Black Sheep American Pub

18450 US-41, Lutz
(813) 528-8757

Recent Reviews

Sort by
jillian lamberty

Best Pub food around!!! Their pizza is literally the best, we get it every time we are there for Trivia Night! Highly recommend

Narrow Hwy

Pizza crust was soaked with what I can only imagine was stale vegetable shortening and being a thin crust the overtone of stale oil dominated the flavor of the pizza.
The cheese was low grade but the marinara sauce was ok if not a bit scarce.
Cheese were good but cooked in oil lower the 450° ergo the breading was super super greasy!
Probably a great hangout for draft beers and drink but not the food.

Robert Noriega

I checked this place out today on a whim and the food was a mixed bag unfortunately, which based on the reviews, must have just been an off day for them.
The chicken fries were super crispy and tender with good flavor & the cheese curds were absolutely delicious - my favorite item of the day.
Unfortunately, the soft pretzel had the texture of a frozen pretzel that had been microwaved (though the beer cheese helped).
The most disappointing bite of the day were from the deviled eggs, which actually was the main draw for me to visit because I LOVE a good deviled egg. The pork on top was tasty but I had a faint taste that can only be described as dish water. 🫢
I will still go back and give this place another shot to try different menu items, but just might not order the deviled eggs again.

Nicholas Mana

Food is alright. Beer is great. Staff is awesome.

Christiana Michael

Atmosphere is awesome and the smash burgers are really good. We went on a Tuesday when it was trivia night and Michael was the friendliest guy. Great place :)!

Robert Pena

Been there like 4 times already food has been very good each time , but the service seems to get worse each time. Maybe it's just I go at the wiring times but this past Friday they had Kareoke and I sat at the high top by the front door and sat there for 15 minutes and no one ever approached me the server who had pony tails passed by me twice . So I got up to leave and I see the server sitting at the bar watching Kareoke while I was not approached. So I left

Becky G Phakos

we were on vacation and this was the most amazing place we could have found. the owner and workers were so fricken awesome. we played l pool and had such great service. I can't say enough good things about the owner and his establishment

Jenny Todd

Good date night on Saturday's place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries, Black Sheep Burger, Smash Burger

Logan Hamilton

It is just garbage

rebecca guindine

We love eating here! Everyone can find something they like. Our faves are the Cuban egg rolls, burgers, and deviled eggs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fowl Play with a Salad, BYO Eggroll Platter, Black Sheep Burger, Pork Belly Deviled Eggs, The Only Ten-I-See, Chicken Fries

diesel jang

Ppl make noise so bad. But they don't care. It was so bad

Mitch Spence

Writing this on the way to a drive-thru after leaving this establishment. Arrived at 6:45pm on a Saturday night - there was one waitress on the floor and one bartender at the bar. Restaurant was not even at half-capacity. 45 minutes after placing our food order, we decided to leave when a party of 6 who was seated ahead of us STILL hadn't received their meals. We drove 20 minutes to get here, reviews looked solid and food looked tasty... but never got to try it. Maybe it was an off night, but we won't be back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Andrea Hanes

Our favorite place! We love it here! Fun menu, great food, awesome staff! We feel like we're coming home when we walk in!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ann Compton

Always great service and food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Pork Belly Deviled Eggs

Jonathan Duffey

I’m picky as eff. Perfection. X crispy and sauced

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...

Black Sheep American Pub

18450 US-41, Lutz, FL 33549
(813) 528-8757