We usually visit Fin Bistro every time we come to Marco Island. Best fish on the island! Sides that come with the dinners are delicious. Highly recommend.
Mark
We enjoyed everything about our meal. Our server, Sal, was fantastic. He was fun and friendly.
Dee
We've been going to Fin over 10 years every winter we're in Marco. The food has gone downhill. Both of our fish entrees were overcooked. I overheard others mention the same. Very disappointing a restaurant that pride itself on fresh fish is not able to cook it properly:(
Lou Ann
Swordfish piccata was excellent. Dinner special for the price was not very good. Lobster Mac and cheese was over cooked. Service excellent. Recognized birthday with a treat! Will return.
Heather
Our server was awesome. We had food allergies and he made sure we would be able to eat safely. The tuna was the best I'd ever had! It was a great dinner.
Carol
Our second dine at Fin Bistro and it proves it is consistently "excellent" over the years. Our party of six was very happy all around. Try the swordfish. It is exceptional!
Jeffrey
This was our first(BUT NOT LAST) visit to Fin Bistro after years of staying on Marco Island. The food from the Frito Misto (one of the best we've had) and Charred Octopus appetizers to the Lobster Risotto that I had, as well as the Florida Black Grouper that my wife had was OUTSTANDING. We also ordered a side of their creamed corn which you should not pass up. Our service was impeccable and Steve the manger checked on us twice to ensure we were having a good experience. If you are on or going to Marco Island do not pass up the chance to dine here!!!!!!
TIMOTHY
Food was exceptional, and our waitress was wonderful. We were not happy with the location of the tables offered. One was looking right into the kitchen and the next one was right next to the exit so there was a lot of traffic. I know someone has to sit there, but I just wish it wasn't me.
Suzanne
Our first visit to Fin Bistro. Derek our server was great in suggesting dishes we try. My husband tried the blackened shrimp pasta and enjoyed it. I tried the Tuna Gremolata which was a great choice suggestion by Derek. The seared tuna was perfect with a nice crispy texture. We will definitely be coming back.
Buddy
Fin Bistro never disappoints! This is absolutely our favorite restaurant on Marco Island. Peter and his whole staff are wonderful and the food is amazing! Our favorite is the Dorado it's perfect every time. 
Our server Jennifer was excellent. Attentive, kind and very on top of everything. We have been longstanding customers of Finn Bistro of 16 years. It's always been our #1 go to spot for a nice dinner and date night. Anticipating it would be the best dinner, we were honestly disappointed in the fish special portion size and the dryness. The scallops were delicious but the mashed potatoes were not my fave. They used to be creamy and delicious like they were pureed. I never eat potatoes but this is the one place I'd try them as they were just really good. If I order scallops every again, I'd ask for a vegetable sub to avoid these potatoes. I had the Bibb salad with goat cheese ball which I love but that portion seemed smaller than usual and for $16 it was not worth it. We understand prices have gone up and it's necessary to adjust them over the years but this has gotten a bit much. We likely won't be returning to our favorite spot because it's just not what it was when the original owner had it. The noise was louder with two four tops seated next to us on either side too.
Bryan
We have lived on Marco Island for 13 years. Fin Bistro has been my favorite restaurant hands down since the first time we went there. There location changed a few years back but it made no difference...it has been just as good. Whenever we have guests I always make sure we go there at least once while they are here. Halibut last night was excellent. Our waitress also was excellent. I feel bad I don't recall her name BUT she had the black framed glasses and dark hair and served our table of seven and was perfect.
William
My main complaint is the timing of the service. Our server brought our initial beverages and then disappeared for a half hour, before reappearing to take our food order. The pace was simply too slow. Nor was there much attention to matters like refilling water.
Karen
Always the freshest and best fish on Marco Island! The pan seared halibut over risotto in a Dijon cream sauce was to die for! Also the beet salad was delicious.
Venetia
The coconut shrimp tempura was delicious. Crisp on the outside and tender jumbo shrimp on the inside. My husband had the shrimp and pasta dish which he enjoyed as well. Since it was our 51st Anniversary, they treated us to an outrageous dessert! Wait staff is excellentl.
