Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream company

Overall great experience. The food was amazing and the service was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Have tried their pizza, calzone, and wings with all being very good 👍 at the suggestion of the owner, today was a Boss Hog sub kinda day. And wow! Excellent toasted roll, homemade meatballs, house marinara, and the 'cheesy pasta'. Described as a blend of Alfredo, queso, and mozzarella cheese 🧀 😋 it has redefined my thoughts about the perfect pasta sauce 😋
Well played Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Been in Lakeland for a year and three months... This is BY FAR the Best pizza in town. There is absolutely nothing even close to this good, North Side or South Side. I'll be back next week!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

pizza was pretty good, in terms of value, it's solid, pizza was cooked perfectly, figured i'd give this place a try since i've never ate here before, regardless of it being delivered, it still came out great and i would recommend this to anyone looking to try new places!

Hey all, this place honestly was not worth the money or effort. My family and I ordered two pizzas and some baked ziti and spaghetti and honestly we could have gotten better from the frozen section. The pizza is paper thin with the pepperonis being nothing but the little chips you get on Tontinos frozen pizzas. The ziti was more cheese than anything and the sauce was beyond bland. The 5 of us all had the opinions that it seemed as if they opened a jar of sauce and dumped it on with some cheese on top.. 2/10 def a 1 and done experience! I will say that their customer service was delightful... But honestly if you guys want to charge the prices that you do you need to put a little more effort into the food and taste quality.

Food: 1

Service: 4

I'm trying to figure out how a 10 inch pizza costs 30 bucks and it got here in 15 minutes and was cold as hell. Oh now i know. It must be the crunchy three day old sausage and meat.

Addendum. I just saw your reply. Your pizza was cold and old and crunchy. And your customer service is even weaker. 3 stars was being kind. Your math is wrong the order came in at 3 17. It did need to cook right? Say 20 minutes but is was at my door before that.

Food: 3

Great tasting pizza just— to my believe just a little over prized —- $12.00 2 slice & Soda! Times are difficult I guess I’ll sacrifice .!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 3

I lived in New York and New Jersey for over 15 years and it has been very hard to find a really good pizza in Lakeland. You have definitely won my heart over with my first order from your company.
I ordered delivery and you immediately called me back to tell me you did not have the small bottles of soda and offered to send a couple of ice and a 2 L. That was appreciated.
I ordered a large pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni, and was astonished at how large it was. And although I originally took one slice out of the box, I knew I could not stop it just one piece. It was delicious, perfect crust, delicious toppings, And cooked perfectly.
If you are looking for pizza that is close to New York style pizza, I highly encourage you to try Wabash pizzeria. You won’t be disappointed.

Food: 5

Service: 5

We ordered from Wabash Pizza while we were down for a graduation. The pizza was delicious! The crust was foldable and perfectly textured. The sauce and toppings were generous and tasty. Highly recommend!

Food: 5

The John father was a delicious pizza I can't wait to try other food from here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

BBQ chicken pizza from here is awesome and the hot wings are good there's alot to choose from pasta, sandwiches, pizza, wings, most definitely coming back

Food here is mediocre at best. The pizza I ordered was basically a burnt totinos pizza — actually, I probably would have preferred that. The pasta my wife ordered was waaay overcooked and the sauce was super watery. We were charged once when we ordered and then they tried charging us again when we were leaving with our order. I was so disappointed, especially because our friends had spoken so highly of this place.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

ordered pick-up of the 12*18 thick crust pizza with one topping, which oddly is not on their online menu anymore. As you can see this pizza was not thick at all with a very small amount of topping. I also did not like the flavor of the sauce nor the fact it left a lasting aftertaste in my mouth. I will usually save the leftover for the next day to eat, but this one I threw out what I didn't eat. This was the first time getting food from here so I do not know if this is the normal quality. My wife ordered a calzone, however I did not try it so I can not rate the calzone.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

My favorite spot. The owners are super chill. Service is always on point. Our food is always fresh. If you want something modified they are always happy to make something the way you want it. Mrs. Courtney makes the BEST sweet tea! If you haven't been here you need to check it out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tried this place for the first time tonight.Owner was super nice. Wife and i had the chicken parm with pasta and a small 10in pizza. it was really freaking good. I will be coming back!