Osteria Capri - Marco Island

We had both a fantastic dining experience and delicious food here recently. The Italian dishes are incredibly authentic, and the entrees are top notch. We also had great service which was attentive but not obtrusive at all. Shout out to the sommelier who was very helpful. Oh yeah, and it has one of the best sunset views available. A hidden gem right off Marco Island.

Made a reservation for a Saturday night through OpenTable like 3 days prior. Arrived and it wasn't even open! WTH??!!!

I made a confirmed dinner reservation for Wednesday, May 14th at 5:00 pm. When we arrrived on time the restaurant was shuttered and closed. I called and left a message but I have received no response.

Good and kind waiters but not great food very messy the bread was just like a white wonder bread and I don’t want to give reviews like this but it was not very good

This is a fantastic Italian restaurant. You cannot get better Italian food in Marco island. I would compare it to a quality restaurant in Rome. Homemade pasta was great. The tagliatelle was as good as I have ever had (reminded me of a restaurant outside of the coliseum in Rome). Not sure why they have some average reviews? Veal chop was great and calamari amazing!

Don't judge this place by the outside. Walk in and everything changes—white tablecloths, folded napkins, and some of the best damn bolognese I've ever had. We came in as a party of eight, and not one person had a single complaint. The menu's stacked, the flavors hit hard, and the service was sharp and on it. They only serve beer and wine, and if you're looking for something non-alcoholic, options are slim. Only knock? The bread. Could use an upgrade. But honestly, when the rest of the meal is this good, who cares?

This place had awesome authentic Italian food! It is an undiscovered gem on the island! You must try it, for sure!

I had a group of 10, everyone having a different dish with the same excellent taste. Chef came out and met the group. Small place with a big taste. You will not be disappointed!!

Food ok. Expensive and noisy. Had to scream at my wife to be heard. Waitress had never heard of Open Table and its food credit. She had to get the manager to finally figure it out. With all the Italian restaurants on Marco Island, this is not one of the better ones!

The noise level was high - we were unable to have a conversation. Linguine with vongole too cooked. Risotto with Astice and shrimps - average - again rice overcooked

Don't let the unassuming exterior fool you. We had an amazing dinner! Food was some of the best Italian we have ever had. Service was excellent. Will definitely be back!

My wife and I live on Marco and just finished dining at Osteria Capri on Marco Island with friends. I think it was our 4th or 5th time. We have never been disappointed. It's the best kept secret restaurant on the island. We consider it one of our favorites.

This small unassuming restaurant has the best chicken Parmesan I have ever had. That is saying a lot. My wife and I judge every Italian restaurant by their chicken Parmesan. This one was as tender as it would possibly be. It came with a side of spaghetti. I tried to swap the spaghetti for another pasta but out waitress said no. I give this restaurant 4* because the waitress was rarely available. We kept having to ask another server or the manager to get us more wine or water. This is the Naples location, not the Marco Island location.

We had a delicious dinner last night, Capresse Salad and the Chef's special, Chilean Bass with lime risotto which was outstanding. Our waiter, Brian was great, attentive and very easy to talk to. We'll be back to try other dishes.

We didi not know what to expect but were very pleasantly surprised. Duo ravioli, Snapper, Veal chop were all excellent as was the plentiful side dish of sautéed vegetables. The prices were a bit higher than expected but overall was very enjoyable. Anna's Service was excellent! My only comment would be to turn the music down a bit.It was very energetic music and a bit loud to have conversation.