Wicked Lick Ice Cream Key West

As a New Yorker, I tend to be picky about ice cream. The Wicked Lick did not disappoint. It was fresh (my husband's had just finished being made) and delicious. Highly recommend the coffee flavor!!!

Best ice cream in Key West!

Key Lime ice cream was very good..great servce!

The staff is very friendly and great! Tasty ice cream. I tried the key lime, which was good!

Looked forward to trying this but felt the flavors were just ok and the ice cream too icy..not enough cream. Cute place and good location.

Wicked Lick ice cream is a five star spot celebrated for making the freshest, densest, and creamiest ice cream by freezing every batch instantly with liquid nitrogen. This process ensures a superior texture and vibrant flavor. You must try their unique items like the savory ice cream nachos or their over the top wicked shakes. It's the ultimate destination for an unforgettable and visually thrilling dessert.

The only thing I regret is not going back for more or getting a bigger size (we just had one day in Key West)! I tried the roasted pistachio topped with chopped pistachios and the Ghirardelli chocolate topped with chocolate flakes in one cup, and it was amazing! Still dreaming about it, sitting in Michigan.

They have amazing pup cups for dogs 🐶😍❤️ My dog loved it!

Sweet ladies at the booth, allowed me to taste multiple flavors before I made up my mind. They were also sweet enough to make a Oreo milkshake for a friend even though they technically don’t sell milkshakes on paper. The ice cream was great! They freeze the concentrate using liquid nitrogen to make the cream due to which the texture is soft and tastes really good. Not too sweet and just right! It’s a cute shop with minimal seating which works really well! I highly recommend it!

Vegan coconut agave ice cream available

Amazing place! Super yummy ice cream and very friendly staff. Highly recommended! We tried the chocolate, strawberry and the cream with caramel.

They were very welcoming and friendly. I had a lot of questions about the ingredients due to a dairy allergy. I ended up getting the Vegan Reef Diver Sundae and it was delicious. They only had one vegan flavor and it was coconut agave, but it was very good. Their ice cream making process is also fun to watch while eating your ice cream.

Wicked Lick did not disappoint! The ice cream was rich, creamy, and full of flavor. You can really taste the quality in every scoop. The staff was friendly, the vibes were fun, and it was the perfect little treat. Definitely worth stopping by if you’re craving something delicious! 🍨✨

The cold coffee tasted very bitter.
Hazelnut Latte was decent too

Tasty ice cream and kind workers! It was a tad pricey, but that’s to be expected in a tourism town. Lots of silly signs throughout the interior to keep you amused while waiting in line 🍨✨