First time at 844 did not disappoint.. Pablo our waiter was excellent, my steak was really good and cooked to perfection. The house old fashion was so good..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ken Harter
Our NEW favorite restaurant in Marco Island. The moment we met the hostess to the moment we left the restaurant, 5 Stars. Great food, service and atmosphere. I would recommend to ALL to put this restaurant on your list. I can’t wait to visit again on our next trip to Marco Island. Thank you !!! P.S. Get the Bananas Foster dessert !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marco Matouk
Expected a much better experience. It was just Ok for us!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
ANTHONY CHIDIAC
A small hidden gem in a small hidden island marco island I had homes in marco island for over 40 years snd now I own a paradise retreat I marco . I had the pleasure to visit that restaurant for the fist time and I really was pleasantly surprised. The menu self illuminated and for me that was a pleaser as I did not have to use my reading glasses. The waiter was very nice and surpisingly offered us a 40 percent discount on any bottle of wine under 100 dollars .do ghsg was very nice. The appetizers the octopus and the shrimps were fabulous and very well presented . The main dish the grouper with the crab meat was exquisite and buttery in flavor and very tasty. The veal medallion were very well prepared. The dessert on the other hand was ok. But overall the meal was very tasty and I do recommend this place if you st ed going to spend some time in marco
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
CoralToons The Vyonder 2004
Definitely will NEVER return! The food very underwhelming and that is being kind . Even the plating is so 90's .. especially for those prices . No wonder the place is empty!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
patti staniorski
Had a fantastic meal and drinks at 844 last week. Been there several times now and it never disappoints. Bartenders and the chef are top notch. Thank you for a great evening!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Justin S
The experience was excellent. The manager was welcoming and gave us a tour around the dining areas as it was our first time here and let us choose where we wanted to sit. We choose a high top in the bar side. It was not too busy and was nice and quiet. Luke was our server and he was fantastic. Great to talk to and attentive throughout the meal- he even shared a quick magic card trick with us, dinner and a show! The menus were backlit for a wonderful high end feeling and the food was perfectly prepared and delicious. We had the stuffed grouper and a medium 8 oz filet. The drinks were also expertly crafted. An elevated experience for sure. We will be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
steve v
This place is a must go in Marco. Place had a great setting, clean, and casual for a steak house. Ribeye and filet were amazing, cooked perfect and the wait staff was amazing. 5 stars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kim Jean
The bar is top notch, love the charcuterie board, always is a good time, just a different vibe from the standard Marco restaurants. The beet salad was fantastic and we all enjoyed our steak dinners cooked to perfection, plenty of options on the menu for everyone in the party. The dessert choices are delicious but the cheese cake martini 🍸 is just next level. I am never disappointed when someone says let's go to 844.
Marco Island Real Estate BROS
Wow!!! Just wow! I’ve been here around 10 times and take my real estate clients cause I know it’s going to be great service, great food and drinks and it’s going to be consistent! Keep it up!
Drinks were goid, bar service was very good. Steak sliders were very good. However, the king crab medallions were obviously fake crab and overly salty quite frankly I shouldn't have paid for them.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
brian shirley
Delicious rib eye with spinach, asparagus, fingerling potatoes and mushrooms. Cooked perfectly. Will go there again next time in Marco.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vincent
Marco Island needs a high end steakhouse and when I returned for the season I was excited to see this place. Too bad it didn't live up to expectations. Our server took our order then pretty much ignored us until it was time for the check. Now to be fair we didn't order steak but the seafood dishes were underwhelming at best. It's the first time I've ever ordered a martini and been charged for olives @$2/each. Two martinis and a $8 upcharge for olives. And yes if you pay by credit card they add 3%. One positive. The sommelier, I believe his name is Henry really paid attention to what was going on in the restaurant and was picking the slack where the waitstaff and bus people fell short. At one point one of the bus people grabbed my son's half eaten plate right off the table but Henry quickly retrieved it. Still next time we will drive to Naples
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Jack Bruton
This place is incredible. Amazing service, the attention to detail is exceptional, the flavors of the food and deserts are delightful. Snow bird or local. If you want a atmospheric meal with phenomenal service and out of this world flavours come here!
