The Stoned Crab

3101 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
(305) 294-4350

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jim

Never would I recommend this place for stone crab. Past disappointed. Service was good. Beer was warm and flat. Stone crabs should be much better but we're not tasty at all. Sorry to post but being honest

Elliot

The food was great and they were very accommodating. The whole staff helped out when I proposed. 

Beckie

The food and service was amazing, did not appreciate fending off flys my whole meal. I did get to feed nurse sharks, so extra bonus!

EdnaT

Overall, the food was bland for all the hype we heard about it. We just expected more flavor the food could've been warmer overall was disappointing

Joy

Upon arrival we were waiting by the hostess stand to be seated. When the hostess walked up she greeted the people standing directly behind us (the restaurant was not busy). The people behind us stated the "they were here first" immediately I was put off by that as my partner is 6'5 and not easily overlooked. It felt intentional. The food was average. We preferred grouper fritters and 1.5 lb fried whole snapper. The sapper was fresh, it came with a small side of barely steamed and unseasoned vegetables (No salt or pepper). Tourist trap.

Robert

Ordered a crab steamer pot. Shrimp was over cooked and stone crab was dry. Had a Key West vibe. drinks were good. Good service.

Cesar

When you advertise stone crab, have to live up to the reputation  of this special seafood plate. This restaurant tries, however, falls short. We try the crab steamer: the stone crabs were not large and the snow crabs were very hard to open and lanky. Having seafood shears would have helped. Price is in the high end, so expected more.

ScottK

Good experience. Outdoor dining plus open air dining is really nice but a closed area for cooler nights would be appreciated. Food was good but not great. That being said lots of good seafood options. Could add some non seafood options to really open up the menu. Would eat here again all that being said.

Marcos Tsukamoto

Camarão enrolado no bacon muito bom!!!! Fetuttine Alfredo também delicioso

luna1732

Closed disappointed as I stayed at the Ibis Resort only to find out there closed till late October.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Melissa

This was terrible, the restaurant was actually closed. The staff that was onsite was so RUDE. When we knocked on the hotel door to inquire on the restaurant it was like we were jerks to ask. They did not care if we were able to Make reservations, view the website without knowledge of closure.

Noel Canino

Worse food ever. I complained to the waiteres and she said... I know I get that all the time. Unbelievable

Gemini

Beautiful place. Lousy unseasoned, over priced food. Got stuffed lobster w nothing stuffed it was in a plastic cup on side. Boiled no seasoning. Didn't eat sides there was no life to them. Boiled potatoes no seasoning, no flavor. Squash just pilled up no onion no color. I paid 40$ for a lobster tail I get from Publfor 15$.
Lobster bake or whatever same. Spent 250 on nothing will never go back.
We asked for peppers ? or hot sauce they guy brought out another plastic cup w lid w green peppers lol. Everything was in plastic cups. For that price have better plating. You catch ur own fish. There is no way a 1lb Snapper is 38$. 1 lb lobster tsil was 40.
We went to the place right before the keys the whale i belive and got better food on a buffet , it had life, color, seasoning. See the pictures bland. See the 2.6 lb lobster tails for 22 vs 1 ln dor 40. I understand the keys maybe 25 for 1lb. Itl be soley a nice looking place that brings people.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Brian Martin

I would never eat at this place again. The food was really bad. That was the first time and last time that my family will ever eat there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Martha Hide

Horrible food we didnt even finish the food. No kids menu Needs to close today!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...