Service- impeccable as always. It was a special birthday dinner and nothing disappointed, from starters to dessert!
JORGE
The food and the service are always perfect. Been eating there for years and will keep going back.
Barbara
We were seated beside a table of ten men celebrating a bachelor party. They were so loud we had to shout to have a conversation between the two of us. On a positive note the food and our server were excellent.
Stephanie
We are local and love coming to Prime for special occasions. We have been to all the high end restaurants in Key West and keep coming back to Prime. The service is amazing - thanks Alec! We always share a NY strip steak and a giant baked potato. Last night we ordered a crab cake and it was amazing! As good as any from Baltimore. And it went really well with our Old Fashioneds. We will come again and again.
Edward
Excellent oyster Rockefeller, steak cooked perfect. Outstanding bourbon selection. Real bartenders and great service.
Ken
If you're looking for quality food, this is your place. Pair a great bottle of wine and you have a perfect match with their amazing food. We will be back...
Kathleen
Husband and I went for a celebration. The bone in filet was over cooked and not a good value for the money. They did cook another steak for me. The waiter was awesome! Paid 335.00 total with tip for two steaks, two beers and two alcoholic mixed drinks. I would not go back.
Alexander Pierce
Prime Steakhouse is a standout in Key West and exactly what a great dining experience should feel like. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was refined but never stiff welcoming, attentive, and effortlessly professional. The staff struck the perfect balance between polished and personable. Service was smooth, respectful, and genuinely attentive without being overbearing. You could tell they cared about the experience, not just the transaction.
The food absolutely lived up to the name expertly prepared, rich in flavor, and clearly handled with pride. It felt like a place that understands quality and consistency, while still making guests feel comfortable and at ease.
If you’re looking for a restaurant that delivers on excellence without losing warmth or humanity, Prime Steakhouse is well worth the visit. I’d happily return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Reagan Stevens
Great meal with great service. Crab claws were perfection and the garlic creamed spinach and truffle mac were perfect accompaniments to the perfectly prepared ribeye. Wine prices are reasonably market up allowing a good portion of the price paid to go to the wine of choice. Key lime pie was also the perfect ending to a great meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marla Davis
Our daughter and son in law got married in Key West and we dined here afterwards as a party of 22. Steaks are obviously their specialty and they know how to prepare them. They have a good selection of cuts to choose from. The appetizers and sides as well as the salads were very delicious. Our server was very attentive and did an excellent job for such a large party. We enjoyed celebrating the merging of two families here. They are tucked away and it wasn’t super easy to find them but follow the smells wafting through the air!
If you're in Key West and you want an amazing steak in a beautiful and comfortable setting, you have found the right place. It's not a cheap night out, but you're going to get what you pay for. Service was exceptional.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M H
Steaks were great, but the key lime cheesecake was my favorite
Had my first Bone in Filet Migon , it was fantastic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Liam
We was celebrating our 15 year anniversary. The food was excellent and the staff really looked after us both. We would highly recommend this steakhouse.
Sonny
Great food and excellent service. The veal chop and the truffle mac with smoked gouda is amazing, also make sure to leave room for crème brûlée.
Service- impeccable as always. It was a special birthday dinner and nothing disappointed, from starters to dessert!
The food and the service are always perfect. Been eating there for years and will keep going back.
We were seated beside a table of ten men celebrating a bachelor party. They were so loud we had to shout to have a conversation between the two of us. On a positive note the food and our server were excellent.
We are local and love coming to Prime for special occasions. We have been to all the high end restaurants in Key West and keep coming back to Prime. The service is amazing - thanks Alec! We always share a NY strip steak and a giant baked potato. Last night we ordered a crab cake and it was amazing! As good as any from Baltimore. And it went really well with our Old Fashioneds. We will come again and again.
Excellent oyster Rockefeller, steak cooked perfect. Outstanding bourbon selection. Real bartenders and great service.
If you're looking for quality food, this is your place. Pair a great bottle of wine and you have a perfect match with their amazing food. We will be back...
Husband and I went for a celebration. The bone in filet was over cooked and not a good value for the money. They did cook another steak for me. The waiter was awesome! Paid 335.00 total with tip for two steaks, two beers and two alcoholic mixed drinks. I would not go back.
Prime Steakhouse is a standout in Key West and exactly what a great dining experience should feel like. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was refined but never stiff welcoming, attentive, and effortlessly professional.
The staff struck the perfect balance between polished and personable. Service was smooth, respectful, and genuinely attentive without being overbearing. You could tell they cared about the experience, not just the transaction.
The food absolutely lived up to the name expertly prepared, rich in flavor, and clearly handled with pride. It felt like a place that understands quality and consistency, while still making guests feel comfortable and at ease.
If you’re looking for a restaurant that delivers on excellence without losing warmth or humanity, Prime Steakhouse is well worth the visit. I’d happily return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great meal with great service.
Crab claws were perfection and the garlic creamed spinach and truffle mac were perfect accompaniments to the perfectly prepared ribeye.
Wine prices are reasonably market up allowing a good portion of the price paid to go to the wine of choice.
Key lime pie was also the perfect ending to a great meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our daughter and son in law got married in Key West and we dined here afterwards as a party of 22. Steaks are obviously their specialty and they know how to prepare them. They have a good selection of cuts to choose from. The appetizers and sides as well as the salads were very delicious. Our server was very attentive and did an excellent job for such a large party. We enjoyed celebrating the merging of two families here. They are tucked away and it wasn’t super easy to find them but follow the smells wafting through the air!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
If you're in Key West and you want an amazing steak in a beautiful and comfortable setting, you have found the right place. It's not a cheap night out, but you're going to get what you pay for. Service was exceptional.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steaks were great, but the key lime cheesecake was my favorite
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Prime's Signature Bone-In Rib Eye
Had my first Bone in Filet Migon , it was fantastic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We was celebrating our 15 year anniversary. The food was excellent and the staff really looked after us both. We would highly recommend this steakhouse.
Great food and excellent service. The veal chop and the truffle mac with smoked gouda is amazing, also make sure to leave room for crème brûlée.
Loading...