Wicked Lick Ice Cream Key West

Delicious ice cream worth it
They have original homemade flavors, me and my boys had late night
coffee ice cream with Oreos

Heavenly delicious

Friendly staff and awesome ice cream!! Look forward to returning when in area ❤️✌️

The Best Ice Cream in Duval!

We had ice cream from here four nights in a row! We don’t have much to compare it to because after our first visit, we were hooked and didn’t feel the need to try anywhere else. Our go-to combo was Mexican vanilla with Oreos and strawberries—absolutely delicious.

The two ladies who helped us each night were incredibly kind and even shared some of the shop’s history with us, which made the experience even more special.

We’d 100% recommend this spot, though to be fair, our recommendation is based on our overall love of ice cream rather than comparing it to other places in the Keys.

Said they are the cheapest ice cream on duval street but don’t believe that. there are way more reasonably priced ice cream shops on duval and this one makes you pay a lot for a small portion. Key west is already a very expensive place to live, shop, and vacation at and they are charging way to much for just ice cream so get your sweet tooth cravings somewhere else please save your money.

You only have 2 options but they are very tasty!

Perfect coffee

As a liquid nitrogen ice cream food truck owner myself, it was wonderful to find Wicked Lick in Key West. It’s the best ice cream I’ve found east of Utah! I love their all-natural homemade flavors and creamy texture. Vegan option was awesome. Owner was terrific and made me happy and eager to support his business.

Got served by the owner. My first time having pistachio ice cream. It was so tasty. Hus ice cream is made in house, that's pretty rare. We ate there twice.

One option, coconut vanilla, but it’s good!

Ice cream tasted watered down by in several flavors that were ordered by multiple people in our group.

Vegan Reef Diver…mmmm dairy free coconut ice cream with agave, crushed Oreo cookies, large chunks of fresh strawberries, and a berry sauce. Absolutely delicious!! The service was friendly and the place was spotless!!

Dietary restrictions: Plant based vegan

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great ice cream!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

BEST ICE CREAM EVER! Butter pecan ice cream with candied pecans Caramel drizzle and waffle chips! Absolutely to die for!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Butter Pecan Ice Cream, Cookie Butter, Waffle Chips, Candied Pecans, Butter Pecan

Worst ice cream ever. Pricy and not creamy at all. We have tried 4 flavors and all the same texture: watery.
No wander this place was empty.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4