Moses was an attentive and fun server! We shared the surf and turf, a delicious fillet, and an 8 ounce lobster kale. This spinach salad with the pistachio vinaigrette was yummy! 
Kassie
The delmonico ribeye was one of the best of the best steaks I've ever had. The roasted garlic with every steak was a nice touch and the Gouda truffle Mac n cheese was excellent! I'm only sad we were from out of town so it can't be a regular date night for us.
Tony
we had a lovely experience here ,i let them know it was my wife's birthday,the staff were very nice and wished her a happy birthday and put a sparkler in her desert ,the food was excellent and service was too. i would recommend this restaurant for the steak (we didn't have any fish ) the ambiance and the overall experience
Nathan
Wonderful experience with Prime to celebrate our 25th anniversary! Everything start to finish was excellent!
Victor
One of my favorites in Key West. We had the bone in filet and oysters for appetizer. Ending the night with the banana bread pudding which reminds me of banana's foster bread. Everything was wonderful.
Silvia
Service was excellent will definitely recommend and will be back. Oyster Rockefeller was not all that. Steaks were on point Truffle Mac and cheese definitely recommend!
Lisa C.
Everything was amazing! The filet mignon was so tender and delicious! I ordered my steak medium rare and it was more on the medium side, but that did not take away how good it was! Also, the Key Lime Pie Martini was terrific!
Angie
Our experience started out great. Service was great, food choices perfect, crab cake amazing! Then the table was seated next to us and knew the waiter. It was like we were forgotten. The waiter was constantly over talking with them and did not even ask if our expensive meal was to our liking or not. My husband ordered his Delmonaco steak medium rare for it to come out medium. But no waiter to tell. The key lime pie was amazing. It was disappointing to be forgotten so easily at a restaurant that is recommended. 
Sean Cuttler
I thought the service and restaurant were very nice. The food was average, nice presentation, but steak taste was average for such an expensive place.
Emmons
Great food great service the price was a little high for what we ordered, overall a good experience
Probably the best place in Key West for a quality steak and old fashioned service. Seafood, especially the crab cakes are equally recommended
Brian
Very unique entrance, make sure to follow instructions on the website. I had the Delmonico ribeye steak with a Red Wine Demi-glaze, it was very tender and tasted great. Wife had the .AIRLINE CHICKEN BREAST Pan seared breast, chicken au-jus , caramelized onion garlic mashed potatoes. Bread and butter was a greater starter. Server was very helpful (Moses), highly recommend visiting if you are in Key West.
Cindy Smith
My husband had a the Porter House Steak it was so tuff he could not eat it which is a 76.00 dollar steak! My baked potato was not cooked was cold and hard returned the potato ask for another one same thing. Oh I forgot they compt us around of drinks! Not as good as Longhorn's!
M Bull
Dark and cool space. Pretty standard steak and seafood well prepared. Friendly staff. Good cocktails. Nice wine selection.
Belinda
Waiter Alis was excellent! Food was very god with good size portions . Our family had a good experience for a Birthday celebration!
Moses was an attentive and fun server! We shared the surf and turf, a delicious fillet, and an 8 ounce lobster kale. This spinach salad with the pistachio vinaigrette was yummy! 
The delmonico ribeye was one of the best of the best steaks I've ever had. The roasted garlic with every steak was a nice touch and the Gouda truffle Mac n cheese was excellent! I'm only sad we were from out of town so it can't be a regular date night for us.
we had a lovely experience here ,i let them know it was my wife's birthday,the staff were very nice and wished her a happy birthday and put a sparkler in her desert ,the food was excellent and service was too. i would recommend this restaurant for the steak (we didn't have any fish ) the ambiance and the overall experience
Wonderful experience with Prime to celebrate our 25th anniversary! Everything start to finish was excellent!
One of my favorites in Key West. We had the bone in filet and oysters for appetizer. Ending the night with the banana bread pudding which reminds me of banana's foster bread. Everything was wonderful.
Service was excellent will definitely recommend and will be back. Oyster Rockefeller was not all that. Steaks were on point Truffle Mac and cheese definitely recommend!
Everything was amazing! The filet mignon was so tender and delicious! I ordered my steak medium rare and it was more on the medium side, but that did not take away how good it was! Also, the Key Lime Pie Martini was terrific!
Our experience started out great. Service was great, food choices perfect, crab cake amazing! Then the table was seated next to us and knew the waiter. It was like we were forgotten. The waiter was constantly over talking with them and did not even ask if our expensive meal was to our liking or not. My husband ordered his Delmonaco steak medium rare for it to come out medium. But no waiter to tell. The key lime pie was amazing. It was disappointing to be forgotten so easily at a restaurant that is recommended. 
I thought the service and restaurant were very nice. The food was average, nice presentation, but steak taste was average for such an expensive place.
Great food great service the price was a little high for what we ordered, overall a good experience
Restaurantji Recommends
Probably the best place in Key West for a quality steak and old fashioned service. Seafood, especially the crab cakes are equally recommended
Very unique entrance, make sure to follow instructions on the website. I had the Delmonico ribeye steak with a Red Wine Demi-glaze, it was very tender and tasted great. Wife had the .AIRLINE CHICKEN BREAST Pan seared breast, chicken au-jus , caramelized onion garlic mashed potatoes. Bread and butter was a greater starter. Server was very helpful (Moses), highly recommend visiting if you are in Key West.
My husband had a the Porter House Steak it was so tuff he could not eat it which is a 76.00 dollar steak! My baked potato was not cooked was cold and hard returned the potato ask for another one same thing. Oh I forgot they compt us around of drinks! Not as good as Longhorn's!
Dark and cool space. Pretty standard steak and seafood well prepared. Friendly staff. Good cocktails. Nice wine selection.
Waiter Alis was excellent! Food was very god with good size portions . Our family had a good experience for a Birthday celebration!
Loading...