Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen

5950 Peninsular Ave, Key West
(786) 862-6305

Recent Reviews

Billy Horton

The food is fantastic!!! Alex our waiter was fantastic very attentive and provided us great service. Alexandria at the hostess desk was outstanding!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

MAN KAT A1.1 Grobi

After waiting for over an hour to get breakfast we were just seconds away from leaving without food when it was finally served. Super disappointing and definitely never again!

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 1

Sasha Watson

Great food, drinks and service. The staff are so nice and attentive. Felt like family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nanci Mooney

Noisy when they did Friday movies, needed more seating options at pools. Rooms nice and staff

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Drake

We were greeted immediately and with exceptional courtesy. We were given options for the table and seated quickly. Or server was attentive and very helpful with questions. The setting was beautiful and the food was excellent!

We didn't expect a 20% gratuity to be added for our family of 3. Waitress was nearly nonexistent. We wished we had the male waiter who was flying around like Superman but our waitress though all were pleasant, weren't there. There is no way our waitress should get the same tip as the waiter who was so attentive to his tables! Outdoors seating was beautiful and the nice solo live musician singing was unexpected surprise. I asked the hostess if the outdoors was buggy & she responded no; it was mosquito filled especially as we were sat next to the bushes. Husband & I got hogfish which was thin and overcooked, some parts of the filet had many bones. My broccoli side had crunchy sand in many bites. My son's filet mignon was superbly cooked tho & my son loved his dish. Lastly, the prices are outrageous for this. Nothing special except for son's filet mignon which was good. Then they added the 20% gratuity on top...

We eat here often and have always enjoyed ourselves. Valentines was not one of their best nights. The service was slow and the Valentines Spcial was not up to their regular standards: the steak was tough and overcooked.

Tim Swiat

We have enjoyed breakfast here at the Yellowfin twice. Andrei and Jean were more than attentive and professional making sure that our visit was five stars. While we are still getting used to slowing down from our fast-paced experiences back at home, Andrei was there when we needed him....checking in at the right times and not when we had bites in our mouths. That speaks to someone who understands service. Tremendous time at the resort, and will be back again soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nisha

Great fish and shrimp tacos! Average chicken burger. Overpriced food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Sierra Belote

Great location overlooking marina/resort. Food is really good but very pricey. Service is lacking.Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible, but has quite a long ramp into restaurant. Might need assistance if pushing yourself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Poke Bowl

Angie A

They have great food and a good assortment of items to choose from. The servers are always great too. Loved the atmosphere there.

Sonya S

Recently stayed at OceansEdge resort and ate at the Yellowfin twice. The service provided by Branka and Alex was excellent! Love that there are inside & outside dining options with live music & fire pits

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barbara English

We came here for the first ever Trivia. That was a blast! The host, Amy is hilarious and makes it so much fun. The food was really good and they had 3 swimming pools! Also, it's right on the water and as we were leaving they invited us back for movie night, outside next to (or while lounging in) the pool. This place is a

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

KWTJA

The specialty holiday menu's are phenomenal! We ate here for New Year’s Eve. They were doing a specialty menu; three courses, beautiful plating. Cindy met us at the door, and graciously found us an open seat despite the restaurant being very busy, Alecia showed us to our table, and Alex our server was top-notch the entire night. The course plating was incredible: chef Yeni and her team make delicious cuisine. John, I believe that was the bartenders name, makes the best fiery margaritas! The restaurant manager stopped by to check on us, I believe his name was Adrian, and wished us a Happy New Year on our way out. 10/10 would eat here again. Great atmosphere, live music, delicious food. What more could you ask for.

NancyG

We were seated in a timely manner, but we were not waited on in a timely manner. We waited over 20 minutes no drinks, so we left. When I made the reservation I was not told that it would be a special menu or that the price was going to be $95 a person.

Load More