We usually visit Fin Bistro every time we come to Marco Island. Best fish on the island! Sides that come with the dinners are delicious. Highly recommend.
We enjoyed everything about our meal. Our server, Sal, was fantastic. He was fun and friendly.
We've been going to Fin over 10 years every winter we're in Marco. The food has gone downhill. Both of our fish entrees were overcooked. I overheard others mention the same. Very disappointing a restaurant that pride itself on fresh fish is not able to cook it properly:(
Swordfish piccata was excellent. Dinner special for the price was not very good. Lobster Mac and cheese was over cooked. Service excellent. Recognized birthday with a treat! Will return.
Our server was awesome. We had food allergies and he made sure we would be able to eat safely. The tuna was the best I'd ever had! It was a great dinner.
Our second dine at Fin Bistro and it proves it is consistently "excellent" over the years. Our party of six was very happy all around. Try the swordfish. It is exceptional!
This was our first(BUT NOT LAST) visit to Fin Bistro after years of staying on Marco Island. The food from the Frito Misto (one of the best we've had) and Charred Octopus appetizers to the Lobster Risotto that I had, as well as the Florida Black Grouper that my wife had was OUTSTANDING. We also ordered a side of their creamed corn which you should not pass up. Our service was impeccable and Steve the manger checked on us twice to ensure we were having a good experience. If you are on or going to Marco Island do not pass up the chance to dine here!!!!!!
Food was exceptional, and our waitress was wonderful. We were not happy with the location of the tables offered. One was looking right into the kitchen and the next one was right next to the exit so there was a lot of traffic. I know someone has to sit there, but I just wish it wasn't me.
Our first visit to Fin Bistro. Derek our server was great in suggesting dishes we try. My husband tried the blackened shrimp pasta and enjoyed it. I tried the Tuna Gremolata which was a great choice suggestion by Derek. The seared tuna was perfect with a nice crispy texture. We will definitely be coming back.
Fin Bistro never disappoints! This is absolutely our favorite restaurant on Marco Island. Peter and his whole staff are wonderful and the food is amazing! Our favorite is the Dorado it's perfect every time. 
Restaurantji Recommends
Our server Jennifer was excellent. Attentive, kind and very on top of everything. We have been longstanding customers of Finn Bistro of 16 years. It's always been our #1 go to spot for a nice dinner and date night. Anticipating it would be the best dinner, we were honestly disappointed in the fish special portion size and the dryness. The scallops were delicious but the mashed potatoes were not my fave. They used to be creamy and delicious like they were pureed. I never eat potatoes but this is the one place I'd try them as they were just really good. If I order scallops every again, I'd ask for a vegetable sub to avoid these potatoes. I had the Bibb salad with goat cheese ball which I love but that portion seemed smaller than usual and for $16 it was not worth it. We understand prices have gone up and it's necessary to adjust them over the years but this has gotten a bit much. We likely won't be returning to our favorite spot because it's just not what it was when the original owner had it. The noise was louder with two four tops seated next to us on either side too.
We have lived on Marco Island for 13 years. Fin Bistro has been my favorite restaurant hands down since the first time we went there. There location changed a few years back but it made no difference...it has been just as good. Whenever we have guests I always make sure we go there at least once while they are here. Halibut last night was excellent. Our waitress also was excellent. I feel bad I don't recall her name BUT she had the black framed glasses and dark hair and served our table of seven and was perfect.
My main complaint is the timing of the service. Our server brought our initial beverages and then disappeared for a half hour, before reappearing to take our food order. The pace was simply too slow. Nor was there much attention to matters like refilling water.
Always the freshest and best fish on Marco Island! The pan seared halibut over risotto in a Dijon cream sauce was to die for! Also the beet salad was delicious.
The coconut shrimp tempura was delicious. Crisp on the outside and tender jumbo shrimp on the inside. My husband had the shrimp and pasta dish which he enjoyed as well. Since it was our 51st Anniversary, they treated us to an outrageous dessert! Wait staff is excellentl.
Loading...