checks in the 10 days we spent in Key West. We will not return and we wouldn't recommend this restaurant.
JoyceE
Pasta Garden never disappoints. We love the food, although portions seem to be a bit smaller lately which is understandable since they haven't raised the prices. We recommend it to everyone and love Fletcher s as our servers. He's the best!!!
I don't like to leave bad reviews but the service and food here was absolutely horrible. It is my first and last time I will ever come here. It took 20 minutes to get a water, the appetizer was disgusting. Our main dish took one hour to get and came out cold and flavorless. We never got checked on for refills or anything. The place is very run down and dirty inside.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Angel Cedeño
One of the best pastas out in Key
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dan Hatton
We were seeking out Italian food on our last night on Key West. My wife had the shrimp scampi and I had the fruitti de mare with pomodaro sauce. Generous portions with pleasant waitstaff. Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
diesuwe
Right in Key West. There is also parking around the corner. Unfortunately, you have to be careful where you sit or lay something down, as the free-roaming chickens create dirt here and there. The food was very good, although the host's talking was a bit annoying.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Cheryl Martin
This place was hands down the best pasta I've had out of town! I'm from Buffalo New York . I had the Pasta Bella mare.. hands down 10/10. Highly recommend. Big portion, flavorful just all around delicious!
Food was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Marsala, Lasagne
Amazing place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We got married in Key West and went to NY Pasta Garden for a small dinner reception. Not only were they wonderful to accommodate our party without a reservation but the waitress Dona was was a complete delight! Her spectacular attitude was both funny and charming. She kept telling all the other customers to congratulate us and even gave us a dessert sample platter at the end of the meal. Thank you so much for the wonderful wedding memories
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This shit is ass and i had to wait like 1:45 mins, the food tasted like cardboard. And the ambiance was horrible someone was smoking weed in the building
Meal was excellent, service was very good and the atmosphere was friendly and warmParking: Large free parking lot close to the restaurant
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We dined yesterday. The place itself and location amazing cute outside area with lights, but tablecloth not fitting table AT ALL not to mention all wrinkled looking like a dog chewed on it and spit it out.. Our server seemed drunk and was saying weird stuff and i feel horrible mentioning it but his fingernails had probably dirt from 2015… food bland no taste and pasta probably frozen, traumatizing experience considering i work in fine dining. Everything was terrible
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
Highly disappointed. Meals didn't contain the food that was listed on the menu. Entrees were missing "chunks of lobster" and "large sea scallops". Another meal was missing the anchovies. One of the entrees delivered was incorrectly. Large salad to share was nice. Waitress refused to split checks. We weren't a large party. This was the only restaurant in our 10 days in Key West that refused our request. We discussed this with the server and she assured us the seafood was in the dishes. Def wasn't. Will not return and will not recommend.
Horrible. They were out of a lot of stuff, including wine, and short staffed. I felt so very bad for our waitress who was very nice and apologetic, but way too many people for her to handle on her own. We left before ordering as we waited for 30 minutes before someone came by - I blame management.
Food entrees didn't match the menu description. No “large chuncks of lobster” or “large sea scallops” in 2 of the entrees. Also no anchovies in one of the dishes. Also one of the entrees was not correct when it was brought out. Server did correct it in a short amount of time. Shared salad was very good. Outside seating was very dark. Difficult to read menus. Inside seating is not appealing at all. Server wouldn't separate the checks. We were not a large party. This was the only restaurant that wouldn't provide separate checks in the 10 days we spent in Key West. We will not return and we wouldn't recommend this restaurant.
Pasta Garden never disappoints. We love the food, although portions seem to be a bit smaller lately which is understandable since they haven't raised the prices. We recommend it to everyone and love Fletcher s as our servers. He's the best!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
I don't like to leave bad reviews but the service and food here was absolutely horrible. It is my first and last time I will ever come here. It took 20 minutes to get a water, the appetizer was disgusting. Our main dish took one hour to get and came out cold and flavorless. We never got checked on for refills or anything. The place is very run down and dirty inside.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
One of the best pastas out in Key
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were seeking out Italian food on our last night on Key West. My wife had the shrimp scampi and I had the fruitti de mare with pomodaro sauce. Generous portions with pleasant waitstaff. Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Right in Key West. There is also parking around the corner. Unfortunately, you have to be careful where you sit or lay something down, as the free-roaming chickens create dirt here and there. The food was very good, although the host's talking was a bit annoying.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place was hands down the best pasta I've had out of town! I'm from Buffalo New York . I had the Pasta Bella mare.. hands down 10/10. Highly recommend. Big portion, flavorful just all around delicious!
Food: 5
Service: 5