Alex behind the bar is incredibly attentive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tomas Mica
Great food, better service, just be prepared to pay. Strongly recommend getting a reservation, best food I’ve had on the island.
First time at 844 did not disappoint.. Pablo our waiter was excellent, my steak was really good and cooked to perfection. The house old fashion was so good..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Our NEW favorite restaurant in Marco Island. The moment we met the hostess to the moment we left the restaurant, 5 Stars. Great food, service and atmosphere. I would recommend to ALL to put this restaurant on your list. I can’t wait to visit again on our next trip to Marco Island. Thank you !!! P.S. Get the Bananas Foster dessert !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Expected a much better experience. It was just Ok for us!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
A small hidden gem in a small hidden island marco island
I had homes in marco island for over 40 years snd now I own a paradise retreat I marco . I had the pleasure to visit that restaurant for the fist time and I really was pleasantly surprised. The menu self illuminated and for me that was a pleaser as I did not have to use my reading glasses. The waiter was very nice and surpisingly offered us a 40 percent discount on any bottle of wine under 100 dollars .do ghsg was very nice. The appetizers the octopus and the shrimps were fabulous and very well presented . The main dish the grouper with the crab meat was exquisite and buttery in flavor and very tasty. The veal medallion were very well prepared. The dessert on the other hand was ok. But overall the meal was very tasty and I do recommend this place if you st ed going to spend some time in marco
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Definitely will NEVER return! The food very underwhelming and that is being kind . Even the plating is so 90's .. especially for those prices . No wonder the place is empty!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Had a fantastic meal and drinks at 844 last week. Been there several times now and it never disappoints. Bartenders and the chef are top notch. Thank you for a great evening!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The experience was excellent. The manager was welcoming and gave us a tour around the dining areas as it was our first time here and let us choose where we wanted to sit. We choose a high top in the bar side. It was not too busy and was nice and quiet. Luke was our server and he was fantastic. Great to talk to and attentive throughout the meal- he even shared a quick magic card trick with us, dinner and a show! The menus were backlit for a wonderful high end feeling and the food was perfectly prepared and delicious. We had the stuffed grouper and a medium 8 oz filet. The drinks were also expertly crafted. An elevated experience for sure. We will be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a must go in Marco. Place had a great setting, clean, and casual for a steak house. Ribeye and filet were amazing, cooked perfect and the wait staff was amazing. 5 stars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The bar is top notch, love the charcuterie board, always is a good time, just a different vibe from the standard Marco restaurants. The beet salad was fantastic and we all enjoyed our steak dinners cooked to perfection, plenty of options on the menu for everyone in the party. The dessert choices are delicious but the cheese cake martini 🍸 is just next level. I am never disappointed when someone says let's go to 844.
Wow!!! Just wow! I’ve been here around 10 times and take my real estate clients cause I know it’s going to be great service, great food and drinks and it’s going to be consistent! Keep it up!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Drinks were goid, bar service was very good. Steak sliders were very good. However, the king crab medallions were obviously fake crab and overly salty quite frankly I shouldn't have paid for them.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Delicious rib eye with spinach, asparagus, fingerling potatoes and mushrooms. Cooked perfectly. Will go there again next time in Marco.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marco Island needs a high end steakhouse and when I returned for the season I was excited to see this place. Too bad it didn't live up to expectations. Our server took our order then pretty much ignored us until it was time for the check. Now to be fair we didn't order steak but the seafood dishes were underwhelming at best. It's the first time I've ever ordered a martini and been charged for olives @$2/each. Two martinis and a $8 upcharge for olives. And yes if you pay by credit card they add 3%. One positive. The sommelier, I believe his name is Henry really paid attention to what was going on in the restaurant and was picking the slack where the waitstaff and bus people fell short. At one point one of the bus people grabbed my son's half eaten plate right off the table but Henry quickly retrieved it. Still next time we will drive to Naples
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
This place is incredible. Amazing service, the attention to detail is exceptional, the flavors of the food and deserts are delightful. Snow bird or local. If you want a atmospheric meal with phenomenal service and out of this world flavours come here!
Alex behind the bar is incredibly attentive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, better service, just be prepared to pay. Strongly recommend getting a reservation, best food I’ve had on the island.
Loading...