The Oyster Society

Yep, another favorite. Live music on weekends great drinks and food. The drink is a smokey Margarita. A-mazing. Located in a plaza with other places and always tons of people.

A must if visiting marco island. Great food and atmosphere. Rhea was a great server that made the night even better. If u have a group try to get the private room, game changer.

Great food, lovely ambiance, and exceptional service from Buse, she truly made our visit special. So happy we came. Thank you!

Fantastic experience! Amazing service, atmosphere and food. Highly recommended!

Great restaurant. Food is always amazing. The atmosphere is cool, has kind of an old-fashioned feel, a great spot to even just get a drink, they have great cocktails and the bartenders are awesome. They have live music and outdoor seating, overall a great spot on the island to check out.

The food was good. We ordered the potato encrusted grouper and the sure and turf. The fish was a little under seasoned. The surf and turf was good. Atmosphere was a 5/5. We enjoyed our meal.

Happt Hour! Delicious Blue Point oysters, mussels were great sushi roll fabulous. Pass on the tuna tacos.

Fantastic place! Milos was out server and he was super attentive and made us all laugh. The food was incredible, coconut rice and sea bass 10/10. The drinks and atmosphere were top notch. They also had a live sax player at 8pm. Had I known, I would have booked the later reservation.

Fantastic food and excellent service. Oyster selection is amazing. The grilled shrimp were great. Volcano roll was excellent as well. 100% coming back here again!

Oyster Society is one of my favorite restaurants on Marco Island. That said, tonight's dining experience was less than enjoyable. Several very young children were seated in the dining area that we were in and they screamed Danielle during the in their entire time and the restaurant. Perhaps they could set all the young children together in one area of the restaurant and allow the adults to enjoy a meal in that back area. In addition, our server name was Milos. He was the worst server I have ever experienced there. He did not listen to our orders or anything else we said. He acted aggravated that we wanted an additional drink after we had finished dining. He didn't understand that we wanted to substitute the potatoes that came with our order and charged us for an additional potato side order of the Daphine potatoes. He reached right in front of my face twice to deliver a drink to my friend sitting next to me. He did not follow proper etiquette in serving from the right and removing from the left. Less than expected for a fine dining experience like oyster Society has always been. He said he has worked there seven years and I have been there numerous times and never seen him. I think he needs some training on etiquette listening to customers. He brought our checks and I said I'd like another drink he made his cash out our checks and opened a new account for the additional drinks. Definitely acted like we were bothering him and not leaving fast enough. So disappointed. I was treating another couple to this dinner and when Milos came to the table with the check, we gave him two credit cards to split the bill. When he came back, he asked me if I was Kenneth. As a female clearly, I was not. He then said I thought maybe you were using your husband‘s credit card, he did not realize that my husband passed away recently, which was an upsetting comment. I feel it is disrespectful to assume that because a woman is dining alone her husband is just not with her. !

Meal was outstanding. Buse our waitresses was top notch. Best meal of the entire season. Thank you.

Excellent food and ambiance. Huge wine selection. Potato encrusted grouper very good. Caesar salad was great

5/5 Definitely the best restaurant in Marco island!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Did not have a great experience with their oysters

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Blue Point Oysters

Very good seafood. I had the bass, and was excellent. Portion was a bit smaller than expected, but was still worth it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4