The Oyster Society

The seafood was excellent really fresh and well presented. Those that ordered the oysters said they were best oysters that that thad with a great range of sauces to accompany the oysters. As a fussy vegetarian I was delighted with the food that was prepared. The sprout and pecan salad was delicious and presented beautifully. Our server was fantastic so friendly, professional and knowledgeable- nothing was too much trouble. Great venue great ambiance.

We love The Oyster Society. The food was excellent, our server was very attentive and fun and I was surprised with a delicious birthday dessert. The restaurant is beautiful and they have very interesting and tasty cocktails.

Excellent experience from start to finish. The atmosphere, food, and service were all wonderful. An absolute favorite of ours!

One of the best dinners I have ever had. My wife and I celebrated our wedding anniversary here and I can't say enough good things about this place. I don't normally eat sushi - but their sushi roll was fantastic. My wife had a halibut special with crab and lobster = amazing. I had the potato crusted grouper = amazing. We both love seafood, and this has to be one of the best seafood experiences. Five stars all the way around.

Black walnut old fashioned was delightful! Crunchy salad was refreshing! Tuna was absolutely delicious! Service was great!

Food was not as expected. Check in unfriendly, wait staff was good but too attentive. Too many interruptions and just wanted to get us out.

Check in was not good. People with no charm. Didn't read our reservation request despite have lots of availability in the area we requested. Remedied it somewhat but not totally yet with attitude. No notion to be accommodating. Short kid with dark hair is not, in our opinion, customer facing. Not typically the Carvelli experience.

Fabulous... ambiance, wait staff, food, wine. We will make sure Oyster Society becomes one of our go-to dining plans.

delicious meal, classic environment, very skimpy on the surf in the surf and turf but made up for it with complimentary dessert

Yep, another favorite. Live music on weekends great drinks and food. The drink is a smokey Margarita. A-mazing. Located in a plaza with other places and always tons of people.

The dinner started out great with delicious oysters and sushi roll for starters. The server was trained to upsell and was aggressive in hurrying our experience. He single handedly almost ruined our experience and had a robotic personality. I ordered the Halibut special and unfortunately was not presented well for $48. It was a flattened, boneless fillet with no accompaniment. Very disappointed and bland. The steak and potato encrusted grouper were better choices. The waiter was spotted napping by the corner standing up at one point of the meal. We were a 745pm seating. I would come back for the oysters. Thats all.

We had a good meal, the oyster were fresh..the scampi blue crab and shrimp with linguini were excellent. Also the scallops either black linguini were quite good.

A must if visiting marco island. Great food and atmosphere. Rhea was a great server that made the night even better. If u have a group try to get the private room, game changer.

Great meal, had the tuna, sushi and scallops. Our kids really enjoyed the fine dining atmosphere and the great server we had

Great food, lovely ambiance, and exceptional service from Buse, she truly made our visit special. So happy we came. Thank you!