Nathan was a terrible server. Seemed bothered we were there. Served us one drink and never returned again to fill waters or ask if we wanted another cocktail or wine. Never saw him after food was served either. Food was mediocre at best. Would recommend for a cocktail for sunset but then leave.
Eleanor
menu limited because it was a Sunday but they never posted that on open table. Had one appetizer which tasted like frozen pizza. Took 45 minutes and food order still not ready. Left the restaurant in disgust! Supposedly a high end restaurant.
Ivy
My wife and I recently celebrated our anniversary at Tesoro, and it was an experience that exceeded every expectation. We chose the restaurant based on the enthusiastic recommendation of a VIP client who praised the food, service, and view—Tesoro delivered on all fronts and then some. From the moment we arrived, the warmth was palpable. The hostess was incredibly hospitable and inviting, offering sincere congratulations on our anniversary and setting a celebratory tone for the evening. We were seated in Sherri's section, and she was the absolute star of the night. Sherri embodies the pinnacle of hospitality and professionalism; her attentiveness, knowledge, and genuine desire to go above and beyond made us feel like honored guests. She was a key part of what made the evening so special. The culinary journey was exceptional. We began with the meatballs and polenta—super fresh and so tender they truly melted in our mouths. For our mains, my wife's Truffle Fettuccine was rich and deeply flavorful, while my Chicken Marsala was a perfect, classic execution. Both were excellent choices. The cocktails were works of art in their presentation, beautifully crafted and enjoyable. The grand finale was the Pistachio Pain De Gêne, which arrived adorned with a "Happy Anniversary" note in chocolate —a thoughtful, personal touch that capped the meal perfectly. It was as delicious as it was meaningful. And then, there's the view. Breathtaking doesn't do it justice. We were treated to a spectacular, picturesque sunset over the water, providing a stunning, romantic backdrop that elevated the entire experience. Tesoro is more than a restaurant; it's a destination for creating core memories. For exceptional cuisine, flawless and heartfelt service, and one of the most beautiful settings in Southwest Florida, look no further. We will absolutely be returning. Thank you, Tesoro, and especially Sherri, for a truly memorable anniversary celebration.
James
We celebrated our anniversary with a perfect tabkevoutsidevto enjoy the sun set. Fibula service
Gary
Our experience was outstanding. Sheri or server was very very good! The food was delicious and very large portions. Of course the setting and sunset was outstanding. Pricing was under $100 for two entrees and two drinks. Very reasonable, we will be back. Thank you for making it the best night we've had on the Island.
Anthony
We did not have a very good experience last evening...the service was uneven at best and the food was not good...The person assisting us would disappear for long periods of time...one time I saw them taking pictures of the sunset...while we waited....The Fig pizza was covered in fig jam...making it very sweet...the pasta while good did not have enough sausage...my wife's seafood dish was dry....We had to wait nearly 15 minutes to get our car...The sunset was beautiful...Would have been good to have heaters outside...
Pablo Antonio Moreno García
How can I explain how nice was the time with you guys, I will comeback soon with more people, and yes we spent a super chilling time, with a nice view and super nice staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marybeth
We really enjoyed our dinner! The view of the sunset while we dined was fantastic and so was the service. We would definitely dine here again!
Victor B
Beautiful rooftop bar with a view. Service was a bit slow at the bar and I opened a tab and walked away front the bar and after the drink came back to the bar to close out and they bartender said they couldn’t find me (we sat down at a table 20 feet away) and already closed my tab (it was the end of the night) and popped a 20% tip on top. Seemed a bit weird and I would have tipped 20% anyway, but it was just an odd way to end the night. VictorB
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ramiro Sosa
Beautiful spot. Although service at the bar was disappointing. Very slow. It was worth it. The biggest problem was we ordered non alcohol prosecco from the menu for my pregnant wife, and they gave us one with alcohol . We noticed when the check came, too late. Bartenders shouldn't mess up like that. And we are 7 months pregnant it's king of obvious even if he didn't hear us. So for that one star. Otherwise it would have been 4.
Outstanding view and a wonderful dining experience! The menu is curated and creative, very tasty seasonal options. It was recommended by a client as a "must go" while visiting Marco Island we were pleased we decided to make a reservation
Ken
ITs an Oceanfront terrace overlooking the Gulf of America. Absolutely stunning views. Food is good, but it is not an extensive menu. Would suggest you review the menu before you go. Make sure you are there for the sunset!
Dan
We had a great time there as we always do. The weather did not allow for outdoors, but the views were still pretty good. The food is great. Our server (Georgianne I think) was excellent. The cocktails were delicious.
Marilyn Joseph
Ambiance was great. Rooftop restaurant with a great view of the beach and sunset. Service was good too, we celebrated my husbands birthday and they gave us a free dessert.
The food was pretty average and overpriced in my opinion. We are vegetarian, options are limited and modifications had to be made. We ordered truffle smashed potatoes which didn't have much truffle taste. Typically smashed potatoes have a crunchy texture to them, these seemed like they were just boiled and weren't baked or fried to get that crispy texture you look for with smashed potatoes. We also got the house green salad, honestly tasted like a salad you get in a bag from a grocery store. Cheese pizza was good but overpriced. The tiramisu tasted like it had been sitting around for days, texture was really soggy.
Service and ambiance would be the main reason I ever go back to Tesoro. The views were great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Annalisa
Beautiful location overlooking the resort and the beach . Food was ok . Service was great , our waiter was very attentive.
