Maggie Mae's Ice Cream Shop
125 E Park Ave, Lake Wales
(863) 456-4555
Customers' Favorites
Banana Pudding and Strawberry Ice Cream
Sugar Free Coffee Ice Cream
Cookies and Creme
Cherry Aimond
Peanut Buffer
Rocky Road
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
My family met our homeschool group here for a back to school ice cream social and our experience was amazing! The staff was friendly and patient with our large group. We tried the Cherry Almond, Chocolate and Cookies n Cream ice cream flavors, and they were all delicious! I think the best part of the experience was getting to watch them make the ice cream as ordered! The kids loved it! Very cool shop.
Our homeschool group met here for ice cream and we had a wonderful experience. Amazing ice cream and great staff! They were very nice and attentive. Definitely recommend going here!
What a unique experience!!We not only had amazing tasting treats, we also had an impromptu science lesson! As we waited for our delectable creations, we discussed how the ice cream was being made right before our eyes. Definitely recommend.
You May Also Like
Melanie's Seafood Company - 120 E Park Ave
![]()
Seafood, Burgers
Market Cafe - 20 N Market St
![]()
Cafe, Salad, Soup
Pete's Phase III - 118 E Crystal Ave
![]()
Bar, Sports Bar