Wonderful atmosphere on the water. Clean, quiet, and relaxing. The service was excellent, but not intrusive. The spinach/goat cheese salad was fantastic. The bone-in ribeye was perfectly cooked. The highlight was their key lime pie - best I've ever had down here which is saying a lot. The meringue was sweet and “too eggy” with the sweetest, best crust I've tasted. The key lime inside was perfect.
Tim
Under the radar but a restaurant we visit at least once a season. Waterfront dining in a quiet outdoor setting. Menu is small but varied. Grouper, snapper, beef and pasta. The generous serving of panko coconut crusted snapper was as good as I've had anywhere. Generally easy to get reservations.
Nikki
Pictures were very deceiving. Portions were very small and overall not very good. We will not go back.
Kyle
There is no sunset view at the restaurant, you have to walk around to the other side of the pier to view the sunset. Once you are there, the sunset view is great. Overall the food quality was very poor. The snapper was very fishy and the coconut crust was rock hard and tough on your teeth. The chicken dish was dry and overall not good food quality as compared to many other restaurants in Key West. The water view from the hotel is very nice and the ambience is nice, but the poor food quality puts a damper on the experience.
Alexa
Quiet escape from the noise of town. Beautiful deck overlooking the beach and ocean. Food was exceptional!
Bethany
The menu was great and the sunset was beautiful! The empanadas appetizers were excellent, as well as the chicken and the steak were great.
Nick
We dined here on Christmas Day and in spite it being Christmas Day, we were greeted enthusiastically, the service was efficient and friendly and the food was fresh and well prepared. The setting out on the deck overlooking the ocean cannot be beaten. Overall a great experience and we can recommend One Duval
Opentable Diner
Christmas Eve - we were sat by the hostess stand at the beginning of service when all the tables were open except one which was one over from the hostess stand. My fault for not asking for a different table. The apps were good (beef carappacio and lobster tempura), however the prime rib was more medium and chewy and dry. Gave half to my dog later. Once the sun went down, you couldn't see your plates or what you were eating. Party of 3 and we spent 400. I would give it one more try though.
Francine Gomes
We had a great experience food was great and waiter was nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert william
Wonderful experience. The food here is outstanding. So delicious
An excellent waterfront dining experience! We were able to view an amazing sunset during dinner as well. The service and food were exactly what we had hoped from a first class venue such as this.
Troy
Underwhelming meals, drinks and service for the price. Not necessarily terrible, just less than expected considering the high price tag. Had multiple better meals for half the price or less in our weekend in Key West. The back bartender was trying to cover a lot of tables which was the issue with service. Waited a good 10 minutes before being noticed even with reservations, then about another 15-20 to get drinks and place order. Will likely not be back next time in Key West.
Amy
Service and atmosphere were nice. Food was plated nicely but rather bland. Spices or seasoning would have been helpful.
Cheryl
Waterside restaurant with a nice menu. Seafood paella was very tasty and the cocktails were good, as well. Nice wine list. Service attentive and friendly.
Frank Turner
Ordered two coffees with two B-52s on the side (Kahlua Bailey's and Grand Marnier) for breakfast I ordered the traditional eggs benedict. It was outstanding. She ordered eggs over easy and turkey sausage. The views while sitting and eating breakfast are absolutely stunning. Our waiter was very attentive, and very informative. The place was super super clean. The total bill came to $70. I tipped $30 because it was worth every penny. Chairs were comfy. Clothes napkins....what a place. If I could give 6 stars I would!
Wonderful atmosphere on the water. Clean, quiet, and relaxing. The service was excellent, but not intrusive. The spinach/goat cheese salad was fantastic. The bone-in ribeye was perfectly cooked. The highlight was their key lime pie - best I've ever had down here which is saying a lot. The meringue was sweet and “too eggy” with the sweetest, best crust I've tasted. The key lime inside was perfect.
Under the radar but a restaurant we visit at least once a season. Waterfront dining in a quiet outdoor setting. Menu is small but varied. Grouper, snapper, beef and pasta. The generous serving of panko coconut crusted snapper was as good as I've had anywhere. Generally easy to get reservations.
Pictures were very deceiving. Portions were very small and overall not very good. We will not go back.
There is no sunset view at the restaurant, you have to walk around to the other side of the pier to view the sunset. Once you are there, the sunset view is great. Overall the food quality was very poor. The snapper was very fishy and the coconut crust was rock hard and tough on your teeth. The chicken dish was dry and overall not good food quality as compared to many other restaurants in Key West. The water view from the hotel is very nice and the ambience is nice, but the poor food quality puts a damper on the experience.
Quiet escape from the noise of town. Beautiful deck overlooking the beach and ocean. Food was exceptional!
The menu was great and the sunset was beautiful! The empanadas appetizers were excellent, as well as the chicken and the steak were great.
We dined here on Christmas Day and in spite it being Christmas Day, we were greeted enthusiastically, the service was efficient and friendly and the food was fresh and well prepared. The setting out on the deck overlooking the ocean cannot be beaten. Overall a great experience and we can recommend One Duval
Christmas Eve - we were sat by the hostess stand at the beginning of service when all the tables were open except one which was one over from the hostess stand. My fault for not asking for a different table. The apps were good (beef carappacio and lobster tempura), however the prime rib was more medium and chewy and dry. Gave half to my dog later. Once the sun went down, you couldn't see your plates or what you were eating. Party of 3 and we spent 400. I would give it one more try though.
We had a great experience food was great and waiter was nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful experience. The food here is outstanding. So delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
An excellent waterfront dining experience! We were able to view an amazing sunset during dinner as well. The service and food were exactly what we had hoped from a first class venue such as this.
Underwhelming meals, drinks and service for the price. Not necessarily terrible, just less than expected considering the high price tag. Had multiple better meals for half the price or less in our weekend in Key West. The back bartender was trying to cover a lot of tables which was the issue with service. Waited a good 10 minutes before being noticed even with reservations, then about another 15-20 to get drinks and place order. Will likely not be back next time in Key West.
Service and atmosphere were nice. Food was plated nicely but rather bland. Spices or seasoning would have been helpful.
Waterside restaurant with a nice menu. Seafood paella was very tasty and the cocktails were good, as well. Nice wine list. Service attentive and friendly.
Ordered two coffees with two B-52s on the side (Kahlua Bailey's and Grand Marnier) for breakfast I ordered the traditional eggs benedict. It was outstanding. She ordered eggs over easy and turkey sausage. The views while sitting and eating breakfast are absolutely stunning. Our waiter was very attentive, and very informative. The place was super super clean. The total bill came to $70. I tipped $30 because it was worth every penny. Chairs were comfy. Clothes napkins....what a place. If I could give 6 stars I would!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...