New York Pizza Express

14609 Livingston Ave, Lutz
(813) 285-5710

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nic Torrance

Great place for collection, no dine in options. You can’t even go in the shop, they take your order outside. Pizza was delicious, highly recommend. It seems the low reviews are for delivery, we really enjoyed ours that we collected.

Liam Lieber

My cheese and toppings quite literally slid off. Absolutely zero adhesion to the dough.

Erin Scruggs

Always great food, not a dine in place, take out only

Kammi Tipton

Our food came with fermented marinara sauce. The sauce was so fermented that the lids on the cups had expanded to the point of busting open. One of the people in our group didn’t realize it was bad and now he’s been attached to our hotel toilet all night and this morning. The garlic knots weren’t knots they were dough triangles with a dusting of Parmesan and a drop of butter. They were so hard I could use them bust the window out of my car. The pizza had almost no sauce and three pieces of pineapple. The Stromboli was gigantic but had little man energy, garbage. Don’t order from here if you want good food, if you don’t care about sitting on the toilet all day, this is your place.

This guy is padding his reviews, so any five stars you see it’s the owner😂

Bryan

Yet another flyer placed under a hotel door. Ordered a pizza, garlic knots, and a calzone. Garlic knots were little flavorless bricks, no sauce on the pizza, and the marinara sauce was fermented. Our group is taking turns with the diarrhea 12 hours later. For all that is holy, don’t eat here. Congratulations Mr owner man, you made me write my first review in 10 years.

Felipe

Best pizza in their zip code I went once and kept going back ever since 😃

Captain Hook

Took an hour and 20 minutes. Cold. Fries were 100 years old. Pizza was cold and tasted what I imagine would be identical to my great grandmother's dead poon.
Be better! - CM

Susan Seidel

The only redeeming factor was that they deliver after 2AM. Pizza was cold and tasted like it was a frozen pizza. Very disappointed.

freire ramirez

I bought a large Hawaiian pizza around 11:15 pm, the pizza had this insect on it.

Wally Genz

After 2hrs wait, Pizza was delivered Cold. Taste non existent. Stay away not worth it

Joshua Durant

A “New York” pizza shop would never do this get it together

Taija Johnson

The pizza and garlic bread were great.
The Alfredo pasta wasn’t that good at all. I recommend getting the pizza.

Thomas Stone

Absolutely a great value for the quality and great customer service.

Lorie Richter

Ordered while vacationing in Tampa, very disappointed. Wings were tough and there wasn't hardly any toppings on pizza . Too expensive for the quality of food.
We had delivered to our hotel.

Natacha Noel

The food was very nasty the lemon pepper wing was hard and salty.

Loading...