Old Hickory Steakhouse

Seriously a 5 star restaurant! Food is incredible! Service is professional and friendly. Atmosphere beautiful. Everything about eating here is a whole experience all the way to picking out your own steak knife. Steaks and cheeses are aged in house. I can't even begin to describe how delicious it is. Try it!!

Not my fist time there , Ambience is nice ! Holidays But became extremely commercial experience They will try to milk you out to my surprise they refused to stamp My vale ticket , as they used to before So since we came with two cars they ended up requesting $100 plus tax and tips of course . I explained I didn't know they do that during holidays which is pretty tricky and not straight forward ? Will think twice before booking or inviting friends or work associates To this place again !

The atmosphere, service, and food were exceptional! We were greeted and seated promptly. The hostess was very pleasant and explained about the steaks and the honey on the way to the table. Our server, Sally, was personable and efficient. Another gentleman was assisting (forgot name). He was extremely helpful too. The charcuterie was amazing! We also tried the Scallops as an appetizer. We both ordered Filet Mignons, with the Corn dish as a side. Outstanding! A nice touch was allowing us to choose our steak knives. We look forward to dining here again soon!

We had multiple servers for our meal but Tony was the person who spent the most time with us. He was friendly, attentive and his recommendations were excellent. Everything was great!

We had a wonderful dinner at Old Hickory Steakhouse! The steak was cooked perfectly, the sides were delicious, and the service and ambiance were excellent. 10/10 experience and we will definitely eat there again.

We have been wanting to try Old Hickory for a while. First off, the service was outstanding! Hands down the best service so this is no reflection on service or the resort itself. The food is what let us down. We are “foodies” and love a good Delmonico. This is the first thing my husband had his eye on, so he ordered it without hesitation. Sadly, it was one of the toughest steaks we’ve ever had. The steak temperature was cooked perfectly, but even so, it was extremely tough and he had to cut off a lot of pieces and eat around it. We also ordered the lamb which was overcooked. The side dishes were not bad, and the lobster Mac and cheese did not have much lobster in it…just something to note. We chose not to send the food back bc we had the kids with us and it was getting late so we had to be mindful of our time. It’s definitely not what we expected for a $450 dinner. Cocktails were great and again, best service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

I really enjoyed Old Hickory steakhouse, the food was amazing and loved the atmosphere under the dome. I'm celiac and staff took exceptional care with the food handling and educating me on what I could eat. The gluten free bread was incredible with the honey butter! Everything was amazing really and I will definitely return next visit to Orlando.

Food, service and atmosphere were amazing. Our waiter Dave was excellent. Highly recommend this restaurant!

Been here as a part of conference and we loved the ambience here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

The wait staff was excellent, friendly and prompt. The food was delicious, well worth the cost. We received our food in a timely manner, without a long wait.

I wish I could give this establishment greater than five stars! The ambience as you walk up already sets the mood. We are here on a Thursday and this is the least populated we’ve ever seen here at the hotel. This time of year seems to be ideal to come. The staff was fantastic. Start to finish. David was an excellent server and made great recommendations. We came for my son‘s 10th birthday. We had the crab cake appetizer which had a bounty of a lump crab meat topped with foam and caviar. It’s a must! Ryan went for the typical kids, chicken fingers and fries. But once he saw the Wagyu ribeye that my sister and I were splitting, he switched for us and started eating her steak. Best steak, any of us have ever had! The truffle potato wedges were stellar! Or dessert Ryan got the carrot cake and it was just as phenomenal as the rest of the meal. It’s an expensive meal, but you absolutely get what you pay for. Everything about this meal from the quality of food, the high level of service, and the ambience made this a meal to remember.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I had an absolutely wonderful experience at Old Hickory Steakhouse - Gaylord for a family birthday celebration! The service was nothing short of excellent, with our server Alex going above and beyond to make the evening special. Alex was attentive, friendly, and ensured every detail was perfect, adding a warm touch to our celebration. The ambience was delightful—cozy yet elegant, creating just the right atmosphere for a memorable gathering. The food was truly great, with every dish bursting with flavor and beautifully presented, leaving everyone at the table impressed. From start to finish, Old Hickory Steakhouse made our birthday celebration unforgettable. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a fantastic dining experience!

Everything was wonderful from the delicious food to the wonderful customer service! We loved it all. Thank you so much!

Absolutely delicious food and drinks! Service was fantastic... Jay was very knowledgeable and treated us well!! Highly recommend!

We had a great time. The food was amazing! Our server Sharon was fantastic. We highly recommend this restaurant if you are looking for really good food this is the place to go.