Calendars Pizzeria & Sport Bar

I love their pizza!

Awesome cauliflower crust pizzas

We're regulars now! We come each week and order something different on the menu. So far we've never been disappointed! For starters...their staff are the friendliest and most personable people. Also, the salad is as.fresh as plucking all the ingredients from a garden outback. Their cheese is the best. Other places have some kind of weird cheese that they use but Calendar's uses the best cheese in all of North Florida. It's a weird thing to point out but it's very important. We'll definitely see you all next week

Remodel looks great

A solid pub style pizza experience to be certain. The toppings were fresh and generous in their supply. It reminded me of a really good street pizza, but indoor.

Pizza crust is a unique twist on it in the area. It is thin but resilient and has an enjoyable crunch to it. Generous use of cheese keeps the whole thing together well.

The southwestern egg rolls were decent and held up to chili's by comparison and were far better than I anticipated.

The Gluten Free Pizza was also good with generous toppings and was better than generally is expected from options available at other restaurants. My wife was able to eat there without any irritating her stomach and said she would order it again in the future.

Overall, it is a really fairly priced and good quality food option for the Maclenny area, and I can recommend it to others. It is superior to the general fast food pizza options available, and I will be coming back again

The decor wasn't particularly amazing, but it was very welcoming and was what you could expect in a small town pizza place. There is a jukebox, and I did think it would be a great location to have drinks and decent food where standing room was essential. Events and the like would be very at home here.

Pool tables in the bar area are a welcome addition to the bar side of the location and putting that together with the quality of the food could make this a great location for a affordable but fun night out for those seeking a hangout location.

Service was good for lunch when I came through, and I will have to try more high traffic time to see if that changes pace, but it does have a very laid back vibe that others could misinterpret as slow to someone expecting fast food pizza.

Overall a 4, but a solid 4 that could drift into the 4.5 range depending on the circumstances and what you are after.

Update: So in earnest, these guys are my go to in town now. I'm updating their rating from my previous one based on their consistency in quality and the people I have had interactions with.

The workers are awesome, and they are good people who are really just good to work with. Each time I have had face contact with a different person and they have all been wonderful people.

I have social anxiety and yet in this place I don't find issue with being at all. It feels like everyone is welcome there and it emanates from the people working there.

Im cheering for this place, and I can say that about few places.

Im giving this a 5 because it deserves it for it s consistent ability to meet and exceed expectations.

Server showed up to take order, then didn’t see her for water refills or even ask how the food was. Ordered the chicken Alfredo pizza and asked for a little extra grilled chicken. The small pizza came out with barely any chicken on it. Plus the spinach was frozen and looked like they just dropped a spoon full here and there on it, plus still cold, barely any sauce. Didnt eat 3/4 of it, and the server didn’t even ask about it just took it. Got the check which had 1.50 for “extra chicken”, plus charged us for the ranch for the pizza. Got sick to my stomach 20 minutes after we left. Won’t be back

This is a well established restaurant and pool hall with decent but slow service and excellent food. They have mini calzone type sandwiches a bit different from what you are used to getting elsewhere. The service was way too slow for a working person limited to an hour lunch but you can call ahead. The prices are a bit high but that's to be expected when you get real food and not the commercial crap you find in corporate stores. If you want a beverage with good food while hustling a table in a relaxed atmosphere, this is the place to come relax.

They forgot an entire pizza on my order and offered no compensation. I wouldn't ever eat here again.

The best pizza in town 😋

Really good service n food

Calendars has posted on their Facebook page their menu with prices. They are not true. We ordered two medium pizzas and a full Greek salad. It cost almost $10 more than their posted prices. I tried to speak with owner, she has not returned my call. It is important to me as to spending our hard earned money. I hope this will be rectified really soon as it Needs to be. Thank you.

Great pizza

The January was great as always. Slow to get my food and was afraid of being hit by flying pool balls, but server was friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Pizza, Greek Salad

Service was not top notch and music was was too loud but food was very good!❤️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Wings, Calzone, The Greek Pizza, Big Pete Medium Pizza, Greek Salad

Probably the worst wings and fries I’ve ever had, and some of the most disorganized and terrible service I’ve experienced. Tried to double charge us for our food and drinks. Go literally anywhere else.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1