Nathan was a terrible server. Seemed bothered we were there. Served us one drink and never returned again to fill waters or ask if we wanted another cocktail or wine. Never saw him after food was served either. Food was mediocre at best. Would recommend for a cocktail for sunset but then leave.
menu limited because it was a Sunday but they never posted that on open table. Had one appetizer which tasted like frozen pizza. Took 45 minutes and food order still not ready. Left the restaurant in disgust! Supposedly a high end restaurant.
My wife and I recently celebrated our anniversary at Tesoro, and it was an experience that exceeded every expectation. We chose the restaurant based on the enthusiastic recommendation of a VIP client who praised the food, service, and view—Tesoro delivered on all fronts and then some. From the moment we arrived, the warmth was palpable. The hostess was incredibly hospitable and inviting, offering sincere congratulations on our anniversary and setting a celebratory tone for the evening. We were seated in Sherri's section, and she was the absolute star of the night. Sherri embodies the pinnacle of hospitality and professionalism; her attentiveness, knowledge, and genuine desire to go above and beyond made us feel like honored guests. She was a key part of what made the evening so special. The culinary journey was exceptional. We began with the meatballs and polenta—super fresh and so tender they truly melted in our mouths. For our mains, my wife's Truffle Fettuccine was rich and deeply flavorful, while my Chicken Marsala was a perfect, classic execution. Both were excellent choices. The cocktails were works of art in their presentation, beautifully crafted and enjoyable. The grand finale was the Pistachio Pain De Gêne, which arrived adorned with a "Happy Anniversary" note in chocolate —a thoughtful, personal touch that capped the meal perfectly. It was as delicious as it was meaningful. And then, there's the view. Breathtaking doesn't do it justice. We were treated to a spectacular, picturesque sunset over the water, providing a stunning, romantic backdrop that elevated the entire experience. Tesoro is more than a restaurant; it's a destination for creating core memories. For exceptional cuisine, flawless and heartfelt service, and one of the most beautiful settings in Southwest Florida, look no further. We will absolutely be returning. Thank you, Tesoro, and especially Sherri, for a truly memorable anniversary celebration.
We celebrated our anniversary with a perfect tabkevoutsidevto enjoy the sun set. Fibula service
Our experience was outstanding. Sheri or server was very very good! The food was delicious and very large portions. Of course the setting and sunset was outstanding. Pricing was under $100 for two entrees and two drinks. Very reasonable, we will be back. Thank you for making it the best night we've had on the Island.
We did not have a very good experience last evening...the service was uneven at best and the food was not good...The person assisting us would disappear for long periods of time...one time I saw them taking pictures of the sunset...while we waited....The Fig pizza was covered in fig jam...making it very sweet...the pasta while good did not have enough sausage...my wife's seafood dish was dry....We had to wait nearly 15 minutes to get our car...The sunset was beautiful...Would have been good to have heaters outside...
How can I explain how nice was the time with you guys, I will comeback soon with more people, and yes we spent a super chilling time, with a nice view and super nice staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We really enjoyed our dinner! The view of the sunset while we dined was fantastic and so was the service. We would definitely dine here again!
Beautiful rooftop bar with a view. Service was a bit slow at the bar and I opened a tab and walked away front the bar and after the drink came back to the bar to close out and they bartender said they couldn’t find me (we sat down at a table 20 feet away) and already closed my tab (it was the end of the night) and popped a 20% tip on top. Seemed a bit weird and I would have tipped 20% anyway, but it was just an odd way to end the night.
VictorB
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Beautiful spot. Although service at the bar was disappointing. Very slow. It was worth it. The biggest problem was we ordered non alcohol prosecco from the menu for my pregnant wife, and they gave us one with alcohol . We noticed when the check came, too late. Bartenders shouldn't mess up like that. And we are 7 months pregnant it's king of obvious even if he didn't hear us. So for that one star. Otherwise it would have been 4.
Restaurantji Recommends
Outstanding view and a wonderful dining experience! The menu is curated and creative, very tasty seasonal options. It was recommended by a client as a "must go" while visiting Marco Island we were pleased we decided to make a reservation
ITs an Oceanfront terrace overlooking the Gulf of America. Absolutely stunning views. Food is good, but it is not an extensive menu. Would suggest you review the menu before you go. Make sure you are there for the sunset!
We had a great time there as we always do. The weather did not allow for outdoors, but the views were still pretty good. The food is great. Our server (Georgianne I think) was excellent. The cocktails were delicious.
Ambiance was great. Rooftop restaurant with a great view of the beach and sunset. Service was good too, we celebrated my husbands birthday and they gave us a free dessert.
The food was pretty average and overpriced in my opinion. We are vegetarian, options are limited and modifications had to be made. We ordered truffle smashed potatoes which didn't have much truffle taste. Typically smashed potatoes have a crunchy texture to them, these seemed like they were just boiled and weren't baked or fried to get that crispy texture you look for with smashed potatoes. We also got the house green salad, honestly tasted like a salad you get in a bag from a grocery store. Cheese pizza was good but overpriced. The tiramisu tasted like it had been sitting around for days, texture was really soggy.
Service and ambiance would be the main reason I ever go back to Tesoro. The views were great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Beautiful location overlooking the resort and the beach . Food was ok . Service was great , our waiter was very attentive.
Loading...