Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria

The host wouldn’t even take a reservation! I am standing at the desk for like five minutes. She says she has two groups coming in and no seats. The group is 12 and 14 there is seats every we ask to sit outside. There is tables all open and she says no seats. I have lived here for years and don’t know who hired this gal. Her math don’t math and you can clearly see they have many more tables than that.

It was a rainy Friday and we ordered pick up. This may have been my favorite meal all week. We got a Caesar Salad and the prosciutto arugula pizza. It was fantastic.

Great pizza and salad. My favorite restaurant in Key West! We ordered a pizza per person. Way too much. Made a great breakfast the next day. Salad was the right size for one person.

Had an outstanding meal! We were warmly greeted at the door and seating at a nice table on the patio. We had a few beers to start. We were not too hungry so went with the meatball appetizer and a margarita pizza. Food and service were exceptional!! That pizza was seriously the best pizza we have eaten! The sauce and dough are amazing. Next time we are in Key West we will be back! We are telling everyone we know about this place. Thanks to trip advisor we gave it and try!

We enjoyed a pizza and lasagna for dinner. The food was very good. Our waitress was wonderful. We enjoyed the atmosphere and their large black cat!

The most difficulty we had here was trying to find the place up the lane way . What a find it turned out to be . The Pepperoni and 4 Malali were top class with a good Wine selection . We were seated on the outside and really enjoyed our evening .

When I tell you this is the best Italian food I’ve ever had, I mean it — and I’ve eaten Italian all over the country. Hands down, the best lasagna and gnocchi EVER. The sauce is incredible, everything cooked to perfection. If you’re ever in Key West, you have to come here. This was our second time, and it was just as good as the first — if not better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lasagna

Went to Onlywood after a show and it was amazing. Food was one of the best meals of the week. Staff was great with excellent recommendations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Pizza, Bruschetta

The atmosphere here was good. But small place with loads of people. Honestly didn't like the food that much, but definitely recommend to come here for wines!! ☺️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

It’s expensive but it’s duval street. Pizza is not a normal size but almost a pan pizza size for full price however, my kids liked it. Maybe it was a one off but the server who took care us was very rude and made us feel unwelcomed. There are better options on Duval street go elsewhere

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

My husband was in the mood for pizza (after a week of seafood) and he found this lovely spot. We ordered happy hour personal pizzas and added garlic and meatballs. They were fantastic! We ended our meal with Profiteroles and Coconut sorbet that were delicious. We highly recommend trying this adorable place!

Tremendous name. OnlyWoodFiredPizza #1

#servicio #1 #$ #value yes. Amazing business Chef

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Plan on smelling horrible when you leave. Longing for a bonfire. & smelling like one ???well then come on in for over priced mediocre food.
Didn’t get our app until after our entree.. just bread service…, but instead of comping the bread he just decided to give us an extra drink which we didn’t want or need at that time. Dessert for my Sons 13th birthday was small…but he said it was very good tiramisu. After we asked for it a couple of times.

We went back to the room, & jumped in the shower to try to get the smoke off of all of us.
We will not be returning…. but we always wanted to try it and this time we were staying right next to it….so… well, we did and this is not even in the top 30 to try, if you find yourself in key west.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Favs when in the West

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Unimpressive. Margherita pizza had flavorless tomatoe sauce and an ovehelming mountain of garlic. And where the hell was the Basil? Expensive and the best thing about my pizza was the crust (I had to eat something).