Mr. Bentley's Homemade Ice Cream

I just wish they had a restroom. At the very least a sink to wash hands if you get ice cream on them.

Good ice cream, higher priced compared to nearby locations like other reviews mention. Also good non dairy/vegan options that are actual ice cream and not the typical ice/sorbet.

It was very good, perfect vacation spot late night ice cream. Small local owned place!

I wouldnt know how this place is. Waited in line for 10 min just to get told theres no milk for my shake. Idk what ice cream place dont hold milk. 1 person working so u can enjoy your wait for nothing.

We had some of the best soft serve swirl in a long time.

This place has excellent ice cream, great choices! however I suggest you go earlier in the day if you don't want to wait in line, evenings are very busy

Ice cream was homemade and so creamy and delicious! We loved that they use natural coloring so no artificial food dyes! The blue moon was the best!
Workers were kind and helpful. Portions and pricing were fair for the island. We’ll be back for sure!

Stopped in for the first time last night and the two girls there were excellent 👌 super friendly and nice. The ice cream is divine!! We will be stopping again soon

We went this evening for some ice cream. We met the owner, who was working and he and his staff gave us great service. The ice cream was amazing, from the peanut butter ice cream cone she had and my strawberry cheesecake. Really was exceptional!!! Highly recommend!!!

Mr. Bentley can get it, this is the best ice cream on the island.

Really good peanut butter cookie dough! Had a lot of cookie dough!

Our group was pretty disappointed. The visual size they have out for a small cone was not what we got. It was more like the kid size. My ice cream was good but was melted. Two others didn’t care for theirs and if we knew they didn’t have apple pie like their website said they did, we would have gone down the road. We will not be back.

My child Lebron, he is allergic to every color in the rainbow but orange. We asked this lady’s today very kindly if he could just have orange sprinkles. The lady said “No” in a very mean voice. And also the ice cream tasted terrible it made my child, Lebron face swollen. Unbelievable.

Kid-friendliness: She talked crap to my child.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We absolutely loved the stop here for some delicious ice cream!
I enjoyed the chocolate chip and cookie dough on a sugar cone!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sorry to have to give this a 3-star (probably a 2.5) but all the ice cream was melted, no vanilla, and no softserve available. This is a great location for ice cream, but the price for my small cone (which had to lay in a cup) was not worth it. Head to Annies a minute down the road.